5 ms·
Eh, they can't prove who is or is not a call girl. They have blunt tools at their disposal for trying to "crack down" on this, such as saying "Hookers typically
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
Eh, they can't prove who is or is not a call girl. They have blunt tools at their disposal for trying to "crack down" on this, such as saying "Hookers typically sit alone at the bar. So no more single women sitting alone at the bar."
I'm not saying it's fair. I'm just saying they may have valid reasons for the policy of cracking down on sex workers and they don't need to have actually mistaken her for a sex worker per se to decide this policy applies to her.
- empath75 8y agoIt’s blatant sex discrimination.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSo are many legal definitions of rape. Many legal definitions of rape are framed such that rape is a crime only a man can commit and only a woman can be victimized by. I've already allowed as how it isn't fair. Is there some greater point here?
- vidarh 8y agoThe difference is that you're presumably not excusing those legal definitions, but you come across as trying to excuse and justify this discrimination when you write: > I'm just saying they may have valid reasons for the policy without any caveat about how this policy was applied only to women. I don't know if it was your intent to come across that way or not, but that is how I read it.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThe title of the piece is "The night I was mistaken for a call girl." It's basically a click bait title. She may not have been mistaken for a call girl. She may have simply been caught by a policy designed to address the issue, however ham-handedly. The conclusion that she was actually mistaken for a call girl seems shaky. I did give a proviso that I wasn't saying it was fair. So I don't know where you are getting this idea that I'm justifying sexism.
- vidarh 8y agoI was not responding to the title. I was responding to your question as to whether the person replying to you by pointing out it is blatant sex discrimination had some greater point. That she was "simply been caught by a policy designed to address the issue" is pretty clear. The issue is that this policy is discriminatory. And in a way that would fall foul of sex discrimination laws a whole lot of places. > So I don't know where you are getting this idea that I'm justifying sexism. You suggested they may have valid reasons for a discriminatory policy. To me that reads like a pretty clear cut justification. If you don't think that's a valid reason for discriminating after all, then my apologies.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoNo, I suggested they may have valid reasons to want to crack down an a specific type of criminal activity occurring on their premises. In this case, sex work. Sex work happens to typically be done by women more than men. I've never been to a restaurant that didn't have a sign posted saying "We reserve the right to refuse service." Given that general policy, they may have been cutting her slack to let her eat there. While homeless, I spent a lot of time in public spaces. Most of them have policies that pets are not allowed, but service animals are. Most homeless people with pets claimed they were service animals. Establishments were generally legally barred from asking for proof. No policy is foolproof. There will always be exceptions to any rule and they routinely complain loudly about it, often while not having either sympathy for the very real problems involved nor a better solution. That doesn't mean I'm justifying sexism. I'm a writer. I was primarily critiquing the click bait title, insufficient evidence that they actually believed her to be a call girl and poor construction of the piece. But I'll drop it. It's late. I'm tired. Whatever.
- Retric 8y agoPosting a sign does not allow you to break the law with impunity. Clearly they can kick everyone out, less clearly can they target one person.
- 8y ago
- manquer 8y agoNot surprised you are down-voted, there is very little if any sensitivity to sexual harassment or crimes against men.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI also failed to state up front "I happen to be a woman." A lot of people here know that, but it's a big forum and mostly male. People routinely assume I must be male, and thus a misogynistic sexist pig, if I say anything pro male on such subjects. Sometimes, I prefave it to try to avoid that. Sometimes, I don't. This time, I didn't. (shrug)
- throwaway-hn123 8y agoBelieve me, everyone knows. Everyone knows what a tough life you've had, how people on HN aren't fair because they don't give you work, etc etc etc etc yawns
- manquer 8y agoI already knew that from earlier your comment below . It does not and should never matter what your gender is, the points you talked stand on their own right.
