4 ms·
> "It appears all the swans I've seen are white, therefore I posit all swans are white. Oh, wait, there's a black one, nevermind." That's such a tedious way to
by tzs 8y ago
> "It appears all the swans I've seen are white, therefore I posit all swans are white. Oh, wait, there's a black one, nevermind."
That's such a tedious way to to test a theory of swan color. You have to go find swans, which tend to live in hard to reach, dirty, obnoxious environments.
It's much easier to rephrase the hypothesis into a logically exactly equivalent hypothesis, "All non-white things are not swans", and test that instead. I can test that without even leaving my house. Just looking around the room I'm in there are hundreds of non-white things, and none of them are swans.
This situation is called Hempel's paradox, also known as the raven paradox or the paradox of indoor ornithology [1].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raven_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raven_paradox