4 ms·
Nuclear plants are required by law to save up capital as they go for decommissioning themselves. They used to be required to pay into a fund for long-term wast
by DennisP 8y ago
Nuclear plants are required by law to save up capital as they go for decommissioning themselves.
They used to be required to pay into a fund for long-term waste storage, and that fund has about $40 billion now. But after the Yucca Mountain project was shut down, the nuclear operators had to store the waste in concrete enclosures on their own properties, so they went to court saying they shouldn't also have to pay the government to do nothing. In 2013 the courts agreed.
There are actually a lot of companies that want to spend money on R&D and build radical new nuclear designs, including Terrapower, Moltex, Terrestrial Energy, Flibe, Thorcon, Elysium, and many others. In the U.S. the NRC makes this extremely difficult.
A couple years ago I got to sit in a meeting between representatives from about a dozen of these companies and a former head of the NRC. The reactor people said their biggest problem was that the NRC requires a near-complete design before they'll even look at it, and then they give a straight yes or no. If yes you still just have a paper reactor, and if no then you're done. The design process costs several hundred million dollars and you have no idea whether the NRC will let you do anything with it. It's a very difficult environment for investors.
The reactor people said just a more phased process would help a lot. The NRC person dismissed their concerns, said it wasn't the NRC's job to help develop new technology or promote nuclear power, and wasn't interested in climate change.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI can understand that this makes new nuclear development in the US a non-starter. Why is the outlook for nuclear just as abysmal in the UK and China though if their regulators are not as disincentivized to permit innovation?
- godelski 8y agoI don't know about the UK, but China has been building new reactors. In fact, that's what's gotten some reactors to a TRL status where they can build them in America. But from people that I've talked to in the UK, they seem to be more afraid of nuclear than Americans. This seems to be a common trend in Europe. Many people citing radioactive mushrooms from Chernobyl.
- DennisP 8y agoChina has spent over a billion dollars on molten salt reactors, was partnering with Terrapower on a fast reactor project until the Trump administration stopped it, and has a bunch of other GenIV reactor projects in progress. Another bright spot is Canada, whose regulators are much friendlier to reactor R&D. Terrestrial Energy has gotten through the hardest part of their licensing process, and expects to have a demo MSR operating by 2025 or so. Seeing their success, Moltex has moved into Canada as well, after making little progress with UK regulators.