8 ms·
ArangoDB: Multi-model highly available NoSQL database
- andrewstuart 8y agoI like Arango but these days it's very hard for a database to compete with Postgres which is incredibly powerful. Every time I've bet against Postgres and used some other data storage mechanism, I always come back to Postgres.
- manigandham 8y agoThe main thing to compete on is distributed scale-out and high-availability which PostgreSQL does not have a good answer for.
- lykr0n 8y agoCitusDB for sharding & replication. Patroni & Stolon for automated replication. Not native solutions, but are an answer.
- contrahax 8y agoCitusDB has a ton of limitations on your schema/table structure right now. Over time it has gotten better, so hopefully in the future it will be a true drop-in scale out solution. Specifically some types of relationships + indexes are not supported.
- lykr0n 8y agoOh yeah totally; it's a slow march forward. MySQL Galera took some time before it was ready for serious use, but the fact that it's semi-usable is awesome.
- doh 8y agoTrue, but as you said, the compatibility is quickly increasing. They actually did a great job and there is fairly little that is not compatible, usually on very advanced side (which is exactly what we would love to have), but the team is especially good at what they are doing and believe they will get there sooner than later.
- manigandham 8y agoCitus only does sharding, not replication. Either way, this is a fundamental design limitation with traditional single-master relational systems.
- bsg75 8y agohttp://docs.citusdata.com/en/v8.1/cloud/availability.html http://docs.citusdata.com/en/v8.1/cloud/availability.html
- manigandham 8y agoYea, that's just normal Postgres replication, nothing to do with Citus.
- tpetry 8y agoCitus is doing sharding and replication: Citus will shard your data and place every shard on e.g. 3 servers. So one server dying is no problem because the data is replicated 2 times.
- jbergens 8y agoDo they have ACID transactions around writing to all 3 servers? Doesn't that cause bad performance? You might also end up with a LOT of servers unless you starting sharing servers for different shards (but still with different sets of 3 servers for every shard).
- manigandham 8y agoAh I see that now. However that's not by default and it still only applies to "distributed" tables, not all the data in the database. Combined with a single-master, it's nowhere near the replica functionality provided by natively distributed storage systems.
- 75dvtwin 8y agowhat about PostgresXL. it is a release v behind Postgres. But it has ACID and cluster. I do not have personal experience with it, but would be interested to hear what folks say. Overall, I agree -- PG with JsonB is extraordinary powerful system, covering document oriented and typical row-oriented use cases. PGs ecosystem with external foreign interfaces, and in memory streaming solutions (like PipelineDB) - must be an envy of any other db ecosystem.
- zbentley 8y agoThat's absolutely true. However, most systems that think they need scale-out are either worrying about a problem they don't have yet, suffering performance problems due to poor database design, or have not fully explored logical (dynamic or hash-based) sharding as a solution to their problems. A huge proportion of modern software businesses can run on single-writer RDBMS instances, properly engineered, at a fraction of the operational and implementation cost of a scale-out solution. That applies to hosted and self-managed solutions equally, in my experience.
- zorga 8y agoThe desire is generally for high availability now and ability to scale out in the future; while a single write db is generally more than enough performance wise, it doesn't give you high availability which is the main desire.
- manigandham 8y agoSure, but scale isn't everything. Operations are far more important, especially when you're a small team. Modern distributed databases scale better but also have better replication, high-availability with automatic failover and no downtime, easier upgrades, easier backups, and generally less maintenance. Removing the single-point of failure with efficient distribution while being able to run easily on docker/kubernetes makes a big difference over a single monolithic database server.
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoValid point, for 99% of startups scaling on one machine (todays SSD based multi core, GB memory hardware is very powerful) with read slaves and failover (Patroni) works just fine. Many I meet as a consultant though want to scale out when they have 100 customers.
- thdxr 8y agoPostgres' inability to handle multiple concurrent queries on a single connection makes it a pain when using it for multi-tenant services. With all the SAAS companies out there I'm surprised this issue doesn't get brought up more often
- andrewstuart 8y agoWhy not just open another connection?
- chatmasta 8y agoEach open postgres connection requires about 10mb of memory overhead IIRC
- grumpydba 8y agoThat's why you need a connection pool. That's true for all database systems.
- cbsmith 8y agoNot all databases systems require a connection pool, though it is often a good idea.
- grumpydba 8y agoI disagree. I've faced incidents on oracle/sql server/postgres/sybase instances when several hundreds of connections where spawned. You definitely need to think about pooling fro the beginning of the design of your application.
- cbsmith 8y agoYes, all of those databases allocate query memory for queries at connection time, and consequently don't scale efficiently for large number of idle clients. That's not all databases. Some don't do that. Some don't even do connections period. Connection pools are a necessary work around for a specific design decision with the system software. They can be helpful other problems as well, but they aren't necessarily a requirement.
