17 ms·
I'm curious about the description of a black hole as a singularity. I'm going to resort to Neoplatonist philosophy to try to understand this. In the formation
by dr_dshiv 8y ago
I'm curious about the description of a black hole as a singularity. I'm going to resort to Neoplatonist philosophy to try to understand this.
In the formation of the universe, the notion of a singularity points at an old idea, argued by Plotinus, that everything started with "The One". This is commensurable with the statement that the boltzmann entropy of the start of the universe, prior to inflation, would be equal to "1" -- because that is the total volume of possible phase space. That, to me, is very elegant -- although it is unclear whether there are predictions about how the 1 becomes 2 ("the indefinite dyad"), 3 and then the inflationary myriad. But still, I'm impressed that the logic of ancient philosophy could correspond reasonably with modern physics.
From this perspective, I'm interpreting big bang's "singularity" as =1. What is the nature of the singularity of a blackhole? Is the event horizon itself the singularity, or does it just an effect of a singularity at the center of the blackhole? Is there a "One" at the center of the blackhole?
- robin_reala 8y agoI think your assumptions are off. Anyway, the event horizon isn’t the singularity itself, it’s the point of no return that surrounds the singularity.
- platz 8y agoMaybe there is a One. Some physicists think that inside a black hole is a white hole, which would look like expansion. Our cosmological horizon could match up with this
- perfmode 8y agoIs this the idea that our observable universe is actually inside of a larger black hole?
- platz 8y agoThat's right
- pvinis 8y agoI've never heard of this. Any suggestions on where to read about these theories?
- dpark 8y agoI think you just read everything there is to read about this. To my understanding, the idea that our universe is actually inside a black hole is not a “theory” in the sense that, say, relativity is a theory. It’s pure conjecture, and essentially not falsifiable. It’s more akin to the “theory” that our universe is a computer simulation.
- perfmode 8y agoIt’s the most intuitive explanation I’ve encountered for why we don’t see other life. (They might be inside of black holes.)
- matt_kantor 8y agoThis is not intuitive to me. Why would they be inside black holes and not outside them?
- michaelmrose 8y agoSo what happens to stuff falling into the outside black hole?
- platz 8y agoyou probably still hit what looks like a singularity from your perspective and get spagettified
- michaelmrose 8y ago
- perfmode 8y agoI think you’re reading tea leaves here
- whatshisface 8y agoIf one doesn't understand a scientific theory then their understanding of it contains no information. Ancient philosophy rarely contains information. As a result the two often appear to line up.
- yesenadam 8y ago>Ancient philosophy rarely contains information. Sounds like you haven't read much, gee. What a strange comment. It has a far higher signal/noise ratio than modern philosophy, I'd say, maybe because usually only the best has survived.
- whatshisface 8y ago>It has a far higher signal/noise ratio than modern philosophy You can look at it this way: every possible statement seems to have been made by at least one ancient philosopher, especially once you include the non-western traditions. There were atom-ists, and continuum-ists, and so on. If you view ancient philosophy as one big bucket of sentences, it will fill up sentence space fairly uniformly. You could reconstruct ancient philosophy just by coming up with reasonable-sounding claims about things they were aware of back then until you ran out of possibilities, although that wouldn't produce the historical association of certain views with certain people. A distribution that uniformly fills space is, in the technical sense of the word, "no information." If you trim it down (for example by doing experiments and discarding whatever doesn't match your newfound knowledge of reality), you get a distribution that "has information." To put it concretely, finding out that an ancient philosopher said something doesn't help, because ancient philosophers said everything they could think of. Whether that is better or worse than what philosophers are doing now is up to philosophers to decide, I guess.
- teolandon 8y agoI haven't actually taken every single statement said by ancient philosophers (if you can even clearly classify philosophers as 'ancient' -- what's the date cutoff?), and put them in a bucket, and checked that the sentence space in that bucket is filled up uniformly. However, new sentences are made every day, new words made very often. Nobody cares about the technical sense of the words "no information". If your argument was extended from 'ancient philosophy' to 'anything ever said by humans', then anything ever said by humans would fill the sentence space fairly uniformly, so finding out that anyone has said anything doesn't help. A single human has not considered and thought about every sentence possible. They have their own beliefs and knowledges, and by reading ancient philosophy, they can expand that knowledge base, change those beliefs. Ancient philosophy is not inconsequential, and it certainly contains "information".
