5 ms·
I would argue that this is why significant digits count. You can't say something is 2.1374cm long when your error is +/-1cm. You can say it is 2cm long though.
by godelski 8y ago
I would argue that this is why significant digits count.
You can't say something is 2.1374cm long when your error is +/-1cm. You can say it is 2cm long though.
- a11595 8y agoSignificant digits is a calculation shortcut introduced to people freshman year in highschool. It's shorthand for error rate. 2.1374cm +-1cm is a completely different error range than "2." In fact, guess what - real equipment error rates are not integers like 1cm - it's something like "+-.96cm" . Your way literally takes results and makes them less accurate. Why in the world would they do that?
- jhall1468 8y agoI'm not sure why anyone thinks significant digits in any way informs error rate, and it's a little hyperbolic to suggest 4 significant digits with a whole number error rate, when they did 1 significant digit with a ~3% to ?% error rate.
- aeternus 8y ago>I'm not sure why anyone thinks significant digits in any way informs error rate In the majority of technical fields the standard is to round the result so that the significant digits do correspond to error rate. https://www.ruf.rice.edu/~bioslabs/tools/data_analysis/errors_sigfigs.html https://www.ruf.rice.edu/~bioslabs/tools/data_analysis/error...
- jhall1468 8y agoI'd expect that in academia for the most part. But this is a consumer product, so they aren't going to follow technical fields, and my hunch is that's for marketing reasons (it looks more authentic). But even then, rounding to the error rate is a standard practice, but it certainly does mean it's wrong or even unethical, it's just pointless not to. Unless of course your motivation is driven by marketing/sales.
- godelski 8y ago> it looks more authentic One might call that deception
- devereaux 8y agoActually, you can. It's just a custom to do differently. But if you estimate your first moment is 2.1374 and your second moment is 1, I want to know just that, because it is the numbers I'll plug in my equations. I will decide to round if and when necessary
- dTal 8y agoYou're implying that by rounding before handing off the numbers, valuable information is lost. Actually, the reverse is true - the rounding itself contains valuable information (how many digits are actually relevant) which is a hidden property of the process that obtained them. Unless you provide it through a side channel, failing to round hides this information, for no benefit at all (because the digits you provide are known to be meaningless). The only time this wouldn't be true is if you mistrust the significant figure calculation of the source, and believe you have sufficient insight to do better.
- devereaux 8y agoYes, I do. In general, I stick to simple things. Enough samples and everything is normal, god bless the law of large numbers. If the precision of your estimation is not a direct function of the standard deviation, but is a "hidden property of the process that obtained" it, we have much bigger problems that losing "valuable information"
- jeena 8y agoBack in high school in physics we would get minus points if we indicated a too high precision in the numbers we used for calculations, it was considered plain wrong to say 2.232cm if you actually only were able to measure that it's roughly 2cm.
- godelski 8y agoAnd that's good, because you'll get the wrong answer if you used the number with too many points (nit picking: more decimal points does not mean higher precision). In fact, this is part of why you'll see physicists do all their reductions with variables and plug in numbers at the very end. This ensures that you doing get (what we could call) floating point errors. You don't have extra numbers hanging around (from real numbers like 1/9 or pi). There are also other benefits to doing this.