3 ms·
I wonder if it would make more sense to instead of having the UK leave the EU, have England and Wales leave the UK with the UK (Scotland, Northern Ireland, Gibr
by tzs 8y ago
I wonder if it would make more sense to instead of having the UK leave the EU, have England and Wales leave the UK with the UK (Scotland, Northern Ireland, Gibraltar) remaining in the EU.
That would certainly seem fairer to the Scots, who rejected their independence vote largely because they weren't sure that they would be able to remain in the EU if they left the UK.
- robert_foss 8y agoFairer, most definitely. But also something that would be undesirable for the UK.
- bogle 8y agoNot if you live in Scotland would it be undesireable so it can't be said that it would be undesireable for the UK, just for unionists.
- DanBC 8y agoThat would create nightmare borders.
- bogle 8y agoNot as much as the British border in Ireland, i think.
- piokoch 8y ago"they weren't sure that they would be able to remain in the EU if they left the UK" - to be more precise, they were 100% sure that they will never be allowed into EU, Spain would never agree for this, as this would open path for Catalonia to leave Spain and join EU.
- cm2187 8y agoWhy Scotland? Why not go into every village and have them in the EU or out depending on how they voted?
- bogle 8y agoScotland is a nation state, in a union with other nations. I'm sure you are aware of that so I'm not sure of what point you were trying to make.
- spinningslate 8y agoA great example of the fundamental schism here. We've already had a Scottish referendum, indicative of long-standing friction between Scotland and the rest of the UK (primarily England, arguably more specifically "the South" of England). Whilst passionate, that was at least executed with some level of respect and decorum. Brexit has driven another, othogonal, wedge through the UK population. In fact it's quickly becoming several: remainers, "soft" brexiteers, "hard" brexiteers and various flavours of each. In comparison with the Scottish referendum, it has been marred by illegal campaigns, fanciful claims and a complete lack of accountability by the main protagonists. It has also split the political spectrum in 4: the pre-existing left/right split, and now a horizontal brexit/remain split. Each of those quadrants is moving away from each other, creating a sanity void in the middle. That, in turn, is being amplified by media gorging on the extremist personalities (Reece-Mogg etc.). I live in Scotland. I have never felt less represented by the Westminster Government or Parliament. My personal values are far more aligned with those of the wider Europe. So I am emotively attracted to solutions that see Scotland retaining affinity with Europe in preference to the neoliberalism that seems inherent in Brexit. And yet, I also know that some kind of European Border between Scotland and England is as impractical and damaging - both economically and socially - as a hard border between the UK and Europe. The entire situation is a mess that is destructive, damaging and divisive. Whatever the outcome, the social and political rifts will take years to heal. Which is appalling in itself. It is unconscionable in a wider context where the big questions of global warming and globalisation are the real challenges we should be confronting. I have never felt so angry at, and unrepresented by, Westminster politics.