5 ms·
On the other hand, I think we are finding out how “essential” some of these institutions really are. During this shutdown, besides these workers unfortunately n
by ryandrake 8y ago
On the other hand, I think we are finding out how “essential” some of these institutions really are. During this shutdown, besides these workers unfortunately not being able to work and get paid, normal life is still going on. Actual essential things are still happening. Armageddon is not happening. Sure, forms are not getting stamped in triplicate, and inspectors are no longer inspecting inspectors, but these are “paper and ink” problems.
As a taxpayer, I see that life is still going on while these jobs are not getting done and I might eventually ask, do these jobs even need to exist? What about my life changes if that stack of papers no longer gets stamped and moved into another stack?
- barrkel 8y agoSure. And then you find out your kids get cancer 10 years later and you wonder why nothing was done about all that toxic waste?
- slg 8y agoThe comment that started this thread mentioned how the shutdown is creating an environmental ticking time bomb in back of their shop. Just because you personally don't immediately feel the repercussions of the shutdown doesn't mean those repercussions don't exist.
- rudedogg 8y agoI think their point was that the ticking time bomb is only caused by regulations, which they can no longer comply with. The situation would be better for them if they could just get the oil recycled from their typical tank, but they need approval for that, so they are falling back to using drums in the parking lot. I doubt any of us trust companies to do the right thing most of the time, but I think we all agree some regulations are dumb, and a loss for everyone except the people whose jobs depend on them. For clarity, I have no idea if the tank inspection is a dumb regulation. And I realize without the regulations, they'd probably be dumping the oil behind the shop somewhere which we obviously don't want.
- ryandrake 8y agoExactly. OP physically can get their oil recycled. The only reason they are not doing it is because the law requires an inspector to come and inspect and tick a checkbox. Without that requirement, there would be no ticking time-bomb. They could just recycle the oil, buy new supplies, and life could go on. Same for the TSA. If the TSA disappeared overnight, we’d just get on airplanes and fly to our destinations like we did before they came around. We have long lines not because there are fewer agents, but because the law says an agent must process you and there are few agents.
- dwaltrip 8y agoIf the regulations were abolished, some companies would just dump the harmful waste products. Negative externalities are a real thing. Obviously, regulations can cause problems or have significant issues, so we should continually modify them as necessary, to the best of our ability. This includes removing them if they aren't beneficial, or creating new ones.
- brewdad 8y agoThe reason that person needs to come tick that checkbox is because less ethical businesses have shown time and again that they will dump the oil wherever is cheapest/easiest if there is no oversight. Same with TSA. While they aren't perfect, we don't have bimonthly hijackings like we did 40-50 years ago.
- freedomben 8y agoYou realize TSA didn't even exist until George W. Bush in 2001. It's also not unheard of for TSA to screw up[1]. I'd also be very interested in where your data of "bimonthly hijackings" comes from. [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/nightly-news/video/atlanta-tsa-officers-fired-after-passenger-took-gun-onboard-flight-to-tokyo-1425774659803 https://www.nbcnews.com/nightly-news/video/atlanta-tsa-offic...
- slg 8y ago
- jkaptur 8y agoDo you think that failing to do essential work always has an immediate consequence that's visible to you personally?
- ashelmire 8y ago1) Remember that many (almost all) government employees are working for free right now. So basically, those individuals are suffering so that you do not. 2) Many government agencies exist to do things that may not affect you personally. NASA does not do anything you'll be affected by - neither does law enforcement. Or border security. You probably wouldn't notice if your local fire department vanished for a few weeks. Until, of course, your house is on fire. 3) Those things that affect society as a whole (like... EPA inspections) take a long time to affect society but have huge costs down the road if not done (good luck cleaning up water sources, or dealing with your cancer caused by your poisoned soil). 4) Airports are starting to be affected first because these are among the lowest paying federal positions, so those employees are going to have to find other work the fastest.
- komali2 8y agoThe US Economy is losing points, fast. You will feel this shutdown. You haven't yet because macroeconomics and bureaucracy happen on scales longer than a month. You'll feel it in the missing percentage gains this year for your investment portfolio (or its complete annihilation if the contraction turns into a depression). You'll feel it later this year when you try to sort some federal paperwork and it takes them 3 weeks longer than normal because everyone at the department is a brand new employee, or they never managed to recover headcount because nobody wants to work for the Fed anymore. You'll feel it when you head to Joshua Tree and it's missing a couple more trees than it should be, and they haven't yet managed to scrub off all the spraypaint. Give it time. You'll feel the pain.
- anth_anm 8y agoHow long til people quit getting food stamps? I can have an unpaid TSA agent at the airport though, so I guess everything is fine.
- proactivesvcs 8y agoIt seems starkly short-sighted to infer that institutions like the EPA may not be "essential" when the anecdote you're replying to shows that they're stockpiling waste fuel. I would think such an act is dangerous in several respects. I think that the original commenter is trying to say is that it's possible that their jobs won't be done if their shop has to close. They're already being impacted: their work time is being wasted. That makes the business less profitable and eventually this could affect everyone that works there. Some of the jobs that "need to exist" are not people who work for the government.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- oliveshell 8y agoGood question. Government waste is frustrating as hell to me as a taxpayer. I believe, however, in spending money to protect our quality of life in the long term. For instance: If the EPA and all environmental legislation ceased to exist tomorrow, you wouldn’t be able to tell in a month, or even a year. You would notice if in ten years’ time your kid got lead poisoning from swimming in the local river.
- wwweston 8y ago> I see that life is still going on This may be something like the idea that life still goes on while you have 10% kidney function and for a certain amount of time after liver failure. Even when a system hasn't outright collapsed yet, that doesn't mean it isn't compromised or even approaching failure. The grandparent comment describes a situation for handling waste, waste that has serious impacts on the health of the environment. That's what you reduce to "paper and ink," so I'll assume you're part of the crowd that generally trivializes environmental concerns.... as if they've forgotten this is where they live and the food chain is how they eat. And then one day we wake up and it's perfectly normal to have a conversation about limiting our consumption of tuna and other fish because of mercury levels they contain as a consequence of uncontained industrial activity. Because we forgot that we're part of a system. Not surprising to see people do... but it is a little surprising to see it pop up on HN. Speaking of the food chain, here's some fun food for thought: https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/lifestyle/food-and-cooking/sns-dailymeal-1968895-eat-avoid-these-foods-during-government-shutdown-011119-20190111-story.html https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/lifestyle/food-and-cook... Planning on flying anywhere? https://www.iheart.com/content/2019-01-04-air-traffic-controllers-union-warns-shutdown-is-making-air-travel-unsafe/ https://www.iheart.com/content/2019-01-04-air-traffic-contro... How sure are you that these jobs don't need to exist? These are just two examples. How sure are you that you really have any idea what the government does? Are you the kind of person who just deletes large swathes of code from a system because they're ugly, because they don't fit your aesthetics, because you're not sure what they do and you'd rather just re-write than find out?
- peteretep 8y agoIf you're driving on the freeway and your car suddenly runs out of gas, the fact your vehicle keeps moving is not a sign that your car only optionally needs gas.