9 ms·
European Union has canceled McDonald’s trademark for Big Macs
- Someone1234 8y agoThis article is a bad faith attempt at reporting this story. Here's a previous hacker news thread which links to a less inflammatory article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18914054 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18914054
- freedomben 8y agoThanks for the link. There is a good comment there from purple_ducks: > What's more ridiculous is McDonalds trademarked the name of a competitors (arguably) flagship product - which they(McD) never used: That definitely doesn't give an impression of a McDonalds who is acting in good faith. Not that that justifies the EU (two wrongs don't make a right or something like that), but it does make McDs a little less of a sympathetic figure.
- lisper 8y agoTo be fair, the article does note this in the second to last paragraph: "McDonald’s ... had also been applying for trademarks on Supermac’s menu items." But this was not intended to be a "fair and balanced" article, it was intended to focus on a particular aspect of the story.
- freedomben 8y agoThanks, my bad, I totally missed that when I read the article.
- lisper 8y agoNo worries, it was pretty well buried. Easy to miss.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- freedomben 8y agoI don't really see why the author thinks this is so funny. While I have no love for giant corporations, I do have a strong distaste for government pushing people around like that. There is nothing more frustrating than having to spend a fortune on lawyers just to deal with the government, rather than adding any value to the product. I do wonder a bit, if this isn't meant to be a protectionist show move from the EU demonstrating (particularly in the wake of upcoming brexit) that there are benefits to staying in the EU... although I prefer to apply Hanlon's Razor liberally.
- lwansbrough 8y ago> I do have a strong distaste for government pushing people around like that Which people? It’s not like this is a taco truck we’re talking about. Who cares what happens to McDonald’s, honestly?* * Something like 1 in 7 Americans works for McDonald’s at some point in their life, which is at least interesting if nothing else.
- isostatic 8y ago> * Something like 1 in 7 Americans works for McDonald’s at some point in their life, which is at least interesting if nothing else. And if Mcdonalds didn't exist, people would buy from Burger King, which would have more stores, and employ those 1 in 7 americans
- emiliobumachar 8y agoMcD was definitely not minding its own business when the government suddenly showed up. From https://m.independent.ie/business/irish/its-like-connacht-winning-against-the-all-blacks-supermacs-ceo-responds-to-big-mac-trademark-success-against-mcdonalds-37713005.html https://m.independent.ie/business/irish/its-like-connacht-wi... : McDonald’s previously hit Supermacs with a 41-page objection against its plans to use the Supermac’s name in Europe stating that it would "take unfair advantage of the distinctive character and repute" of trademarks previous won by the global restaurant giant. The US firm partly based its objection on already secured trademarks for its products such as the ‘Big Mac’ and ‘Chicken McNuggets’, claiming introducing Supermac’s into the market would cause confusion.
- emiliobumachar 8y ago" In other words, it doesn’t even matter if everyone knows that McDonald’s sells burgers called Big Macs: There are ways to prove it, and McDonald’s didn’t bother. Don’t tell us, show us. There are rules, Ronald, and you will follow them." I can see the logic behind that. If Uncle Bill's Bait Shop's printout is not good enough, should McDonald's menu be?
- sjwright 8y agoI can't see the logic. McDonald's submitted multiple affidavits, brochures, menus, packaging and actual sales figures. What else could they possibly do to prove a trademark is being used? If that's not enough to prove the use of a trademark, then the value of registering a trademark in Europe has plummeted to zero.
- tlamponi 8y agoThey "show me that you use it" wasn't only for bigmac, it was also for trademarks they did not used but: > "trademark bullying; registering brand names... which are simply stored away in a war chest to use against future competitors". https://www.independent.ie/business/irish/its-like-connacht-winning-against-the-all-blacks-supermacs-ceo-responds-to-big-mac-trademark-success-against-mcdonalds-37713005.html https://www.independent.ie/business/irish/its-like-connacht-...
- sjwright 8y agoThat's right, but here we're talking about the trademark for Big Mac. I'm pretty sure they're using that one.
