2 ms·
>Nicotine is viciously addictive. I don't see how anyone could consider one of the most addictive substances, and its associated withdrawal symptoms, to be "har
by SilasX 8y ago
>Nicotine is viciously addictive. I don't see how anyone could consider one of the most addictive substances, and its associated withdrawal symptoms, to be "harmless".
Addictive stuff is bad if taking it has other negative effects. Food, water, and air are likewise addictive, but that doesn’t mean you should do without. You’d need to cite something other than being addictive to establish a reason to avoid them entirely.
>And yes, nicotine replacement therapy has a decent track record compared to other methods, which should not be surprising since you don't have to actual break the addiction. You just maintain the same addiction with a different delivery system.
I think the idea is to follow them up with a tapering off of the nicotine levels, which is much easier at that point.
- matthewmacleod 8y agoI think the idea is to follow them up with a tapering off of the nicotine levels, which is much easier at that point. And indeed, if you fail to taper off, at least you’re doing yourself much less harm.
- empath75 8y ago> Addictive stuff is bad if taking it has other negative effects. The definition of addiction includes negative consequences. If there aren't any, it's not an addiction.
- SilasX 8y agoThen my point is equivalent to saying that the parent didn’t establish it as being addictive under that definition. Dictionary definitions don't help resolve a debate on the substantive points.
- edflsafoiewq 8y ago> Food, water, and air are likewise addictive This is a perverse usage. The physiological need for food, water, or air is innate; it arises from your body itself, not the action of the external substance on your body. Additionally they do not induce the classical development of tolerance. Many people would hold that addiction itself is bad. Even if there are no other negative effects, there is the effect of dependence on the addictive substance and commensurate loss of independence (the addiction always occupies some mental space since you must always think about how you are going to satisfy it).
- SilasX 8y agoOkay, if I may rephrase the point in a less cheeky manner: It's not very informative that a substance is addictive in the sense that "you must use this every day or experience extreme negative side effects". You have to also look the cost of taking it and what it does to you when you use it. I have to constantly eat to stay alive? Manageable. I have to consume water and breathe air? Manageable. I have to inject 50 cents of insulin? Manageable. I have to absorb 50 cents of nicotine? Manageable. If I have to consume expensive amounts of crack, which also makes me homicidal? Okay, then that's a problem. I was objecting to the OP's criticism of the lingering nicotine addiction and usage as some kind of be-all end-all deal-breaker. No, it depends on the relative harm. If you go from "expensively sucking down toxic junk to get your nicotine fix every day" to "taking a cheap nicotine-only does everyday", that's not defeating the purpose of anything, and it's very much missing the point to dismiss it as "still being addicted to nicotine".
- darpa_escapee 8y agoThere's a difference between a physiological need, like consuming water and air, and a chemical dependence. > I have to constantly eat to stay alive? Manageable. I have to consume water and breathe air? Manageable. No matter where you go, the entirety of society is structured around the fact that all people need to eat, drink and breathe. > I have to inject 50 cents of insulin? Manageable. I have to absorb 50 cents of nicotine? Manageable. This is where the disconnect is. The cost of insulin dependence is not merely the cost of insulin itself. An insulin dependent person must always be aware of their blood sugar levels and diet. They must always be prepared for a situation in which they're away from their insulin supply. They must be prepared for an emergency or incapacitation due to complications with their condition and its treatment. There's a significant cognitive load that isn't accounted for by the fabric of society like the need for food is. Likewise, there's a psychological, social and occupational cost to nicotine addiction that isn't reflected in nicotine's price alone. This is why people are saying that chemical dependence is inherently bad: it's an inconvenience at best, a costly burden to most and a killer at worst.
- baddox 8y ago> Addictive stuff is bad if taking it has other negative effects. I get your point, but I think it's a bit oversimplified. I think that addiction itself can cause problems, even if it's just distress from feeling a lack of control. I've had several people tell me that caffeine addiction is no big deal if you're getting it from mostly healthy or neutral sources, but I remember being addicted to caffeine for sleep/attention regulation and for me that dependence was stressful on its own. Another example might be porn addiction, which is well-known to have negative effects due directly to the dependence on certain stimuli to achieve certain mental/physical states.
- standardUser 8y agoI'm guessing you have never struggled with nicotine addiction, or perhaps you're one of those people who experiences a more mild addiction than average. But if most people were to develop nicotine addiction for several years and then stop for a week, they would experience mental anguish far beyond what anyone could consider "healthy". For long time smokers, that anguish can go on for months. Healthy people do not experience intense mental suffering simply because they don't have nicotine. It's a disease - an illness - even if it does not cause cancer.
- zepto 8y agoFood water and air are not addictive. They are necessary for survival.