3 ms·
> In any case, Wag and its walker are probably not at fault. I'd be after the driver. Not sure how you can jump to that conclusion. A driver can probably assum
by gnicholas 8y ago
> In any case, Wag and its walker are probably not at fault. I'd be after the driver.
Not sure how you can jump to that conclusion. A driver can probably assume that a dog being walked by a person, even near the road, will be controlled appropriately by the walker.
The only time a driver could not reasonably assume this is where the dog is too large to be controllable by the person (kid or small adult) who is walking it.
Without any facts, we can't presume the driver is at fault. Also, we have no way of finding out who that person is, except through Wag. So it's sort of pointless to pin our hopes on them.
Lastly, if the driver really were clearly at fault, it would be more likely that the Wag walker would have provided information to this effect. The fact that he/she has not is more consistent with it being the walker's fault.
- diaktifkan 8y agoI disagree the Walker would ready up this information. Because fault isn't always clear. And what if they were an immigrant and terrified of the police? To the OP, sorry for your loss. That's a tragic thing to have happen and I hope this is a lesson for you as well not to trust someone without getting to know them first.
- e40 8y agoIt's almost like people with an agenda have come here to comment. The GP blames the driver and another blames the dog. Without knowing any details. This is very fishy.
- nicky0 8y agoBut being Amreica, someone has to be to blame. It can't just be an unlucky accident of circumstances.
- gnicholas 8y agoThe author wrote the post because of the company's post-accident behavior, not because there was an accident. His point is that Wag isn't sharing information about what happened, or what parties are involved. Without this information, the author is completely helpless. And the only way to get anything from Wag is to pre-emptively forego all recourse, including sharing his story. This is the primary focus — not on the mere fact of the accident.
- askmike 8y agoI don't agree: I'm not from the US and generally think everyone is over reacting with constantly (threatening) to sue everyone else. But here the problem here isn't that the dog died, it's how Wag has handled the problem afterwards, and how their (poor) communication suggests that they didn't really do their due diligence in vetting the walkers. EDIT: a similar thing happened in my country (the Netherlands) where an Uber driver hit (and killed) a young woman after driving around in circles (a technique used to get more clients apparently, instead of parking somewhere), and Uber immediately pulled the "he is not an Uber employee and he wasn't with an Uber customer when it happened, so it's not our fault card". which resulted in public outrage[1]. They could have just send some flowers to the family, now they got a PR crisis instead. [1]: https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/een-uber-chauffeur-rijdt-een-jonge-vrouw-dood-en-uber-stellen-haar-ouders-vast-doet-daar-helemaal-niets-mee-~bedbe09c/ https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/een-uber-chauff...
- beaconstudios 8y agoI think the incentives in play force companies to act callous. It seems to me that companies are wary to act with empathy lest they get sued and the court takes it as an admission of guilt (or at least evidence of culpability, or something the jury will pay attention to). It's like that old advice where you should never say "sorry" after a car accident (as a Brit, apologising is a natural impulse even when not at fault) because it can be taken as an admission of fault.
- dagw 8y agoas a Brit, apologising is a natural impulse even when not at fault Someone explained it to me as when an American says "sorry" they mean "I'm sorry I did a bad thing to you" and when a Brit says sorry they mean "I'm sorry a bad thing happened to you". Which also explains the not uncommon American response to "sorry" of "Why? It wasn't your fault".
- beaconstudios 8y agoYeah that's it, though many Brits also share that reaction.
- michaelmrose 8y agoSomeone does have to be to blame even in the case of an accident. When you drive a multi ton machine at high rates of speed you are accountable for it. Likewise when you take money for a service you are accountable for not letting their dog run into the road which is usually pretty easy for an animal on a leash. What did wag do wrong that we know? The walker wasn't the person on the profile. They are withholding information regarding the incident. They tried to force the victim to agree to be legally silenced in order to pay for direct costs incurred. This is 1000 times worse than paying nothing.
- cgriswald 8y agoA car shouldn’t be within leash distance of a pedestrian. As long as the walker is behaving appropriately as a pedestrian and the dog is on leash the driver is going to be found at fault. The same is true even in cases where that is not the case. Obviously we don’t know in this instance but in most cases fault goes to the driver if the dog is on leash, and given that this dog did not belong to the owner I’d be surprised if it was off leash. It might have been a flexilead in which case the outcome might be different depending on jurisdiction and circumstance but in any case the owners are going to have a better time going after drivers. Neither party in this case involved the authorities or contacted any of the affected parties. The walker was already doing something they might not want Wag knowing about (having a third party walk the dog). I don’t think you can make any conclusions there so I’ll stick with my “probably”.
- Rapzid 8y agoDo you believe it's likely the driver is at fault given the lack of evidence? When I imagine a pet getting killed by a car I image it becomes free and running out in front of a car, not a car breaking a law and encroaching on the pets leash space. Perhaps there are some counter-intuitive stats on this I'm not aware of :) Further, there are a LOT of places where a person on a sidewalk would be within a leash length of a car legally driving 30+ mph.