3 ms·
> In fact, we now have compelling epidemiological evidence that vaping almost doubles risk of cardiac events If you continue to smoke tobacco. "Scientific" st
by mistermann 8y ago
> In fact, we now have compelling epidemiological evidence that vaping almost doubles risk of cardiac events
If you continue to smoke tobacco.
"Scientific" studies like this that assert causation when all they have is correlation, based on surveys that we know little about (and likely wouldn't be able to learn the full details of even if one was energetic enough to hunt down the original paper), certainly don't do anything to convince me. If anything, it just increases my suspicion around the "science" we're fed.
- hannasanarion 8y agoThis is literally the same argument that was used in the 60s to defend full-blown tobacco smoking. There are ways to establish causation besides the randomized controlled trial.
- skwb 8y agoWell they have correlation that remains correlated after you adjust the model for other risk factors. So is that direct evidence? No. But when you add in the other lines of evidence, you start building a case. It's sorta like a murder trial (not withstanding a separate discussion of our criminal justice system...) where the case is built over lines of evidence. And as one of my graduate professors once said, "there is no double blind randomized trial for the efficacy of parachutes" ;) [0]. [0]. https://www.bmj.com/content/327/7429/1459 https://www.bmj.com/content/327/7429/1459
- mistermann 8y ago> But when you add in the other lines of evidence, you start building a case. It's sorta like a murder trial (not withstanding a separate discussion of our criminal justice system...) where the case is built over lines of evidence. When you're dealing with a murder trial, whether harm has occurred is clear. In this case, not only is there a lack of evidence for causation, there's not even any evidence for harm.
- skwb 8y agoPeople have died of cardiac events and lung cancer. Some people have used e-cigarettes. Some have not. Is there evidence that connects the use of e-cigarettes to these deaths? That's for science to decide.
- mistermann 8y agoSimilarly: People have died of cardiac events and lung cancer. Some people have chewed gum while walking. Some have not. Is there evidence that connects chewing gum while walking? That's for science to decide. As it is, we have none. But until then, I'd rather not have it outlawed or be forced to pay for research without some reasonable reasoning that there may be some significant risk involved.