3 ms·
It makes no sense to say that individuals and businesses must offer an open forum for any speech anyone can think of. Would you allow the KKK to hold nightly ra
by chc 16y ago
It makes no sense to say that individuals and businesses must offer an open forum for any speech anyone can think of. Would you allow the KKK to hold nightly rallies in your home? How about Islamic terrorists? Freedom of speech is a requirement for some governments, but private parties are not required to make themselves a platform for anybody else's speech. He didn't offer detractors space in his book, and Amazon is not required to offer him space in their marketplace.
- joelmichael 16y agoComparing nightly KKK rallies to having a book available in stock if you search for it is hardly appropriate. Obviously free speech has its limitations, but absolutely none of those apply here.
- chc 16y agoThey're both examples of private parties offering a platform for free speech. You just disagree when it's your private property they want to use for their platform. And I agree it's a little bit unfair to compare the two: One is a bunch of ignorant people talking about how they don't believe in mating outside their race and the other is a guide to raping children. I don't think the distinction works favor of your argument, though.
- joelmichael 16y agoShould Mein Kampf be sold?
- chc 16y agoYes, and it is.