3 ms·
EVs don't solve the CO2 footprint of cars, the improvement is too small. We must drastically reduce the low-occupancy car miles driven and reverse the car growt
by fulafel 8y ago
EVs don't solve the CO2 footprint of cars, the improvement is too small. We must drastically reduce the low-occupancy car miles driven and reverse the car growth trend in developing countries.
- virgilp 8y agoYour comment makes A LOT of assumptions - in both ways e.g.: - you are ignoring the benefits that EVs could bring, as well as synergies with future technology improvements. Radically better battery technology coupled with cheap, affordable solar might be a game changer of unprecedented scale. - On the other hand, there's no proof that "drastically reducing the low-occupancy car miles driven" or "reversing the car growth trend" is either feasible or beneficial (how do you achieve the goal? Any measure is likely to have side-effects. I haven't seen any realistic proposal that doesn't have potentially horrible side-effects). Lastly, let me just tell you that I love it when people living in developed countries know what developing countries should do (which is typically "stay poor", but delivered in a more politically-correct way)
- majewsky 8y ago> I haven't seen any realistic proposal that doesn't have potentially horrible side-effects. What are the horrible side effects of car pools?
- virgilp 8y agoCar pools are "desired effects", maybe - for sure they aren't "realistic proposals". There are no horrible side effects to "a healthier population"; however, the prohibition showed us that there may indeed be bad side-effects to banning alcohol consumption & distribution (which could be argued as a measure that leads to a healthier population).
- alexgmcm 8y agoIt isn't just CO2 though. As a city dweller I look forward to a future with less air and noise pollution.
- blktiger 8y agoLess air polution for sure, but most of the noise from cars isn't from the engines. It's mostly the noise of tires traveling over pavement.
- dx034 8y agoDepends on speed. In cities, most noise tends to be from engines (esp trucks, buses etc). On motorways, engine noise plays little role.
- alexgmcm 8y agoWhere I live it's definitely the engines. Cars aren't so bad, but buses and motorcycles (which have removed the muffler) are horrendous. I don't have much faith that laws can solve the problem, so the spread of electric technology is my best hope.
- ericb 8y agoIf you add in solar and batteries with continual improvement, the improvement is just fine. > We must drastically reduce the low-occupancy car miles driven and reverse the car growth trend in developing countries. Any solution that ignores self-interest at the personal and state level is not a solution that can be banked on to work.
- strunz 8y agoNot everyone lives in a big city where this is even a realistic goal.
- brewdad 8y agoSure but most Americans (and Europeans) do. Don't let perfect be the enemy of good. Just because a solution doesn't solve every use case doesn't mean it's not worth pursuing.
- usaar333 8y agohttps://cleantechnica.com/2018/02/19/electric-car-well-to-wheel-emissions-myth/ https://cleantechnica.com/2018/02/19/electric-car-well-to-wh... 50% is hardly a small improvement. In some areas you are looking at a 70+% improvement. Asking people to swallow standard of living deductions is a lot harder than them getting a slightly different type of car.