- TrolTure 8y agoI think they require some 'independent' source of information, like news articles. I'm quite surprised by the comments on this article. McDonald's didn't present their case properly while that should have been easy. Seems the onus is on them, regardless they still have their appeal.
- slededit 8y agoThis ruling doesn't inspire a lot of confidence in fair treatment for foreign companies in Europe. Its one thing if this was a default judgement because McDonald's was boycotting the proceedings, but they filed a good faith response. If McDonald's is a bullying litigant - there are ways to deal with it that don't bring the court itself into disrepute.
- pergadad 8y agoIn the contrary, it shows that both big and small companies are treated equally. What would not have been enough for a less known company was also not enough for Mcdonald's, shcih simply didn't make the effort to submit outside evidence. The judgement was a bit legalistic in so far as common sense would have said 'obviously McD sells Big Macs' but it's simply that they didn't submit the right kind of evifencr. From other articles McD seemingly was acting like a trademark bully in registering it's competitors' product names - meaning they (presumably less known outside Ireland) had to provide objective evidence. It's only right that the burden of proof is applied equally to all, McD shot itself in the foot, first in causing this issuey first by filing frivolous trademarks and trying to block a competitors entering the markety causing the whole process, and then by not making the effort to submit the right kind of evidence. No one else is to blame and this is a huge e endorsement of the fairness of the EU trademark system. They can appeal so it will all be a non-story in a while.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoWhy do you assume the problem is with the EU and not with McDonald’s? The people who judge the matter have clear rules to follow, rules that McDonald’s lawyers are intimately familiar with. And yet they messed up. Is it some grand conspiracy against foreign companies or an arrogant multinational that is used to rules not mattering to them?
- rgbrenner 8y agoEUIPO says McDonalds didn't prove they sold bigmacs in europe... The decision says Mcdonalds submitted 3 affidavits, brochures, menus, packaging, and SALES FIGURES of Big Macs in Europe... and the EUIPO said they don't believe any of it. Bizarre. If actual sales aren't evidence of use, how do you prove this? If I had a trademark in europe, I would be worried. This has to be overturned on appeal. https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Big-Mac-euipo.pdf https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Bi...
- crooked-v 8y ago> If I had a trademark in europe, I would be worried. Especially given that the final resort of "walk into a store and buy one and present it to a judge" is impossible for, say, enterprise software shops that build nominally custom variations of their product for each client.
- lovich 8y agoShould you have a trademark that prevents anyone else from using the name because you made a custom one off for a single customer?
- crooked-v 8y agoIf you're producing variations of Wibbleworths Customer Management System for a variety of clients and marketing them all under the Wibbleworths brand, that's absolutely something that should be trademarkable.
- pgeorgi 8y agoThat wouldn't work for a court case in 2018 that covers the 2012-2017 time frame anyway.
- JackuB 8y agoThey haven’t submited any actual sales figures: > They claimed significant sales figures in relation to ‘Big Mac’ sandwiches
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- BuckRogers 8y agoI have no opinion on Brexit, but I imagine this will shift more corporate resources out of the EU and into the UK. For the stability aspect alone. Business tends to hate uncertainty as do investors and this seems rather insane.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoNo it wont. Because you don’t understand the issue, you didn’t bother reading what happened. You just came here to shit on the EU for no reason but your own biases which you thought you saw confirmed in the headline. What happened is something that is actually causing stability because a huge multinational was prevented from bullying a new upstart company.
- repolfx 8y agoNo, OP is right. This isn't stability. By "stability" people mean government decisions are predictable and make sense, not that tiny EU companies can create big problems for major corporations by exploiting the bureaucracy. What will CEOs of large American companies think when looking at this ruling? They will think the following: "Everyone knows McDonalds makes a product called Big Mac. It's their primary burger product and has been a stable brand for decades. Europeans know this. I've been to Europe and eaten a Big Mac myself. Their usage of this brand should not have been in question to start with. Why was it in dispute? Then their lawyers submitted lots of documentation to satisfy the bureaucratic box tickers, and apparently that still wasn't enough. If a brand as big as McDonalds can't successfully keep their primary product trademarked in the EU, what chance do I have? Maybe I'll think twice before prioritising these markets."