- andrepd 8y ago>I'm curious about the description of a black hole as a singularity. I'm going to resort to Neoplatonist philosophy to try to understand this. Modern physics (with its successful predictions) require complicated mathematics to understand. What makes you think that neoplatonist thought can help you understand a modern scientific theory?
- dr_dshiv 8y agoComplicated mathematics doesn't make the singularity more understandable. It just makes more people give up trying to understand. I don't think any physicist would claim that modern physics understands time=1. Neoplatonist thought holds the belief that the structure of the physical world is based on fundamentally basic mathematical patterns -- which is completely commensurable with modern physics. That they viewed the one as the origin of reality seems to provide a reasonable and human-readable perspective on how the entire universe of 100B+ galaxies could once exist in a volume smaller than the nucleus of an atom. Math =! understanding. I have faith that the world is fundamentally reasonable and understandable. All models are Wong, some are useful, that sort of thing. So I appreciate the perspective of very smart ancient philosophers on this origin issue.
- lostmsu 8y ago> Complicated mathematics doesn't make the singularity more understandable. What do you mean it does not? Limit theory does that in great depths. Some cases are unaccounted for, but that might actually be due to the incompleteness theorem.
- ben_w 8y agoThe ancient Greeks put the “Euclid” into “Euclidian geometry”. It took until about 1813 for that to be replaced with non-Euclidian geometry, and everything that makes General relativity really interesting is non-Euclidian.
- dr_dshiv 8y agoKeep in mind that the first 28 postulates of Euclid remain valid even in non Euclidean geometry. Even Euclid had to invoke another principle to clarify the 29th, which is now seen as an optional principle. http://mathworld.wolfram.com/EuclidsPostulates.html http://mathworld.wolfram.com/EuclidsPostulates.html
- danbruc 8y agoMost physicist probably don't think that black holes actually have a singularity and attribute singularities predicted by general relativity to the fact that the theory is only approximate and breaks down under the conditions at the center of a black hole. Just because the equations say there is a singularity does not mean that there is a real singularity.
- Retra 8y agoIdeally, we'd understand space completely in terms of the relationships between things, and our coordinate geometry would not ascribe any "positions" to events, but only "relations" between events. Singularities are places where our improperly-formed coordinate maps break down. Which means we'd rather like to look at black holes as holes in the coordinate mapping, rather than as singularities, but we don't have the mathematical prowess to do that. Or good enough scientific understanding of the phenomena to know that we've done it correctly.
- danbruc 8y agoCoordinate systems are not the primary issue. It's true that coordinates can be problematic but the laws of physics are independent of coordinates because those are of course only a tool we use to perform calculations. But take for example the classical law of gravitation which requires dividing by the square of the distance between the two bodies. The distance is independent of the coordinates you use to describe the positions of the bodies but you still get a divergent force as the distance approaches zero. So the breakdown of the law is not due to a bad choice of coordinates but inherent in the equation and a strong indication that the law is probably only approximate for short distances.
- Retra 8y agoI believe you're just saying the same thing I am in different terms. The fact that zero is even a 'distance' you can divide by is consequence of the fact that you're deriving distance from the coordinates of the bodies. If distance was instead fundamental (and not a function of coordinates), you'd not even have a zero distance, and you'd have no inclination to attempt dividing by it. (But the math for doing that is basically to always account for every part of every body, and that's just entirely intractable.) This is assuming mostly Newtonian physics, of course. Once you start dealing with fields and quantum mechanics, none of this makes as much sense.
- dr_dshiv 8y agoKeep in mind that this idea of oneness wasn't just some idea of some philosopher -- it was the central idea of Platonic philosophy. Obviously, I disagree with a knee jerk rejection.