9 ms·
Smaller living space means that you can't save the thing you will need once every five year anymore. A previously adaptive behavior becomes poorly adaptive. Ch
by im3w1l 8y ago
Smaller living space means that you can't save the thing you will need once every five year anymore. A previously adaptive behavior becomes poorly adaptive.
Cheap disposable items. Where before you would have a few hand made item of high quality, you now get a lot of lower quality items. This is partially related to technological advancement. If things become obsolete fast, it doesn't make sense to build with quality. Anyway a consequence is that it's easier to acquire a large amount of stuff than before.
Anti-landfill propaganda. We are guilt-tripped for throwing stuff in the garbage. We are told to dispose of things in very complicated ways and then it may be easier to just not dispose of it.
Breakdown of community and family. Before we might keep things around by giving them away to relatives or friends. There is a satisfaction in passing the torch. But this option isn't as available anymore.
- tjr225 8y agoAnti-landfill propaganda? Do you have any evidence whatsoever that anti-landfill propaganda exists in any capacity? I'm being totally sincere and I'm not angry at you whatsoever...this is just the first I have ever heard of anything like this.
- erik_seaberg 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_waste https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_waste There are cities and companies whose stated goal is to have no garbage service and (somehow) recycle literally everything.
- tjr225 8y agoI'm failing to see how this ideology has invoked any sort of propaganda to suit its goals? They seem like pretty decent goals, too- though my opinions on this aren't really relevant towards whether or not propaganda is being employed.
- vibrato 8y agoReduce reuse recycle
- tjr225 8y agoI can see where you're coming from and it is hard to distinguish from campaign and propaganda but are you genuinely and sincerely suggesting that suggesting that humans "Reduce, reuse, and recycle" Is propaganda? What is the opposite action of that? What is a negative thing one could do counter to reducing, reusing, and recycling? It seems to me that the only propaganda that could come about would be counter to those goals.
- mrob 8y agoIt's propaganda. The correct solution is for the state to tax the externalities and let the free market solve the problem, instead of hoping people will solve it out of ethical duty. "Reduce, reuse, and recycle" instead of taxing waste is just giving the sociopaths/psychopaths yet another advantage. With correctly priced externalities there would be no need for such slogans, because it would be in everybody's best interest to do the right thing.
- ams6110 8y agoThey do both. I pay the city per container to pick up my trash. They also run a relentless "reduce, reuse, recycle" campaign.
- wccrawford 8y agoFrom Wikipedia >Propaganda is information that is not objective and is used primarily to influence an audience and further an agenda, often by presenting facts selectively to encourage a particular synthesis or perception, or using loaded language to produce an emotional rather than a rational response to the information that is presented. Propaganda doesn't have to be negative, it just has to be influential. The "negative thing" about "reduce reuse recycle" is the thing we're talking about here: "Hoarding". It encourages people to keep things they don't actually need or want, which has negative effects on their living conditions and psyches, which in turn can be negative for society in general. I'm sure it's great for the environment, but it's less than great for the humans.
- ironcan 8y agoYour link doesn't support your thesis, and I don't know of any place that have such policy, except probably shitty places that didn't have good services in the first place.
- trevyn 8y agoSee the “Zero waste jurisdictions” subhead: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_waste#Zero_waste_jurisdictions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_waste#Zero_waste_jurisd... Austin, Vancouver, San Francisco, Boulder. Can personally confirm that it’s a big public propaganda and policy thing in SF. You get people spending time washing out their bottles like we’re running out of glass or a place to put it.
- throwaway64738 8y agoMeanwhile others are so desperate for clean water to drink they are desalinating sea water. Humans are very strange.
- acutesoftware 8y agoI worked for a place that removed all bins from peoples desks and offices, so the only bin left was in the kitchen. I suspect the idea was to "remove the bins to reduce waste", but we still ate our lunches and just went for many walks a day to the kitchen. They stopped the policy after several months
- vict00ms 8y agoSame thing happened at an office I worked in: removed personal bins from desks, then returned them after the bins in the kitchen and bathrooms were constantly overflowing.
- thatoneuser 8y agoIt's not propaganda like the govt brainwashing citizens. There are a lot of modern green movements that not so subtly implore you to not throw things away. Maybe it sounds weird to have that stuff called propaganda, but it exists. There are billions and billions of dollars on the green movements and movements don't come without some propaganda.
- darkpuma 8y ago"Reduce, Reuse, Recycle" Classic propaganda mantra. The term may have negative connotations to some people today, but if you're being technical the term is neutral. There is propaganda for bad things, and propaganda for good things. Consider that during WWII, both sides were producing unambiguous propaganda: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_propaganda_during_World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_propaganda_during_Wor... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_the_Soviet_Union#World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_the_Soviet_Union... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_propaganda_during_World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_propaganda_during_Worl... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_Nazi_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_Nazi_Germany The last is obviously where the negative connotations for propaganda come from, but they certainly didn't invent it and the people who opposed them were using it too. Propaganda is just a tool, and like most tools, it's amoral. Neither moral nor immoral. What matters is what you use it for. A hammer is amoral, you could use it to build an orphanage or to hit an orphan.
