4 ms·
> 53+ thousand new users This might explain why my perception of average comment quality has dropped. It's purely anecdotal, but it feels as if the volume of j
by echelon 8y ago
> 53+ thousand new users
This might explain why my perception of average comment quality has dropped. It's purely anecdotal, but it feels as if the volume of joke posts and "me too" responses has increased well beyond what it was five years ago.
Comments have always been the most valuable part of HN for me. It's frankly starting to feel a little bit like Reddit around here, and I'm concerned about the signal:noise ratio dropping any further.
- diamondo25 8y agoYes, this is an issue of anything popular. Not that it is a bad thing, as it keeps the community alive, but it feels "not the same" and might drive users away, like what happened on Facebook.
- dvno42 8y agoPerhaps a few tweaks can be made to the platform to help ensure HN's "core values" (that sounds silly) are passed on to new users. For the most part there's always been a good herd mentality to negate the one off low quality posts and a bit of public shaming "We don't talk like that around here...". Maybe a "Posting Guidelines" page and more weight added to the down-vote button to those that are privileged to have it could help.
- cordonbleu 8y agothere are sockpuppets rings abounding, likely there are black/grey hat SEO spammers trying to elevate thier live[valid,working] link count to game the g00gle search results, and then there are people that want to comment, civilly and substantiavely but have been somehow cut off from doing so, thus create a throwaway login for that purpose just to make thier voice heard. and then there are trolls and the indignant that just like to derail a normal conversation because its "funny". I have to deal with these on my chat board often but not at large scale. There are of course, normal users that are trying to have a constructive discourse, i believe there is ample signature to flag the differences to a discriminating mind, or someone with admin/mod status and access to the management tools.
- wyxuan 8y agoThere are some positive aspects, as it allows for more diversified opinions on various issues. I find that it is great that there are chicken farmers, bridge builders, etc on this platform. But I agree. There have been less and less articles on directly tech relating things, and more on general world news. Some of the things are important and worth posting, but HN has become a little bit of a general news aggregator.
- scrumbledober 8y agoOn the one hand I totally agree, but on the other hand I also really enjoy reading what fellow HN-users think about the more diverse topics.
- paulddraper 8y agoI think comment quality is still high. But over the last 18 months, I've noticed a lot of -- IDK -- partisan(?) votes. Certain topics -- UBI, NN, GDPR, US vs EU politics -- seem to get comments upvoted/downvoted purely based on what side the comment supports, rather than the quality of the comment.
- scottlocklin 8y agoHonestly such subjects should not be in a technical blog/aggregator. The most successful forum I have ever seen only had two rules: 1) On topic (quantitative finance) 2) No politics, no religion Politics and religion can come up when it comes to quanting, but there is no reason for them to, and raising these topics is purely destructive. There are plenty of places to go argue with someone about noise if you want to.
- robin_reala 8y agoFor what it’s worth, the last point in the commenting guidelines is this: Please don't submit comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. It's a semi-noob illusion, as old as the hills.
- h1d 8y agoRight. 80% of the time, I don't even read the original article.
- paulddraper 8y agoNot reading the article is an HN staple.
- matthiaswh 8y agoTo be fair, people have been decrying this very same thing since the time I registered 8 years ago.
- ksec 8y agoI felt the same, recently I have a habit of clicking into user and see if they have only recently joined. I also notice a higher percentage of consumer hardware related news from various sources appearing on HN front page. It used to be only some real breakthrough, important announcement that gets the front page. I have a simple solution. Old HNer should start downvoting rigorously. To show we have little tolerance on noise and HN isn't Reddit.
- tough_luck 8y agoI think comment quality doesn't just depends on users but type of content that gets exposure too. I have always found that to understand most of submissions on hacker news you've to have some level of understanding and knowledge in technical fields. Same goes for comments. So hacker news will probably never become reddit and memey as long as we have great submissions and vigilant moderators.