5 ms·
I don't really see why the author thinks this is so funny. While I have no love for giant corporations, I do have a strong distaste for government pushing peop
by freedomben 8y ago
I don't really see why the author thinks this is so funny. While I have no love for giant corporations, I do have a strong distaste for government pushing people around like that. There is nothing more frustrating than having to spend a fortune on lawyers just to deal with the government, rather than adding any value to the product.
I do wonder a bit, if this isn't meant to be a protectionist show move from the EU demonstrating (particularly in the wake of upcoming brexit) that there are benefits to staying in the EU... although I prefer to apply Hanlon's Razor liberally.
- lwansbrough 8y ago> I do have a strong distaste for government pushing people around like that Which people? It’s not like this is a taco truck we’re talking about. Who cares what happens to McDonald’s, honestly?* * Something like 1 in 7 Americans works for McDonald’s at some point in their life, which is at least interesting if nothing else.
- isostatic 8y ago> * Something like 1 in 7 Americans works for McDonald’s at some point in their life, which is at least interesting if nothing else. And if Mcdonalds didn't exist, people would buy from Burger King, which would have more stores, and employ those 1 in 7 americans
- emiliobumachar 8y agoMcD was definitely not minding its own business when the government suddenly showed up. From https://m.independent.ie/business/irish/its-like-connacht-winning-against-the-all-blacks-supermacs-ceo-responds-to-big-mac-trademark-success-against-mcdonalds-37713005.html https://m.independent.ie/business/irish/its-like-connacht-wi... : McDonald’s previously hit Supermacs with a 41-page objection against its plans to use the Supermac’s name in Europe stating that it would "take unfair advantage of the distinctive character and repute" of trademarks previous won by the global restaurant giant. The US firm partly based its objection on already secured trademarks for its products such as the ‘Big Mac’ and ‘Chicken McNuggets’, claiming introducing Supermac’s into the market would cause confusion.
- eridius 8y agoIf McDonald's genuinely thought Supermac's expansion would cause customer confusion, then they're not only right to challenge it but they have a duty to challenge it in order to protect their trademark.
- jacobolus 8y agoMcDonald’s is famous for trying to sue a Scottish woman who started a sandwich shop in England called McMunchies, claiming that they owned any use of “Mc” to refer to food. Along with various other small clearly unrelated businesses with Irish/Scottish owners. Which brought Lord Godfrey MacDonald, of Clan MacDonald, down on them (“I am The MacDonald”).
- Lio 8y agoThere’s something particularly egregious about large corporations trying trademark widely used generic words or terms. Such behaviour is prohibited most places. That these companies try intimidating people with spurious law suits makes it easy to dislike them. My own personal favourite is a dodgy gym eqipment company which has been recently bullying various blogers for using the generic term for a group of cyclists, peloton. They can’t have the word it belongs to common language. It’s crazy. It’s like if McDonalds tried to trademark “hamburger” and then threatened to sue people who live in Hamburg.
- jayalpha 8y agoIf I remember correctly, Disney has a trademark for "snow-white".
- kingofhdds 8y agoProtection of a generic word within particular context may be absolutely fair. Say, you made an OS, and called it "Pretzel". You can't go, and prohibit anyone to call their pretzels pretzels, but if some big corpo Shmoogle will create their own product called Pretzel OS, I'm pretty sure you'll be not ok with it. "Mc" is no different, if applied narrowly to burgers there's no reason why it can't be copyrighted, because within the context it's not in fact a generic term. Crazy behavior of copyright lawyers is a problem for sure, but a separate one.
- pgeorgi 8y ago> I do have a strong distaste for government pushing people around like that. Since trademarks are an artificial monopoly erected by the government, they exist to push people around. So would the solution be no trademarks? If so, any step that devalues the concept of trademarks (because they're considered unreliable) should be a positive, no?
- dnautics 8y agoI'm pretty low on IP in general but trademarks do serve a useful purpose: namespaces are rivalrous so it makes sense that the government be able to say, hey, you can't start selling low grade big Macs in your town and potentially give McDonald's a bad name.
- isostatic 8y agoIt's not about "giving mcdonalds a bad name", it's about protecting me from buying what I think is mcdonalds (for some reason), but actually being sold something else. As Pirate Party say: "Trademarks are okay as long as they protect consumers from fraud, etc, but never okay when they punish consumers." They're similar to rules protecting origin. If I buy Feta, it's guaranteed to come from Greece. This protects me. Nothing stops me from buying "greek style cheese", which comes from Italy, I have informed choice.
- freedomben 8y agoVery interesting question, thank you! Requires some thought, and I'm still evaluating it. Some initial thoughts are, that I tend to agree with you. On the one hand, I think the pragmatist view would be that society is benefited (through disambiguation of source, quality, etc. On the other hand, to equitably codify such a subjective mechanism (e.g. does it cause confusion in reasonable consumers?) is nearly impossible, and rather than risk unjust vertical empowerment of one entity (government) over another (citizen), I think I'd rather just not do it all (which is to your point). Like many things, I suppose it comes down to questions of philosophical purity (and therefore morality) vs. pragmatic positions. I see myself as more of a purist than a pragmatist these days, but that may just be my natural inclination toward non-conformity (and all the governments I can think of are heavily tilted toward the pragmatic side).