6 ms·
I've seen terrible logic errors in biology models as well. It just tends to be drama when I talk about those examples. I have a form of cystic fibrosis. Accord
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I've seen terrible logic errors in biology models as well. It just tends to be drama when I talk about those examples.
I have a form of cystic fibrosis. According to the CF Foundation website (last I looked), my body overproduces mucus and I am drowning in my own mucus and this is why lung clearance methods are prescribed.
I have seen exactly one study that concluded that people with CF actually underproduce mucus. This study makes more logical sense and fits with my first-hand experience that I'm sicker and cough more when my sinuses are too dry. I have more lung issues on days where my sinuses appear to have too little mucus, not too much.
It's more logical because mucus plays a critical role in the immune system in keeping out invaders and people with CF are chronically ill and infected due to a terribly compromised immune system.
I've seen at least two discussions on the internet where women with CF complained about vaginal dryness ruining their sex life. I have yet to see a woman with CF claim she left a mucus trail behind her like a giant garden slug and could comfortably have sex with ten men a day because she's just soaked all the time.
Yet, women with CF also complain of vaginal "goopiness."
Logically, the vaginal goopiness and the gunk filling the lungs of people with CF are both some form of phlegm or pus, not the body overproducing mucus. But that's not what the medical literature states. The medical literature illogically claims that I am merely overproducing mucus and drowning in my own mucus.
I'm getting well when the world says this can't be done, ergo my mental models are probably more accurate than the medical literature.
But I'm a former homemaker, so I am routinely told I'm crazy and making all of that up.
Whether you are talking racism or biology, our mental models for how it works shape outcomes. Weirdly, people seem to often think this is not true for biology.
- darkerside 8y agoSad that this is getting down voted. Science is wonderful, and it's behind many incredible breakthroughs in modern technology, obviously. But in my book, logic beats science every time. You can point to all the studies in the world, but if they conflict with my own literal experience, I am going to be at the very least skeptical of the science.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThank you. I wish people would actually engage me on the logic rather than acting like I must be crazy and making things up while they pretend such assumptions aren't some form of prejudice. I'm starved for actual meaty engagement on such subjects. Like explain to me why you think I'm wrong instead of telling me I hallucinated my entire life and if I really do have CF and I really am getting well, it's 18 years of placebo effect and I couldn't possibly know what I'm talking about. Fear me. I can apparently hallucinate my body into better health. Up next: Darth Vader Force chokehold, clearly.
- hkeide 8y agoYou’re very articulate and it all makes sense. Science is about building better models and explanations of things which can be observed. It’s not about simple hypothesis testing. Read The Beginning of Infinity by David Deutsch if you’re interested in this subject. Please ignore the anonymous HN dilettantes.
- darkerside 8y agoReading other replies to your original post is alternately enlightening and incredibly frustrating. So much armchair crap from people who have clearly never encountered anything outside of established science and so refuse to believe that anything outside of established science can exist! As if established science were somehow virgin birthed into existence, and not built upon centuries of painstaking observation and analysis. Especially considering your form of CF is atypical, you'd think researchers would be tremendously interested in identifying a possibly conflated disease that presents with the same symptoms.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIt's definitely very frustrating. In the good news column, this discussion is the most meaty engagement I've ever gotten and I'm generally pleased with this unexpected turn of events. I think the most charitable reading I can give is that when I was much sicker, I tended to do a poor job of trying to present my case and "you never get a second chance to make a first impression." Hopefully the silver lining is that some people will recognize how much my writing has improved over time and will see my past typo-filled and often not very coherent posts as compared to later ones as evidence that my claim that I was very sick at one time and I've gotten healthier holds water and makes sense, even without ever meeting me in person.