- jerf 8y agoHow old are you? In the 80s and early 90s, prior to "climate change" pushing out every other environmental concern, there was a big push to recycle due to the "landfills filling up". Accompanying video would be of a bulldozer maneuvering over a field of garbage that extended as far as the eye could see, which wasn't all that far since there were so many piles of garbage. You'd get videos of cities filled with garbage (garbage service strikes were particularly helpful here), footage from the famous Gar-barge [1], and vague intimations that we're all going to be in garbage up to our knees if we didn't recycle more. Random dumping was also quite a bit more prevalent back then, and I recall walking through state forests and just coming across an impromptu trash dump by the locals, so that helped make it feel more pressing. In more modern times, see the movie Idiocracy or the beginning of Wall-E, both of which were at least visually pulling from images floating around in the 80s and 90s, albeit exaggerated. It made for good rhetoric, but ultimately, it was pushed out in favor of the other things you may be familiar with because it's basically ludicrous nonsense. Yes, there are absolutely some tricks to building a safe landfill and it's not free, and the risks need to be accounted for and taken care of, but it's essentially inconceivable that the world could run out of landfill space. (By the time that could happen, the technological landscape must have changed so thoroughly that your other predictions about what could happen are just useless.) The threats basically abused people's inability to think volumetrically, which anybody who has done a pool-building project, or a significant concrete project, or significant landscaping project, or anything else that involves trying to think volumetrically. You learn there's always more volume than you think there is. It's true that if we had to store trash areally, we'd be in some trouble, but landfills are volumetric, and society needs a lot less than you might think as a result. Yes, we have some impressive trash piles here and there, but there isn't all that many of them, and there can't be, because even if we tried to generate enough trash to become a problem with landfills, we'd long since have strangled ourselves on the other problems that would produce. (That is, you think we've got a CO2 problem now, wait until we try to produce 1000x more "stuff". We wouldn't get far enough into that process for the landfills to be our biggest problem.) Energy usage and the corresponding pollution, care about contamination of groundwater and such, and simply straight-up the economic advantages of efficiency are all much better reasons to take good care of our trash and try to extract as much value from every unit of resource we take from the ground via reduce, reuse, recycle before getting the next resource. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobro_4000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobro_4000
- ryanmercer 8y ago>Anti-landfill propaganda? Do you have any evidence whatsoever that anti-landfill propaganda exists in any capacity? For starters "Reduce, Reuse, Recycle" https://www.epa.gov/recycle https://www.epa.gov/recycle https://www.wwf.org.au/get-involved/change-the-way-you-live/reduce-reuse-recycle https://www.wwf.org.au/get-involved/change-the-way-you-live/... https://www.greenpeace.org.au/blog/beyond-reduce-reuse-recycle/ https://www.greenpeace.org.au/blog/beyond-reduce-reuse-recyc... http://www.mygreenapple.org/reduce-reuse-recycle http://www.mygreenapple.org/reduce-reuse-recycle https://www.conserve-energy-future.com/reduce-reuse-recycle.php https://www.conserve-energy-future.com/reduce-reuse-recycle.... https://kids.niehs.nih.gov/topics/reduce/index.htm https://kids.niehs.nih.gov/topics/reduce/index.htm https://www.nrdc.org/stories/reduce-reuse-recycle-most-all-reduce https://www.nrdc.org/stories/reduce-reuse-recycle-most-all-r... https://www.reusethisbag.com/articles/reduce-reuse-and-recycle-tips-for-kids/ https://www.reusethisbag.com/articles/reduce-reuse-and-recyc... http://pantheonchemical.com/reduce-reuse-recycle/ http://pantheonchemical.com/reduce-reuse-recycle/ https://recyclenation.com/2015/05/history-of-three-r-s/ https://recyclenation.com/2015/05/history-of-three-r-s/ https://www.veolia.co.uk/nottinghamshire/recycling/recycle-nottinghamshire/3rs-reduce-reuse-and-recycle https://www.veolia.co.uk/nottinghamshire/recycling/recycle-n... http://www.ecokidsusa.org/3rs.html http://www.ecokidsusa.org/3rs.html Hell they even had a song in a Rocko's Modern Life episode 21 years ago (and every single time someone says recycle my brain goes "r-e-c-y-c-l-e recycle"): "R-E-C-Y-C-L-E recycle C-O-N-S-E-R-V-E conserve don't you P-O-L-L-U-T-E pollute the river, sky, or sea or else you're gonna get what you deserve The ozone is in horrible condition, from fluorocarbons in our atmosphere. they are too small to be seen by normal vision but there's getting to be more of us each year we come from a variety of places like Styrofoam containers & aerosol cans we love to eat the ozone it's our favorite dessert and if you don't have an ozone then the sun can really hurt I must admit we make a lot of garbage this dump is filled up way above the brim if we don't make an effort to recycle the future could be looking mighty grim someone's cutting down the O-town forest it's not enough to sit around and grieve if we don't protect our flora and our fauna then we won't have the oxygen to breathe R-E-C-Y-C-L-E recycle C-O-N-S-E-R-V-E conserve don't you P-O-L-L-U-T-E pollute the river sky or sea or else we're gonna get what we deserve!"
