4 ms·
>I'm curious about the description of a black hole as a singularity. I'm going to resort to Neoplatonist philosophy to try to understand this. Modern physics (
by andrepd 8y ago
>I'm curious about the description of a black hole as a singularity. I'm going to resort to Neoplatonist philosophy to try to understand this.
Modern physics (with its successful predictions) require complicated mathematics to understand. What makes you think that neoplatonist thought can help you understand a modern scientific theory?
- dr_dshiv 8y agoComplicated mathematics doesn't make the singularity more understandable. It just makes more people give up trying to understand. I don't think any physicist would claim that modern physics understands time=1. Neoplatonist thought holds the belief that the structure of the physical world is based on fundamentally basic mathematical patterns -- which is completely commensurable with modern physics. That they viewed the one as the origin of reality seems to provide a reasonable and human-readable perspective on how the entire universe of 100B+ galaxies could once exist in a volume smaller than the nucleus of an atom. Math =! understanding. I have faith that the world is fundamentally reasonable and understandable. All models are Wong, some are useful, that sort of thing. So I appreciate the perspective of very smart ancient philosophers on this origin issue.
- lostmsu 8y ago> Complicated mathematics doesn't make the singularity more understandable. What do you mean it does not? Limit theory does that in great depths. Some cases are unaccounted for, but that might actually be due to the incompleteness theorem.
- dr_dshiv 8y agoI don't mean to be dismissive of complex math, but it can be seen as an excuse by people who expect the universe to NOT make intuitive sense. Usually, powerful mathematical explanations are quite simple (Maxwell's equations, Boltzmann's, etc)
- lostmsu 8y agoI, for one, don't expect the universe not to make intuitive sense. I just think average folk intuition is waaay to weak for that. Actually, I think the same applies to nearly all people, mathematicians the least of all.