- pddpro 8y agoAny resources you'd like to recommend to a beginner that comprehensively covers all aspects of Postgres?
- brylie 8y agoPostgreSQL Tutorial covers many fundamentals: http://www.postgresqltutorial.com/ http://www.postgresqltutorial.com/
- porker 8y agoPostgres is powerful, I want a row in a table to have a relationship to one or more rows in _any other table_ in the database, and Postgres can't help with that. That to me is a compelling reason to use something other than Postgres.
- ralusek 8y agoThere are a few solutions to what you're proposing which might help. One solution is to have a generic reference property paired with another indicating which table to reference reference_id: '1234', reference_table: 'posts' reference_id: '4321', reference_table: 'comments' You can still benefit from indexes for joins in the same way that you would with actual foreign key constraints, but the downside with this is that you can't actually apply a foreign key constraint. Another solution you can look into, which I don't have much experience with myself, is table inheritance: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/3074535/when-to-use-inherited-tables-in-postgresql https://stackoverflow.com/questions/3074535/when-to-use-inhe... Another form of modeling the data in such a manner is called Exclusive Arc, which is that you just simply put all of the possible keys you might reference on the table, and add a foreign key on all of them. Then, when you need to make a reference, you just leave all but the one in use on that row as null values. If a "like" can go on a "post" or a "comment" or an "image", you would just have all 3 foreign key columns/constraints on the "like" table. And lastly, and probably best of all, is to simply use 1-2 tables for your entire data model for vertices/edges, and just treat Postgres as a graph database.
- porker 8y ago> One solution is to have a generic reference property paired with another indicating which table to reference > You can still benefit from indexes for joins in the same way that you would with actual foreign key constraints, but the downside with this is that you can't actually apply a foreign key constraint. Thanks, I had not thought JOINs possible on this - how would a query look? I'm guessing it works only for one type of reference_table. > Another solution you can look into, which I don't have much experience with myself, is table inheritance: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/3074535/when-to-use-inhe.. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/3074535/when-to-use-inhe.... Been there, tried it, banged my head on most of these (particularly the FK limitation): https://www.postgresql.org/docs/11/ddl-inherit.html https://www.postgresql.org/docs/11/ddl-inherit.html :) If it was fixed by Postgres it'd be awesome. I've lost the wiki page which was around on the topic, but it was unchanged for ~10 years, so really should've been marked 'wontfix'. > Another form of modeling the data in such a manner is called Exclusive Arc, > And lastly, and probably best of all, is to simply use 1-2 tables for your entire data model for vertices/edges, and just treat Postgres as a graph database. That's what I'm doing, with the 'node' table using JSON to store the node-specific data. I feel sooooooo dirty but it works. Yet to figure out schema evolution of the JSON in a controlled manner :)
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoMy two wishes for Postgres (as a fanboy): 1. Unify JSON and SQL syntax, instead of user->>'email' make it user.email 2. Support sub tables, so I can decide if I want a sub table (schema) or JSONB (schema-less)
- TheJeebus 8y agoProblem is that JSON property names can contain '.', so it would be ambiguous.
- neunhoef 8y agoDisclaimer: I am one of the core developers of ArangoDB and I work for the company ArangoDB. Yes, ArangoDB is young (6 years) in comparison to PostgreSQL (30 years). Yes, PostgreSQL is a phantastic database with an amazing open source community and is not going away any time soon. Yes, PostgreSQL is a good choice for a project in which you need a relational single server database. However, ArangoDB actually has a different value proposition, so in a sense, it is not a direct competitor. ArangoDB is native multi-model, which means it is a document store (JSON), a graph database and a key/value store, all in one engine and with a uniform query language which supports all three data models and allows to mix them, even in a single query. Furthermore, ArangoDB is designed as a fault-tolerant distributed and scalable system. In addition it is extensible with user defined JavaScript code running in a sandbox in the database server. Finally, we do our best to make this distributed system devops friendly with good tooling and k8s integration. Last but not least, ArangoDB is backed by a company which offers professional support. Therefore any well informed decision for a project needs to look at the value propositions and capabilities and not only at the age and experience, which is of course a big argument, since people are - rightfully so - conservative with their databases.
- djupblue 8y ago>is designed as a fault-tolerant distributed and scalable system What is the consistency model and have you validated that it actually works as designed (for example with Jepsen)? I didn't find anything detailed on your website.
- internalfx 8y agoThis is where I went after RethinkDB shut down. The built-in UI is really nice. If you use documents and graphs, take a look.