- gwern 8y agoNot a '90s kid, I see: https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/01/01/what-happened-to-90s-environmentalism/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/01/01/what-happened-to-90s-e...
- js2 8y agoThere's definitely stuff I don't throw out when that would be the easiest path because I feel bad about it going to the dump. A dead treadmill with a working industrial motor that I'm trying to find someone who can use the motor. The kids' old swing set with perfectly usable pressure treated pine. All manner of electronic detritus (anyone need a 25 foot VGA cable? How about a 35 foot HDMI cable that's not current spec? Old component cables? An old Dell minitower? Wall wart transformers? ...). Etc.
- baxtr 8y agoI have made the exact opposite experience (friends, family etc), i.e. small space = a few, highly selected top quality items. Lots of space = hoarding of things you might need one day (usually never)
- jacobush 8y agoI read our OP as listing behaviors which may have been productive before, as mal-adaptive in today's society.
- raverbashing 8y ago> hoarding of things you might need one day (usually never) Until you throw it out, then you will need it a couple of days later
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jdietrich 8y ago>it's easier to acquire a large amount of stuff than before I suspect this is the factor. A behaviour that is adaptive in an environment of scarcity becomes maladaptive in an environment of abundance. When my grandmother was a child, practically the only thing that genuinely counted as "garbage" was ash from the fire. Pretty much everything else had a meaningful value. Scraps of paper could light the fire. Scraps of cloth could make a quilt or a rug. Vegetable peelings went to the pigs and not a morsel of edible food was wasted. Packaging wasn't a word anyone was familiar with, but boxes and tins would be saved for re-use. Furniture was repaired and re-repaired until it was only good for firewood. A lot of people were essentially raised to be hoarders, either through direct experience or transmission of those values from their parents. That mindset isn't irrational, but it's a poor match for the 21st century. It's all too easy to lose sight of the purpose of those values and hoard for the sake of hoarding. I think that similar factors explain a significant part of the obesity epidemic. The scarcity-era virtues of clearing your plate and being a generous host become vices in a world of supersized portions and supermarket offers.
- tomastrajan 8y agoThis reuse, repair, until you really can't was still very common in eastern Europe in 1990s, now it's slowly going away ...
- narag 8y agoYour historical explanation is reasonable and rational. The problem is that compulsive hoarders and eaters aren't. I mean there are persons that like to hoard, persons that like to eat much, but the extreme cases involve a personality disorder.
- darkpuma 8y agoIt could be that the hoarders were always present but before modern abundance and throwaway culture, their condition never manifested in a way that made them stand out from everybody else.
- 8y ago
- eru 8y ago> Where before you would have a few hand made item of high quality, you now get a lot of lower quality items. Hand made items didn't use to be of universal higher quality. Just the opposite.
- V-2 8y agoIt depends what we mean by quality. They could be of higher durability (although they didn't necessarily owe it to the fact they were hand-made in and of itself).
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoJane Austen's letters include high praise for a hand-made dinner set her family acquired. You can go and see it at one of the houses she lived in. It looks terrible by modern standards - very poor and rough. Industrial design and production create items with tolerances, precision, and (optionally) durability that are almost completely unimaginable if you're making things by hand. The only items up to modern standards are suits of armour and later clockwork pieces. If you're used to modern manufacturing they look professional. But every element was made by hand - literally hammered or pressed out - and the incredible precision in later jointed pieces is just jaw-dropping.
- Retric 8y agoIt’s generally durability that’s better with modern hand made goods not precision. A soda can for example is very precisely as weak as possible to still be useful. A hand made chair on the other hand tends to be excessively durable.
- eru 8y agoBut that's just a result of economics. You can get excessively durable machine made good as well.
- owenversteeg 8y agoOh come on. There are tons of things that are better handmade even in a modern world. Clothing, high end silverware, tables, rugs, knives, glassware, jewelry and musical instruments off the top of my head. Specifically for many musical instruments, machine-made is out of the question. For example, violins - there's an enormous amount of money to be made, but the entire market is handmade (even the low-end ones are ultimately assembled by hand, at extremely low wages in China.)
- dd36 8y agoAnti-landfill propaganda? Does that go along with throwing things in a garbage can propaganda? Flushing the toilet propaganda? Do people not know the definition of propaganda?
- ams6110 8y agoWhat he means is the guilt trip laid on people who don't recycle. When I was a kid there was no recycling. Everything (except returnable beverage or milk bottles) went in the trash. Now, the expectation is that you will sort your garbage by type and haul most of it to a recycling center where you have to handle it again and put it into designated bins. This is a lot of extra time and work and so some people (I'm one of them) end up with bags and bins full of cans, bottles, and plastic sitting around at home until I can work in a time to get to the recycling center. I go back and forth on recycling or just throwing everything in the trash because it's too much trouble, and as one individual it doesn't really matter what I do.
- dd36 8y agoI’ve never seen recycling presented as anti-landfill propaganda.