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoSo there's a strong correlation with being female and being a sex worker, as opposed to male. Now replace the correlation with other undesirable traits, like being a thief and having a certain skin colour. Do you still call that a 'blunt tool to crack down on issues that don't necessarily apply to each individual' or can we just call that racial discrimination and agree no such tools should be applied? The idea it's okay for your daughter, wife, mother etc to be denied a seat, where you can sit alone, because she's a priori categorised as a sex worker merely because of gender, is pretty insane to me. Of course your personal relationship shouldn't matter, but maybe it hits home a little bit more like this. The whole idea about discrimination is that people are judged not on the basis of their own behaviour, but the behaviour (or stereotypical views of such) of a group they (often involuntarily) belong to. And that's inherently unfair. Instead we should always try to make a fair assessment of the individual. Of course we use mental shortcuts that can be discriminatory, but we always have to try and allow recourse. That's why a 60 year old tends not to be hired as a security guard, because they lack the fitness. That tends to be viewed as reasonable age discrimination, but only in the context of explaining the underlying assumption, that age determines fitness, and that this assumption is not challenged by the applicant. But if the 60 year old can demonstrate sufficient fitness and challenges the assumption, denying the job based on age is no longer lawful. In short, the assumption must be reasonable, must be made clear, and must not be challenged. I can imagine the owner's worry, and that he profiled her based on mental shortcuts. But if she then demonstrates she is not a sex worker, denying her a seat anyway is silly. Let's not forget, she came there for years. If she came with colleagues, she'd leave with them. If she came alone, she'd leave alone. She never engaged anyone else. The first thing you'd do is have an honest conversation and see if your assumptions are even correct in the first place. In this case they went straight to applying a policy based on a wrongful assumption, and then denied any recourse or apologies once they were given ample indications to be incorrect in their assumptions. In this case, the assumption was made, was somewhat unreasonable given her familiarity with the staff (knowing faces, names), was not made clear initially, and was not allowed to be challenged. That's sex discrimination, a case handled incorrectly and it's not ok.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThat's reading an awful lot into my comment that's not actually there. It's a click bait title. She may not have been mistaken for a call girl. The anecdote is told to try to introduce opinions about how the death by a thousand cuts is a larger problem than actual sexual assault. The piece isn't that well written overall. I realize and stated in my very first comment that it isn't fair. Assertions that I'm saying sexism is totes fine seem wildly out of line to my mind.
- coldtea 8y agoSure, and blacks commit more homicides per capita, so perhaps they should have them segregated at the restaurant and other establishments. /s
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoRecall the problem with rapists in India. The govt wanted a curfew on women. The PM suggested "Its men doing the raping; lets have a curfew on men". So the sensible approach here is, to ban men from bars. Doesn't sound so reasonable now, does it?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoAnd if a man wrote an article about visiting India and how this curfew was applied to him and titled it "The night I was mistaken for a rapist" and I said "Eh, they may not have actually thought he was a rapist. It was a policy applied to all men." I seriously doubt I would have so very many people pile on to wildly twist that nitpick into "So, why are you so strongly pro sexism?" or some nonsense.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoThe point is, its unreasonable to restrict rights to make it convenient for policing. We both know, there would be outrage if men were so profiled (by restricting their rights wholesale). To ignore this part of the issue is disingenuous.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoDiscussion elsewhere in this thread doesn't corroborate your assertion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18946801 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18946801 I also wasn't at any point suggesting it was okay. I posted several clarifications concerning that detail while new comments to the same effect continued to pour in, some of them snarky one liners. I don't know what's going on here, but it's probably not what you and others are claiming is going on.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI guess its the skating by the 'restrict women's activity because {plausible enforcement reason}' that's sensitive. So often somebody casually reducing women's activities for 'good reason' that some can't let it slide any more. The 'handmaids tale' kind of thing. Remember women couldn't buy property back in the 1970's, for plausible reasons (most didn't have jobs so no cash flow). Its that fresh in some folks' minds.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> Eh, they can't prove who is or is not a call girl. They have blunt tools at their disposal for trying to "crack down" on this, such as saying "Hookers typically sit alone at the bar. So no more single women sitting alone at the bar." If you want to be rational about it, the information you need to make a decision is not limited to how many hookers sit alone at a bar, but also how many hookers there are in the general population. If that number is low, then you have no good reason to assume that a woman sitting alone at a bar is a hooker, and therefore no good reason to stop women from sitting alone at a bar. That's Baye's rule, right? What's the probability that a woman is a hooker given that she's sitting alone at the bar? It's the probability that a woman will be sitting alone at a bar given that she's a hooker, weighted by the probability that any woman is a hooker, normalised by the probability any woman will sit alone at a bar. Nerds should know those things, if nothing else, to avoid many awkward conversations: "Why do you want to know how much my spaghetti carbonara cost?".
- james_s_tayler 8y agoAh but with Bayes Rule if you don't know the statistics you take the starting prior as 50/50 in which case "she might be or she might not".
- DoreenMichele 8y agoAs a woman who frequently eats alone in restaurants, I can tell you it is fairly aberrant behavior. Men eat alone. Old men frequently eat alone. Women are almost always with someone, whether children, gal pals or a romantic interest. I only noticed that it's odd and began paying attention to other women in eating establishments because I was getting weird reactions from people. /Anecdata to feed your hypothetical algorithm
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoThe strongest effect on confidence should come from the prevalence of hookers in the general population. Indeed, the normalising effect of women sitting alone at bars can be omitted.
- 8y ago
- james_s_tayler 8y agoAlso you can't just ask someone "are you a sex worker?" and get a straight answer as you'll notice people who indeed are the thing you accuse them of feign incredulity as a tactic to camouflage themselves and make you doubt yourself. I noticed this watching a lot of those hidden camera shows with dodgy repair men. They know they are indeed crooked but get all in your face "are you accusing me of being a liar? That's outrageous!". Life is impossible.