3 ms·
Another problem I have with this sort of security person is the assumption that security risks always trump other risks. A few years ago we found some vulnerab
by cortesoft 8y ago
Another problem I have with this sort of security person is the assumption that security risks always trump other risks.
A few years ago we found some vulnerabilities on a server of ours, and some of the security folks were really upset we didn't immediately shut down the server. I argued that we needed to weigh the risks of the vulnerability vs the risk of shutting down the server immediately. Both actions involved risk, and we needed to weigh which was more severe.
Just because something is a security risk doesn't make it the most important thing automatically. It has to be analyzed in the context, and triaged in similar ways as other risks we discover in our work.
- tptacek 8y agoThe problem with this logic is that the risk of "shutting the server down" is almost always financial loss to the software firm, and the risk of "leaving it up" is often harm to end-users, who are an externality in the equation you're describing.
- cortesoft 8y agoSometimes, but shutting down the server can also harm users, if it is providing services that those customers rely on.