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoI wouldn’t dismiss your claims, but I’d have some questions. First, have you had genetic testing to confirm that you have CF? If so, then that completely rules out a misdiagnoses of something presenting with a similar set of symptoms. Second I’d be curious what form of the disease you have, since that make make your experience different from someone elses’. Concerns I’d have with accepting your theory about CF as it applies to people other than yourself (I’m not doubting your own experience) is that mucus and pus are fundamentally different, and this has been studied. For example one area of study is using various drugs to break down a key component of mucous called mucins, and this is based on assays of CF mucus. You would expect pus to be composed primarily of dead tissue and immune cells, especially neutrophils. No one is going to mistake a slide of pus and a slide of mucus, and no one will mistake a spectrograph of the two either. In support of your idea is that the genetic basis for CF is known and can be replicated in tests, and the pathological mechanism involving over absorbing calcium and sodium ions is also known and reproduced. BUT... it’s also known that overproduction of mucus is not related directly to CFTR! What that means is that the observed overproduction is a secondary result of the underlying condition. That leaves room for the literature to be correct (probably) without accounting for all expressions of the disease. In other words you could be right, and so could the researchers and doctors. One thing that occurs to me is that a thicker mucus as expected with CF might still create the perception of dryness. Accumulations or blockages resulting from it would be the result of overproduction, but still lead to poor “delivery on target” so to speak. It doesn’t help if one’s vagina is effectively dry because instead of producting a slippery material, an overly viscous substance is produced. Maybe in some people the net result is a lack of mucus where it needs to be, spread around, and resulting infections. It could be that the prognosis for people with a form less associated with overproduction also leads to a better prognosis, because it’s fundamentally an easier problem to solve than other forms or expressions. It’s an interesting idea, although I’m sorry that you have to live with it.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThank you. First, have you have genetic testing to confirm that you have CF? Unfortunately, no. I have had two or three blood tests that indicate I do not have any of the 100 most common alleles. Last I checked, there were 1600 known alleles. My insurance denied my CF specialist's request for a more comprehensive (and expensive) test from Stanford. I was diagnosed with atypical cystic fibrosis at age 35 based on sweat chloride results and medical history. My sweat chloride results were 41, as were my oldest son's. My understanding is that historically, below 40 was normal and above 80 was CF. The numbers in between were an undefined grey zone. At some point, they decided that this grey zone was a milder form of CF. At the time that I was diagnosed, the life expectancy for CF was 36. I was diagnosed just before I turned 36. So logically I shouldn't have any of the more common alleles. Those alleles really should result in a case of classical CF and have a more severe presentation. My best understanding is that I have the same pattern of issues as classical CF, just less severe. The lessened severity combined with a late diagnosis meant I had my own mental models for what was going on with my health and allowed me to question what doctors were telling me. Because CF is so deadly, most people with a diagnosis are terrified of questioning what they are told. I stopped participating on CF lists because they aren't places you can have a meaningful discussion of the science. I've talked to a guy with a PhD in chemistry and a guy with a PhD in biology to help me understand a few things about how CF functions at the cellular level without having to deal with histrionics and hatred from people terrified of questioning the current mental models. One thing that occurs to me is that a thicker mucus as expected with CF might still create the perception of dryness. Mucus is supposed to be slippery. You can have thicker mucus from being dehydrated. Or it firms up to trap invaders. If it is thick, it is either trapping something or it's incorrectly formulated. It can't do it's job. People with CF are chronically infected. Logically, thickened mucus is a reflection of a high load of infection, at least in part. it’s also known that overproduction of mucus is not related directly to CFTR! What that means is that the observed overproduction is a secondary result of the underlying condition. I think most of what we think of as CF is really secondary, tertiary or further downstream effects. If we had a condition called Pale Skin Disorder where you were chronically sunburned to the point of being at high risk of dying from skin cancer, you would have a lot of symptoms that aren't per se inherent to having pale skin. If you are chronically infected your entire life and chronically malnourished your entire life because people don't know how to address issues with the CFTR, this will have consequences that aren't per se due to the defect in the CFTR. No one is going to mistake a slide of pus and a slide of mucus, and no one will mistake a spectrograph of the two either. No, of course not. But at what point does mucus become phlegm? How chemically deranged does mucus need to be before it gets recognized as not normal, healthy mucus? How many microbes does it need to contain to be considered some kind of drainage due to infection rather than mucus? Phlegm is not pus. But they are both a form of infected drainage. I don't have the language I want for the ideas I have, in part because I generally don't get meaningful engagement. I'm trying to make a distinction that's clear in my mind. When I'm adequately hydrated and have enough salt, etc, my mucus membranes are moist and I'm less infected. I no longer have vaginal dryness either. I spent some time waking up worried that my period had started because dry was the norm. If it was wet, I was bleeding. That fact did not prevent me from having vaginal discharge, including from frequent yeast infections. I no longer get yeast infections either.
