3 ms·
>> Eh, they can't prove who is or is not a call girl. They have blunt tools at their disposal for trying to "crack down" on this, such as saying "Hookers typica
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> Eh, they can't prove who is or is not a call girl. They have blunt tools at their disposal for trying to "crack down" on this, such as saying "Hookers typically sit alone at the bar. So no more single women sitting alone at the bar."
If you want to be rational about it, the information you need to make a decision is not limited to how many hookers sit alone at a bar, but also how many hookers there are in the general population. If that number is low, then you have no good reason to assume that a woman sitting alone at a bar is a hooker, and therefore no good reason to stop women from sitting alone at a bar.
That's Baye's rule, right? What's the probability that a woman is a hooker given that she's sitting alone at the bar? It's the probability that a woman will be sitting alone at a bar given that she's a hooker, weighted by the probability that any woman is a hooker, normalised by the probability any woman will sit alone at a bar.
Nerds should know those things, if nothing else, to avoid many awkward conversations: "Why do you want to know how much my spaghetti carbonara cost?".
- james_s_tayler 8y agoAh but with Bayes Rule if you don't know the statistics you take the starting prior as 50/50 in which case "she might be or she might not".
- DoreenMichele 8y agoAs a woman who frequently eats alone in restaurants, I can tell you it is fairly aberrant behavior. Men eat alone. Old men frequently eat alone. Women are almost always with someone, whether children, gal pals or a romantic interest. I only noticed that it's odd and began paying attention to other women in eating establishments because I was getting weird reactions from people. /Anecdata to feed your hypothetical algorithm
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoThe strongest effect on confidence should come from the prevalence of hookers in the general population. Indeed, the normalising effect of women sitting alone at bars can be omitted.
- dsajames 8y agoDo you find anything consistent among these women who eat alone? Age, how busy/rushed they appear, how tough they appear, etc? Would you guess they are single with few friends in the area? Perhaps they mostly just have more confidence in going out alone.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThe pattern I noticed was that my behavior of eating alone in public as a woman was, in fact, unusual as other people seemed to think. I haven't noticed enough other women eating alone to notice any patterns concerning characteristics of women who eat alone. It really seems rather rare and my interest in the phenomenon was limited in scope to wondering why it got such weird reactions from other people and paying enough attention to verify that, yea, verily, it's genuinely unusual. People aren't merely making that part up. I didn't pay attention beyond that. It's not some formal study with records, etc.