2 ms·
In all seriousness, the reason why this and several collections roughly as large as it went for $45 on the market is precisely that it must not be that useful a
by jerf 8y ago
In all seriousness, the reason why this and several collections roughly as large as it went for $45 on the market is precisely that it must not be that useful anymore. If it truly were a skeleton key to the world it would not be going for $45.
I'm abundantly positive there's still a lot of perfectly valid login credentials in there, but the trick is finding them without also triggering rate limiting detection now.
- elorant 8y agoI'm not aware of the specifics of the dark market, but from a marketing perspective selling something for cheap makes it easier to sell volume. Perhaps the guy who did the hack didn't want to go into the trouble of finding the one bidder who would give him top dollars, not to mention the dangers a contact like that might include. It's easier to find 1k buyers for $45 than one for $45k.
- jerf 8y agoThere isn't a "the guy" who did "the hack"; this is an aggregate compilation of a series of low-quality elements that have mostly lost their market value. It's the computer security equivalent of this: https://smile.amazon.com/Midnight-Movie-Madness-MegaPack-Digital/dp/B01DL6PBMG/ https://smile.amazon.com/Midnight-Movie-Madness-MegaPack-Dig... 50 low-value movies for $11.99. Note the distinction between "low value" and "no value". Yes, you might find something you like in there, as some of the reviewers did, but the economic value of this stuff has passed. My point is that the market value has been lost because there actually is some churn in passwords and accounts. If 99% of the credentials in this hack still worked, it would not be getting sold at this price at all; it would be selling something worth tens or hundreds of thousands, if not millions to the right buyer, for You Pay Only $44.99. Not gonna happen. It can't be worth all that much to most buyers if that's all they're selling it for. Or it's just so widespread that it's worthless, although I'd suggest in that case that we'd have heard about it earlier. Have I Been Pwned actually has some hookups in that world.
- elorant 8y agoSure, but let's not forget that there are e-mails in there too. $45 for 750M e-mail addresses doesn't sound like a bad deal. Perhaps whoever compiled that list is aiming at spammers and that's why he's selling cheap to get volume.
- bitwize 8y ago> It's the computer security equivalent of this: https://smile.amazon.com/Midnight-Movie-Madness-MegaPack-Dig.. https://smile.amazon.com/Midnight-Movie-Madness-MegaPack-Dig.... 50 low-value movies for $11.99. Note the distinction between "low value" and "no value". Yes, you might find something you like in there, as some of the reviewers did, but the economic value of this stuff has passed. They should call it "Amazon Subprime".