5 ms·
Loss of America’s Largest Aquifer – the Ogallala (2018)
- ncmncm 8y ago"Success" seems to mean reducing the decline of the water table from 21 inches/year to 17 in isolated places, with the rest still pumping madly away. If we needed another example of Late-Stage Capitalist Failure, we needn't look far. Fittingly, conflict between Nebraska and Kansas is over water from the Republican River basin.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoOff the top of my head and without source attribution: Over 90% of the land that can be farmed is being farmed. Over 3/4 of that is for livestock feeding. Almost 1/3 of cereal crop grown is for animals. Now is probably a good time to eliminate meat from our diets. And grow more forests and grasslands. Grasslands more than trees will sequester carbon. It’s a different kind of aquifer crisis here in California. We are a desert and places that draw from the fast depleting aquifers will have to deal with salt water flowing back in...that would be a disaster. Ca has 45-50 billion in Ag revenue. That industry would be decimated. It’s staggeringly mind boggling as to how easy it is to sacrifice the commons without any foresight whatsoever.
- someguydave 8y agoI’m sure Republicans love to destroy the commons because they hate farming and making money.
- ncmncm 8y agoExponentially increasing output followed by utter collapse is the characteristic pattern. Of course it is not limited to modern capitalism. Lots of civilizations have collapsed -- just rarely so spectacularly, and never so global, as we have coming. 98% of forest-floor insects in the Puerto Rico jungles vanished. Amazing! 75% of the Great Barrier Reef bleached. But these are just the first cracks in the dam.
- someguydave 8y agoYou should open your mind to new ideas and investigate the link between wealthy market-oriented countries and environmental concern.
- jessaustin 8y agoconflict Nebraska has certain well-understood longstanding obligations with respect to water flowing into Kansas, but that is a normal thing and there haven't been arguments about it since 2002. Kansans learned not to initiate shooting wars with neighboring states back when we burned Lawrence. Nebraska and Kansas have used different enforcement regimes, but a variety of regulatory approaches is one of the benefits of the federal system. It seems unlikely that the aquifer will be restored within the next century, but slowing the rate of destruction is still desirable. IMHO attempting to do it all with well pumping enforcement won't work. A better approach would be to end all government subsidies for USA grain production. Grain farmers would complain, and some would go out of business, but the result would be less intensive irrigation.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI hear you about the ending of subsidies. It is likely one of the first meaningful steps to take to resolve multiple issues we face wrt Ag/trade/aquifer/environment
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoWhat do you think should be done to restore aquifer strength not just in that region but also every where else..like out west in CA.
- hedora 8y agoFor CA, take a look at the ballot initiative that failed miserably in the last election. double facepalm
- jessaustin 8y agoThe California situation is different, perhaps more similar to Arizona than to the Great Plains. IMHO, Arizonans should realize that they have built huge cities in the desert, and consequently should cease irrigated agriculture completely. That would allow some dairy to return to the Midwest where it belongs, but that's a mere aesthetic preference of mine. My thoughts about California are not quite so drastic because the most intensively farmed areas did not start out as deserts. Still, ISTM a proper pricing structure for irrigation water would not result in almonds dominating the southern Central Valley as they do.
- skookumchuck 8y ago> Late-Stage Capitalist Failure Socialist economies have hardly been a model of sustainability and environmentalism. They're much worse.
- stretchwithme 8y agoI don't think it's capitalism. The resource certainly is not property owned and managed for profit. It's a community owned resource whose users aren't paying for what they use. Even if it were owned by a group of 100 people, if all had the right to use as much as they want and it will eventually be used up, the incentives for such a resource make it a tragedy of the commons. It would be better if all the existing users or all the residents of the region became shareholders in a corporation that charged everybody for what they use. Owners have an incentive to not let their resource be all used up at low prices. No, they want to conserve a resource and charge higher prices if they can. The everybody-owns-it model means people only pay for the cost of pumping the water, without any regard for what water will cost once the resource is gone. A resource with sensible ownership, on the other hand, would incentivize conservation, because customers are more likely to pay a price that reflects the future value of the water, not just the cost to pump it. So, no, I don't think the current situation is capitalism. It is a situation that property rights has not been properly applied to yet.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI think you mean Tragedy of the Commons situation?
- stretchwithme 8y agoI fail to see the distinction in meaning. I phrase it the way Wikipedia does. It can happen on the Jersey Shore, I suppose. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
- pygy_ 8y agoThat works fine if the owners are invested in preserving the resource. This doesn't square well with publicly traded companies who have to ensure their operation is maximally profitable in the short term. They'd pump the place dry, then find a way to turn sand into money.
- stretchwithme 8y ago
- masonic 8y ago"Fittingly"? Note that blue California has far more acute acquifer depletion and (thanks to one-party control) has no oil extraction tax... contributing to severe groundwater poisoning in places like Kern county. Coastal CA already suffers saltwater intrusion into groundwater... which, of course, is blamed on global warming instead of acquifer depletion.
- gralx 8y agoWikipedia's article "Ogallala Aquifer" says that its volume has reduced 9% since the 1940s, 3% in the period 2001-2008 alone (32% of 9%). At this rate of depletion, the aquifer has 240 years left, and once depleted, it would require 6000 years to recharge. Assuming that drawing on the aquifer is feasible only at a volume much greater than 1% of capacity, its useful life would be significantly less than 240 years.
- lambdasquirrel 8y agoYou don't have to "deplete" it like so to cause problems. Some areas that are higher up will lose access before others. In some places, wells will have to be drilled deeper, and everywhere, the water table will drop. You can't get something for nothing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- stevespang 8y agoDid not see any mention of how politicians in Texas dealing with this - - - most likely with a big s##t eating grin taking huge bribes from the oil industry so they can pump the Permian basin dry, pedal to the metal, as they say
- arminiusreturns 8y agoLet me tell you about the oil companies. They say they drill the saltwater disposal systems to below the aquifer level so they "aren't contaminating it"... I call bullshit. I think there is more than just water level depletion at risk. And don't get me started on T Boone Pickens and the coming water capitalism boom...
- gonesilent 8y agoYup when you drill through them all you end up connecting the aquifers. Yet it shocks me how all these frackers say it needs more study. US government has Superfund sites with these problems and it's well researched....
- deogeo 8y agoTurn their FUD around on them. If it "needs more study", then ban it immediately until the risks can be better understood. Anything else would be irresponsible.