6 ms·
>Most of it pushes these quit-smoking drugs or just different forms of nicotine intake (which is the very drug you're supposed to be trying to quit in the first
by SilasX 8y ago
>Most of it pushes these quit-smoking drugs or just different forms of nicotine intake (which is the very drug you're supposed to be trying to quit in the first place).
Wait, what? I thought nicotine itself was pretty harmless, and that most of the harm from smoking comes from all the other junk you suck into your lungs? Wikipedia seems to agree:
>The health effects of long-term nicotine use are unknown. The general medical position is that nicotine itself poses few health risks, except among certain vulnerable groups, such as youth. Nicotine use as a tool for quitting smoking has a good safety history.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicotine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicotine
- standardUser 8y agoNicotine is viciously addictive. I don't see how anyone could consider one of the most addictive substances, and its associated withdrawal symptoms, to be "harmless". And yes, nicotine replacement therapy has a decent track record compared to other methods, which should not be surprising since you don't have to actual break the addiction. You just maintain the same addiction with a different delivery system. Interestingly, vaping itself is just another nicotine delivery system, but one that the anti-smoking zealots decided to demonize, unlike the various inhalers, patches and gums they push.
- dageshi 8y agoNicotine addictiveness seems to vary based on consumption method, I say that as someone who smokes cigars but doesn't inhale (common practice among cigar smokers), I don't find cigars addictive in the least.
- Konnstann 8y agohow do you smoke without inhaling the smoke? Genuinely curious, I thought the whole point was to inhale the smoke, otherwise you don't get any flavor.
- kgwgk 8y agoYou can taste wine and spit instead of swallowing, to give just one of many examples.
- dageshi 8y agoAhh by inhale I mean you don't inhale into your lungs, mouth only. You take the smoke into your mouth where you can taste it but continue to breath freely through your nose without taking any smoke down into your lungs. You do absorb nicotine through the lining of your mouth and it's not without risk, mouth cancer is a possibility but my understanding is it's a much lesser risk than smoke in the lungs. Finally you can retrohale where you allow some smoke to come up through the sinuses and out via the nose, which allows you to pickup some extra flavour.
- AlgorithmicTime 8y agoYour lungs don't have taste buds, those are in your mouth. You take the smoke in your mouth, mainly. You might pump it through your nose, too.
- subcosmos 8y agoIt is viciously addictive, yes, but it's all that other crap in cigarettes that lead to lung cancer and heart disease, two of the largest killers of all people. Would you rather people be addicted to just the nocotine, or the nicotine plus carcinogens?
- snuxoll 8y agoDon't forget the MAOI's that also contribute to the addiction.
- SilasX 8y ago>Nicotine is viciously addictive. I don't see how anyone could consider one of the most addictive substances, and its associated withdrawal symptoms, to be "harmless". Addictive stuff is bad if taking it has other negative effects. Food, water, and air are likewise addictive, but that doesn’t mean you should do without. You’d need to cite something other than being addictive to establish a reason to avoid them entirely. >And yes, nicotine replacement therapy has a decent track record compared to other methods, which should not be surprising since you don't have to actual break the addiction. You just maintain the same addiction with a different delivery system. I think the idea is to follow them up with a tapering off of the nicotine levels, which is much easier at that point.
- matthewmacleod 8y agoI think the idea is to follow them up with a tapering off of the nicotine levels, which is much easier at that point. And indeed, if you fail to taper off, at least you’re doing yourself much less harm.
- empath75 8y ago> Addictive stuff is bad if taking it has other negative effects. The definition of addiction includes negative consequences. If there aren't any, it's not an addiction.
- SilasX 8y agoThen my point is equivalent to saying that the parent didn’t establish it as being addictive under that definition. Dictionary definitions don't help resolve a debate on the substantive points.