- BuckRogers 8y agoBoth FranzFerdiNaN and phatfish below weren't able to infer or comprehend what form of stability I was referring to. It's absolutely laughable, outright, to consider that I meant the EU or the nations that it consists of are "unstable". I don't care about the UK or EU, this is just an objective analysis of business realities. It's the political expectations that matter. Threatening something as known as the Big Mac is begging for even worse parasitical behavior on the behalf of corporations. It's not going to encourage any investment into EU boundaries, other than what's required to siphon money out. It's the same thing as Trump disrupting trade arrangements with China. There's nothing offensive or aggressive about these observations unless the reader is defensive and has a bone to pick on their part.
- JackuB 8y agoSo I went in an read the actual ruling document https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Big-Mac-euipo.pdf https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Bi... (only 8 pages) and it pretty much made sense for me (IANAL ofc). McD’s lawyers screwed up, not submitting required evidence of actual use in years 2011-2016. They printed out webpages with promo materials and a wikipedia page (as article correctly points, “duh, we are McDonalds”) - not a great proof of anything for any court. Then submitted some packaging of the product. Not any evidence that the product was actually sold and trademark used in those five years - no sales figures, website traffic stats… As said, makes sense to me Edit: that said, still makes no sense why were they challenging the use of Big Mac in the first place… shrugs
- Svip 8y agoNewspaper articles talking about Big Macs would also have helped. And if you are unwilling to release sales figures or website traffic statistics, newspaper articles are a decent alternative option.
- mattmanser 8y agoThe Irish firm has 'mac' in their name. Supermac’s said it can now expand in the United Kingdom and Europe. It said it had never had a product called “Big Mac” but that McDonald’s had used the similarity of the two names to block the Irish chain’s expansion. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-mcdonald-s-corp-trademark-supermacs/mcdonalds-loses-big-mac-trademark-case-to-irish-chain-supermacs-idUSKCN1P92JA https://www.reuters.com/article/us-mcdonald-s-corp-trademark... From the other articles I've seen about this the implication is that the judgement was probably heavily influenced by McDonald's own anti-competitive shenanigans of trademarking names of competitors products: The US chain had also trademarked the term “SnackBox,” an offering by Supermac's that McDonald’s does not offer. https://www.irishcentral.com/culture/food-drink/supermacs-mcdonalds-big-mac-trademark https://www.irishcentral.com/culture/food-drink/supermacs-mc...
- philliphaydon 8y agoAh I initially got confused because I thought supermac was some bigger Big Mac I had not heard of and went to Google. Disappointed now.
- pergadad 8y agoHere's a better link from a collective of European IP lawyers. The point is that McDonald's was assuming it would be treated differently than any smaller company, and also that the Big Mac trademark might have been too broad to begin with, but this was not the decisive factor. http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/2019/01/euipo-cancels-mcdonalds-big-mac-trade.html?m=1 http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/2019/01/euipo-cancels-mcdonalds...
- znpy 8y agoOTOH, you you are irish and your surname is McSomething (which naturally reads as "mac-something") then you should be free to use that as branding. It's literally who you are and who yo've been your whole life, and your ancestors before you. Which is basically what McDonald's creators did.
- djaychela 8y agoAm I the only person who sees privacy pages on sites like this - where they say 'accept our conditions and cookies' and there seems to quick way to make settings that you're happy with - and then presses the back button, adding that domain to an internal list of sites I won't visit again? Any time I see any Oath-owned domain, I know that it'll be difficult/impossible to set what I want, so I don't even bother any more.
- isostatic 8y agoNo, you're not the only one
- dmitriid 8y agoYup. Same here. I ended up reading comments on HN to see what the article was about. Under GDPR Slate's privacy banner is probably illegal, by the way, because it doesn't provide a way to opt-out.
- BerislavLopac 8y ago> I ended up reading comments on HN to see what the article was about. I always do this first.
- ErockSteady 8y agoLiterally zero chance of this not being reversed on appeal.