3 ms·
The referendum was a vote to leave; reasonable people can disagree about what form that should take but the referendum result clearly rules out remaining in the
by lmm 8y ago
The referendum was a vote to leave; reasonable people can disagree about what form that should take but the referendum result clearly rules out remaining in the EU, in the most simple of terms.
May has negotiated the only practical set of terms. If Corbyn was as serious about ruling out a no-deal Brexit as he claims, his party would've voted for May's deal. The part I find incomprehensible is that the remain lobby refuses to acknowledge that if we vote down every possible deal then the result will be no deal.
- KnightOfWords 8y agoNo-deal is the least popular option among voters, given the high risk of tanking the economy. If the government and parliament can't agree a deal I think the only sensible way forward is another referendum.
- nicolas_t 8y agoAt this point, they should just do a new referendum to ask if people really still want to leave. I'm rather sure that the stay would win
- lmm 8y agoAnd if the public keeps giving the "wrong" answer do we keep holding more referenda until they give the "right" one? To do a new referendum when the first one hasn't even been implemented makes a mockery of the whole thing.
- zeveb 8y agoThat is the traditional EU approach, c.f. the Constitution of Europe, Treaty of Lisbon and so forth.
- jenscow 8y agoUnfortunately, there isn't enough time.
- jamiethompson 8y agoIt won't happen but I agree. It's like asking someone if they want to go out for dinner, then finding that the only place open is a place with a zero star hygiene rating. At that point it's reasonable to ask, "shall we just stay home instead?"
- verytrivial 8y agoThe 2016 referendum was flawed in its formulation and execution, and was itself already the 2nd referendum on the topic.
- lmm 8y ago> The 2016 referendum was flawed in its formulation and execution Agreed, but having asked the question and got the answer we have to implement it if democracy is to have any credibility. > and was itself already the 2nd referendum on the topic. Hardly. The EEC was a very different institution from the EU (indeed I'd say the closest modern equivalent is the EEA or EFTA).
- jcranmer 8y ago> Agreed, but having asked the question and got the answer we have to implement it if democracy is to have any credibility. To paraphrase a famous quote, democracy is not a suicide pact.
- lmm 8y agoThere is indeed precedent for suspending democracy in times of war. Suspending it over customs arrangements seems a little more dubious.
- jcranmer 8y agoDirect democracy does not scale to running a country. Effectively, the task of making, deciding, and implementing policy is very much a full-time job, and most people cannot devote the time it takes to be sufficiently informed to make decisions. Decisions that require a lot of careful policy crafting and negotiation to implement are not good candidates for referendums, especially when the cutoff is as low as 50% + 1. In jurisdictions with saner direct democracy mechanisms (say, Switzerland), there is substantial filtering of any proposals through the regular legislature process so that referendums are less "implement this policy" and more "this is something that is important to us, please figure out what needs to be done here." With respect to Brexit in particular, the government made a grave error in triggering Article 50 prematurely. May then called an early election to strengthen her negotiating position which actually weakened it instead. There is substantial cover for saying "We clearly need more time to figure out how to do this, and the March deadline is too soon to get this done. Let's pause this process for now." Sure, a lot of people will be pissed, but we're at a stage where any action (including inaction) will piss off at least 30-40% of the population.
- marmada 8y agoThe referendum wasn't binding in any form. It's also clear that there was a lot of misinformation during the original referendum, and that Brexit is going to be very different from what much of the public imagined it to be. Now that 16-17 year olds can vote, I'm sure e the referendum would have ended up much differently. At the very least there should be a second referendum, but even better, the referendum should be discarded completely--there's a reason things like constitutional amendments require 2/3rds majority in the U.S.
- lmm 8y agoThere was never a 2/3rd majority for joining the EU; IIRC opinion polls have generally hovered around 55% approval at the best of times. If leaving is such a major constitutional change to require a 2/3rds majority, surely entering was too.
