3 ms·
> I think this notion that trying to help people, sacrificing yourself to help people was a sickness became very widespread, especially in the ’70s and ’80s und
by paganel 8y ago
> I think this notion that trying to help people, sacrificing yourself to help people was a sickness became very widespread, especially in the ’70s and ’80s under the better-known term codependency. It’s part of our now unconscious culture, the way we look at altruists. When we hear about them, many people think first, “Are they sick?”
I personally wouldn't go that far as calling a person "sick" for being extremely altruistic but it is generally well-known that gifts/free things are never really "free".
For a sociological view on gifts/altruism not being genuinely "free" there's Marcel Mauss's classic "The Gift" [1], while from personal experience I can tell that I used to be taught by both my peasant Eastern-European grand-mothers to never accept free stuff from our neighbors (like going to eat at their place or something similar), the reasoning being that those neighbors would most certainly want something in return at some point in the future.
In a similar vein there's this Seinfeld season 3 episode called "The Pen" [2], where Jerry accepts a "free" pen as a gift from one of his parents' neighbors and, obviously, that turns out not to have been the best idea.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Gift_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Gift_(book)
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pen
- moopling 8y ago'it is generally well-known that gifts/free things are never really "free"' Although for some definition of altruism, this could always be argued to be true, I think this misses some nuances. If you give to charity (say with motivation being a relief from guilt or a feeling of social duty), I think most people would consider that an altruistic action. In that situation, you have no real expectation of future return, so I would say the gift was "free". Or similarly, when you care for a dying relative, there is often no expectation of benefit other than from the act of giving itself.
- paganel 8y ago> Or similarly, when you care for a dying relative, there is often no expectation of benefit other than from the act of giving itself. In doing so you may inadvertently "program" your children/younger relatives to also take care of you once you get older, by the power of example. There's of course nothing wrong with that, because that's how human society has worked for millennia until very recently (when we've started outsourcing elderly care outside of the close circle of relatives), I just wanted to point out that there are a lot of costs and benefits "hidden" in humans' social interactions which are not easily identifiable by the modern eye.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoWhat about people who don't have children or younger relatives? I agree that there's plenty of side-benefits, but I think the distinction between "business" and "altruism" is that altruism happens when people don't calculate those side benefits explicitly. Of course, we're talking about a spectrum here, not binary thresholds.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> from personal experience I can tell that I used to be taught by both my peasant Eastern-European grand-mothers to never accept free stuff from our neighbors (like going to eat at their place or something similar), the reasoning being that those neighbors would most certainly want something in return at some point in the future. Isn't this essentially antisocial advice? That is: society is literally built out of these types of exchanges. I help you in your need, you help me in my need later. I do something nice for you, you do something nice for someone else, someone-{n}-else does something nice for me. Gifts stop being gifts when strings get attached explicitly.
- paganel 8y ago> Gifts stop being gifts when strings get attached explicitly. It's already very difficult to get out of that stupid "Secret Santa gift" tradition that has encompassed most of the world's corporate offices, i.e. gifts that almost nobody really cares for, which are not given with "strings" attached, but you'd have to be a very brave individual to say to your office colleagues "hey, this year I'm not going to play this Secret Santa game". You can sort of also see this in action in the FOSS world. Most of the FOSS code doesn't have anything in its license on the lines of "you should not criticize the makers of this free software" but, nevertheless, I have met lots of cases (and it has happened to me, too) of FOSS users being reprimanded by the code's creators for daring to say that some things don't work as they should, with replies such as "it's free code! If you care so much about it why don't you contribute back?".
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> It's already very difficult to get out of that stupid "Secret Santa gift" tradition that has encompassed most of the world's corporate offices, i.e. gifts that almost nobody really cares for, which are not given with "strings" attached, but you'd have to be a very brave individual to say to your office colleagues "hey, this year I'm not going to play this Secret Santa game". I think it's because a lot of people see this as an externally imposed custom, the kind of "teambuilding" bullshit in which you technically don't have to participate, but will earn negative social points if you don't. I dislike Secret Santa too. I have no problem buying someone a gift just because I like them, but being forced to do that by external circumstances feels just wrong. BTW. this applies to Christmas as well. I don't think I've ever seen or heard of a more "joyful holiday" which so many people secretly hate. It's that one time of the year where cultural norms force everyone to pretend to be super-nice to each other. Those are some observations, but I don't have any clarified opinion on whether customs like these are net good or bad. But they seem to turn into strings for many. -- RE FOSS and reprimands, a lot of this feels like an issue of temper and personal manners - which many don't have[0]. Also, FOSS creates a peculiar type of self-imposed burden on creators. You're not just giving a piece of software away, you start to feel responsible for maintaining and troubleshooting it. If you don't have time or will for that, you'll fall behind, and as issues start to pile up, you can start to feel bad about yourself. I regularly feel bad about a bunch of outstanding tickets I have on a small animated cat for Emacs, a joke project I made 8 years ago. I can easily imagine how overwhelmed people can start lashing out, when a ticket description or a comment pushes them over the edge. It takes some self-reflection and maturity to recognize that most of the problem here is self-imposed. Human psychology is weird. -- [0] - In "How to Stop Worrying and Start Living", Dale Carnegie makes an observation that expecting gratitude is a fool's errand, and if you predispose your gift-giving on expectations of gratitude, you'll be unhappy.
- leesec 8y agoThis is kind of cynical I think. Lots of people donate to charity with nothing in return. Personally I donate 5% of post tax income to charity and I've never gotten a thing out of it other than a thank you email from the charities. People might think, "oh, you just do it for the Good Person Status Points it gives you when you mention it", or that, "you just do it to make yourself feel good". The second one may be partially true, but the first one I don't care about at all and I highly doubt anyone has ever cared or even remembered, though I do like to mention it to encourage others to give. I really just think I was blessed to be born with this brain and in this certain predicament where I have extra money, and I should be giving some of that back to the less fortunate, on principle.
- stronglikedan 8y agoI help strangers whenever I can by giving them free things and not expecting anything in return (or even to ever see them again). I've often wondered if I'm being selfish by satiating my altruistic tendencies. I.e., am I doing it for them, or me? I've often also wondered, is it really free to them, or is the "cost" their independence, ambition, and/or sense of accomplishment? Regardless of the answer to either question, I doubt I'll ever stop.