3 ms·
No, I am not trolling. My initial remark (very early in this thread) was just that the formulation wasn't clear to me. I thought that might trigger a rewording
by Someone 16y ago
No, I am not trolling. My initial remark (very early in this thread) was just that the formulation wasn't clear to me. I thought that might trigger a rewording that would help later readers. After that, I just answered questions about why I found (past tense!) it not clear. I also think I made clear that I do understand the problem:
*Apparently, we must deduce that all boxes get closed between visits from "they will not know anything about the previous prisoners' experiences ahead of time". I am OK with that,*
but I guess I should have been even clearer. It may seem nitpicking, but to solve this, I need two things:
- an understanding of what the problem is.
- a solution to the problem.
I find it natural that, getting stuck at step 2, to revisit step 1, looking for something I missed on reading it first (Quoting Polya: 'What is the unknown? What are the data? What is the condition?'). When I did that, I started to wonder what the description tried to say. Since the trivial answer that I gave in my initial reply, I did get that, but it didn't exactly jump out to me.
Thanks for the polite replies, but let's close this discussion. It is helping neither of us.
[Dmn: initially, I thought "of course the probability is way better than (1/2)^100'. There are only 100! permutations to choose between", but rereading the problem once more I begin to wonder whether 'in which he randomly distributes 100 pieces of paper'* actually implies that each box receives one piece of paper. Please don't reply, or I may feel obliged to apologize again.]