- Fomite 8y agoPhlegm is mucus produced by lung tissue. And your lungs (or vagina) being filled with pus would be a very different thing.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMy point is that phlegm is akin to pus in that it is drainage due to infection. It is not "normal" mucus. Women routinely have vaginal discharge of various sorts that is not normal, healthy mucus. The fact that women with CF have both substantial vaginal discharge and vaginal dryness severe enough in some cases to "ruin" their sex life strongly suggests that there is a difference between what is produced in quantity by the mucus membranes of people with CF and normal, healthy mucus. I'm saying that difference is that it's a form of discharge due to infection, not an overproduction of mucus per se. If it were the same thing as mucus, women with CF should not be simultaneously reporting vaginal dryness that interferes with sex and vaginal discharge.
- Fomite 8y agoYou're saying then that women with CF have a persistent, chronic, but undiagnosable infection. Note that if, as a medical researcher, one managed to identify an underlying causal agent for CF, that would be career changing. Also, your vaginal dryness theory is only true if CF-related discharge works as a responsive lubricant. That could be, as you suggest, due to a difference in kind, but it could also be a change in composition, differential overproduction, or a complex interplay of several other factors.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMedicine agrees that all people with CF are chronically infected. That part is not some novel theory on my part. I don't have a vaginal dryness theory. My point is that CF is genetic and impacts all cells of the body. The way it works vaginally and in the lungs ought to be consistent. Women with CF consistently report vaginal dryness. They also report vaginal discharge. This discharge appears to not be mucus, given the rest of their testimony. The reports of women with CF concerning their reproductive tract should cast some light on lung function and is not consistent with prevailing theories that people with CF are "drowning in their own mucus."
- samatman 8y agoPhlegm is mucous of the respiratory system, by definition. Vaginal anything can't be phlegm for that reason. Not to take anything away from the rest of your post; dealing with an idiopathic condition that your doctors don't understand must be very frustrating. Best of luck.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI'm aware that the vagina does not produce phlegm, which is why I added the word pus -- which someone else felt the need to correct and inform me phlegm and pus are not the same thing. Both replies appear to assume that I don't know what I'm talking about. This is the norm: I'm a former homemaker, so I must not know anything medical. I'm human. I make mistakes. I'm not a doctor and I don't speak like one. However, I also have a certificate for "Certified life and health insurance specialist" that I got as part of my job at Aflac where I read medical records all day as part of my job. Among other things, the certificate program covered medical terminology and some basics of health and biology. For example, I had to know the different bones in the body because I paid accident claims and a broken hip paid different from a broken arm, etc. I'm not a medical professional. But I did have a job for over five years that required me to be able to comprehend medical records and surgical reports well enough to decide how much money to pay people for their medical treatments for covered health events. The rumors that I'm merely an uneducated former homemaker are a tad exaggerated. I'm not trying to give you a hard time. This is just a long-standing pattern of how people reply to my comments. Phlegm is mucous of the respiratory system, by definition. Also, while we are all being pedantic here: Mucus vs mucous https://grammarist.com/spelling/mucous-mucus https://grammarist.com/spelling/mucous-mucus Mucus is a noun. Mucous is an adjective. And I'm adding that because both you and the other person "correcting" me used mucous when you meant mucus: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18945575 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18945575
- samatman 8y agoOne is a typo, the other a factual error. Vaginas don't produce phlegm, period, and never will. I don't know you from Adam, I have no idea about your past and also don't care much. In this one, specific instance, you do not know what you're talking about. Pouring half a page out doesn't change that. There's no need to be defensive about it, or take it as more than it is. This is HN. Mistakes get pointed out.