- raverbashing 8y agoThanks for exemplifying all the naivety of leavers Before the referendum Norway "was out" and it was all good for them, recently any form of CU agreement is "in" (like May's deal). Funny how leavers forget that, seems like comprehension of anything besides "in" or "out" is too much for them. "result clearly rules" hilarious, just hilarious. Even Farage said a close result would end up in more discussions. But of course they like to "forget" that. We agree on Corbyn being a waste of space though.
- jamiethompson 8y agoAlso don't forget that "No deal is better than a bad deal"
- lmm 8y ago> Before the referendum Norway "was out" and it was all good for them, recently any form of CU agreement is "in" (like May's deal). It wasn't leavers who voted down May's deal. Or do you think Parliament has a 230 majority for leaving with no CU agreement? A 230 majority de facto voted to leave without a CU agreement. I don't know which possibility is more worrying: that they did so by mistake, or that they did so on purpose.
- raverbashing 8y agoIt was leavers (just check how the DUP and Tory brexiters voted) and some remainers together that voted down that agreement > Or do you think Parliament has a 230 majority for leaving with no CU agreement? Well, at least against that deal, that is a fact, more than 400 votes were against May's deal.
- lmm 8y ago> Well, at least against that deal, that is a fact, more than 400 votes were against May's deal. Do you think there is any deal that the remainers who voted against May's deal would vote for? Do you think they want a no-deal outcome? Do you think there's any other plausible outcome?
- matthewmacleod 8y agoI don’t really agree with this analysis. A vote was held, and the decision was to leave. That’s fine - we should not have run that referendum in the form it was, but we can’t deny the result. The problem is, Brexit was an entirely empty vessel into which voters’ fantasies were poured. The outcome in no way resembles any of the ideas that were articulated before the referendum. There is now a concrete plan that basically everybody hates, because it’s the worst of both worlds. There are three realistically possible options right now. The UK either exits with the agreed deal, exits with no deal in a disorderly fashion, or cancels Brexit and remains in the EU. The first option is bad because nobody wants that deal. The second is bad because it would be obviously catastrophic. The third is terrible because it directly contravenes the outcome of the referendum. In short, all the options are fucking awful. There’s no real democratic legitimacy for any of them. Under these circumstances, having a second referendum that says “this is what we were able to negotiate, now do you want to go through with it or forget the whole thing” is possibly the least shit option. I hope it will be cancelled, but at least if it’s not I can be sure that it was voted for with knowledge of what was to come.
- lftl 8y agoWhy not just accept the deal, and then negotiate better terms down the road? Is there something binding in it that would make it hard to renegotiate once the pressure of the clock has been removed, and you possibly have better leverage?
- roywiggins 8y agoOne binding piece is the "backstop", which is in there to guarantee no hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. It essentially forces the UK to remain in the customs union if they can't work something else out with the EU. There are many and various extremely good reasons for the backstop, but its very existence is anathema for many Brexiters, since it would force the UK to follow EU regulations indefinitely. Alternatively, the UK could put a customs border in the sea between NI and the rest, but that would put NI in a different regulatory regime, and that's anathema to the Tories' partner in government, the Northern Irish DUP, which will not accept anything that could move NI closer to the RoI. So 1) most Brexiters don't like a customs union and don't care about NI 2) the DUP don't want any borders on either "side" of NI (but want Brexit anyway). https://www.apnews.com/eb12b6eb1da3436cba22bd64de6d9ec8 https://www.apnews.com/eb12b6eb1da3436cba22bd64de6d9ec8 The actual contours of the UK/EU relationship after Brexit would otherwise be mostly up for negotiation. If you didn't mind a possible permanent customs union, then exiting with May's deal followed by a bunch more negotiations would seem like a sane thing to do...
- simion314 8y agoThe problem I see is that some people voted leave but they were promised some things, probably there are a few camps that each want a different thing, if the referendum had details like leave with condition 1, leave with condition 2 etc then it would be clear what is the will of the people. It is not the will of the people if the chosen leave option is the one liked by a small group, it is the contrary.