> This reads like some weird gotcha journalism... in The New Yorker of all places. Why is that surprising to you? It's amusingly similar to the discussions he

> This reads like some weird gotcha journalism... in The New Yorker of all places. Why is that surprising to you? It's amusingly similar to the discussions here about astronomy: based on observations and predictions, if one were looking for gotcha journalism, one would probably point a telescope for the gotcha wavelength at the New Yorker.