7 ms·
Proponents don't automatically presume this. It isn't axiomatic. We just look at the data and disagree with your assessment. Yes, there is a tremendous amount o
by UncleMeat 8y ago
Proponents don't automatically presume this. It isn't axiomatic. We just look at the data and disagree with your assessment. Yes, there is a tremendous amount of inefficiency in the entire process. Some people look at this and think that taxes are therefore not a good plan. Other people look at this and think that despite the inefficiency taxes solve such an important need that it is worth it.
The other problem with this sort of argument is that it works at literally every tax level. If federal income tax rates were 1% then your argument would work just as well at discouraging any tax hike. There is clearly an inflection point but it is worth examining where that point is.
- Rooster61 8y ago> Proponents don't automatically presume this I respectfully disagree. Dogmatic clinging to political and economic ideals is rampant in society. People do this all the time. That doesn't apply to EVERYONE who holds the opposed opinion, though. Nor was it my intention to imply that. > Yes, there is a tremendous amount of inefficiency in the entire process. It's not just a matter of inefficiency. Inefficiency is intrinsic to any economic system as large and complex as that of the US, and that's to be expected. What isn't to be expected, or at least condoned, is the ACTIVE measures taken by those in office/places of power to squander money that is not naturally misappropriated by that complexity. Our current political/economic client is rife with this. > The other problem with this sort of argument is that it works at literally every tax level. The fact that an argument is right at every level isn't a problem, nor does it make it invalid. I'm of the opinion that no tax is going to be truly utilized correctly until the underlying problem of corruption is fixed. And please don't take my tone as accusatory. I do appreciate people taking a critical look at an issue and still coming up with the opposite of my stance.
- sharemywin 8y agoThat's a very black and white way of thinking about it.
- Rooster61 8y agoIMO, its very close to a black and white problem. Corruption is an extremely cancerous thing to a state, and I'm not convinced things will get better with the current level that's present.
- weberc2 8y agoI think this is a good way of looking at the problem but unfortunately it doesn’t resemble the public debate at all. It would be great if the conversation were about the inflection point and not ad hominems (“people who don’t want to raise taxes hate the poor!”).