- edflsafoiewq 8y ago> Food, water, and air are likewise addictive This is a perverse usage. The physiological need for food, water, or air is innate; it arises from your body itself, not the action of the external substance on your body. Additionally they do not induce the classical development of tolerance. Many people would hold that addiction itself is bad. Even if there are no other negative effects, there is the effect of dependence on the addictive substance and commensurate loss of independence (the addiction always occupies some mental space since you must always think about how you are going to satisfy it).
- phkahler 8y ago>> Nicotine is viciously addictive. I hope you are equally against sugar which is also addictive and has much worse adverse effects than nicotine.
- giggles_giggles 8y agoI've never had a panic attack at the airport because I couldn't have sugar for a couple of hours, but I have had one because I couldn't vape. I've never yelled at a coworker because I couldn't have a cookie, but I did when I was quitting nicotine because it made me feel insane. I've never lashed out at my girlfriend because I couldn't have a Coca-Cola, but I did many times when my vape's battery had died and she wanted to stay out of the house a little longer, or I had run out of e-juice. I quit a couple months ago and it's been life changing, just to not have the dependence. When I give up sugar I do not instantly find that my relationships are easier to manage, for instance, without the demon of sugar addiction popping up into my brain to have me lash out at my loved ones who are standing in the way of another hit of sugar. Even putting it that way sounds absurd, but swap in nicotine and it makes perfect sense. Obviously you don't understand the true mind-bending power of nicotine. The comparison to sugar is one that could really only be made by someone who has never experienced a nicotine addiction. I say this as someone who loves sugar and tries to cut back. It's not the same. It's not even slightly the same.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoI worked with this guy. One day, there was a piece of paper stuck up outside his cube that said (as best I remember): "I am trying to quit smoking. I am a Vietnam vet and I have worked in the post office. All that is standing between you and sudden death is this silly little patch I am wearing. Be very kind to me." Yeah, nicotine withdrawal can be a real thing.
- SilasX 8y ago>I've never had a panic attack at the airport because I couldn't have sugar for a couple of hours, but I have had one because I couldn't vape. Maybe you haven’t, but low blood sugar diabetic emergencies are a thing.
- namlem 8y agoTobacco is viciously addictive. Nicotine on its own is only mildly addictive. Tobacco contains MAOIs that potentiate nicotine.
- wnevets 8y agoDoes anyone else remember when marlboro released cigarettes with less nicotine in them and marketed it as a healthier choice?
- SilasX 8y agoWait, they said the lower nicotine made it safer? I'd always heard it as being the lower tar that was supposed to be healthier?
- wnevets 8y agoYup, a quick google turn this up. I remember being confused as a child when adults would tell me theses were healthier. They would always just smoke more. https://www.nytimes.com/1992/01/18/business/new-philip-morris-cigarette-emphasizes-less-nicotine.html https://www.nytimes.com/1992/01/18/business/new-philip-morri...
- oh_sigh 8y agoI guess the idea is not that nicotine is inherently unsafe, but lower nicotine levels will lead to lower addiction levels, leading to fewer cigarettes smoked?
- thatcat 8y agoAccording to your source the ld50 for nicotine is 6 mg/kg. Although the dosage taken is relatively low, nicotine is still way more toxic than most things people consume on purpose.
- Silfen 8y agoLD50 is entirely irrelevant to this discussion. No one goes to the store and orders 1mg/kg of a substance. When considering acute harm, the relevant metric is the ratio between a typical recreational dose and an overdose. For example, there are very few tobacco servings that contain more than 20mg nicotine. A person is very unlikely to come anywhere near the, say, 360mg lethal dose.
- thatcat 8y agoNicotine is more toxic than tar and other substances, as measured by the LD50; it's just that those substances are all really hot and carcinogenic. 360 mg / 6 = 18, less than 1 pack has a lethal dose of nicotine. However, since uptake by the body is low for nicotine, smoking what would seem to be a lethal amount doesn't kill people. https://www.webmd.com/smoking-cessation/nicotine-poisoning-can-you-overdose#1 https://www.webmd.com/smoking-cessation/nicotine-poisoning-c...