- janemanos 8y agothe cool thing about Arango is that you can use all data models also in a cluster setting and combine the models as you need. A pretty nice and helpful community around the project as well.
- k__ 8y agoIs it connection based like MySQL and such?
- amirouche 8y agono
- josiahpeters 8y agoThe entire offering looks very compelling. Unfortunately I couldn't get a sense of operational efficiency or performance of ArangoDB in the wild. I couldn't convince our CTO if we adopted this product, would we be trading the extra development agility of the mixed models: graph, aql and kv for an overly complex babysitting problem. Can anyone here speak about their experience using ArangoDb in a multi tenant SaaS product? How is it to manage your own cluster, backups, etc?
- roflc0ptic 8y agoI lead our database team for a while, and picked ArangoDB. We started to regret it pretty soon thereafter. While I was there, we found that our cluster would just die. I think they got put fix in for that, though my memory is hazy. After I left, they came to really regret it. My team was working at scale, and basically found themselves doing QA work, trouble shooting with the Arango team. To their credit, the Arango crew was extremely responsive and helpful. Maybe they've fixed things up since then; it's been a year and a half. At this point, I would hard pass on any database whose name doesn't start with PostgreSQL. Just got burned too hard. Graph databases ostensibly let you write queries that would otherwise be unwieldy, but it turns out PostgreSQL's `recursive` keyword lets you achieve roughly the same things, sans having to learn a whole new query language.
- mr_toad 8y ago> PostgreSQL's `recursive` keyword lets you achieve roughly the same things Or you could run GraphQL on top of PostgreSQL. Just because you can write anything in SQL doesn’t mean you should.
- pluma 8y agoGraphQL has nothing to do with graph queries though. GraphQL is called that because it was created as a query language for Facebook's "social graph". It actually doesn't provide any graph operations or recursion (i.e. you explicitly tell it how many levels deep you want to go). You can provide a GraphQL interface on top of any backend or database, though.
- rishav_sharan 8y agoI used Arango for my hobbyist project and enjoyed it immensely. Aql is an absolute joy. I am hoping that they improve foxx (web server which runs on top of the db) because that would make arango the best tool for my kind of use cases
- pluma 8y agoHi, I'm part of the Foxx team. Out of personal interest: what improvements to Foxx are you looking for?
- Simran-B 8y agoWhy not use Nginx or Node.js alongside ArangoDB? The problem with integrating a full web server is that you don't want the database to wait until some external request carried out by the web server finishes (no blocking). If there was an integrated web server, but fully decoupled to not block the database, then there would probably be no real benefit over running a separate web server on the side.
- maxpert 8y agoSame question I always ask, who is using it in prod? How huge the database size is? I’ve used postgresql with almost 200+ GB size of single table and it works like breeze! What are caveats, traps I should be aware of?
- coleifer 8y agoYes. I'm also curious about what kind of tradeoffs I would be making by choosing arangodb over postgres, etc. For example, with Postgres you have acid but not much in the way of horizontal scale-out. With Redis you have speed (single thread, though), but data must fit in ram. What am I giving up by choosing this DB?
- ahs1200 8y agoIt's a broad band antibiotic. It's meant to be applicable to all purpose databasing. Horizontal scaling is given but you need to reshard your collections. Great, no exaggeration, overall performance and in some special cases better than specialized databases. My 2 cents.
- ahs1200 8y agoJust take it and bombard it with 1TB of generated data. Good test data sets out there too?
- lbj 8y agoAt Sabre we're currently taking a really hard look at https://www.memsql.com/ https://www.memsql.com/. Im not seeing enough strength in the NoSQL paradigme, at least for our use-case, but I'm definitely looking for better and faster management of an arbitrary number of leafnodes and consumernodes.
- dang 8y agohttps://hn.algolia.com/?query=ArangoDB%20points%3E10&sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=story&storyText=false&prefix&page=0 https://hn.algolia.com/?query=ArangoDB%20points%3E10&sort=by...
- Gby56 8y agoI've been using it for personal projects and it's been quite fun ! The comments about Postgres and database XX vs ArangoDB are always the same, this is a choice depending on the use-case, if you have a vague scenario, ArangoDB has good performance on a wide array of use cases. On a personal note, the main downside is not having any ORM for Golang for example, Node.js doesn't have any worth considering too. Python seems to have arango-orm, which makes it simpler for small projects to integrate it. Another improvement could be the graph visualization, simplifying the setup to use another solution would be nice.
- gurpreet- 8y agoI trialled ArangoDB for a short while approximately 2 years ago. I was looking for a graph database to tinker with and learn about. I was pleasantly surprised with ArangoDB. It was really user-friendly and I liked how easy it was to setup when compared to other multi-model databases. Definitely consider it for a hobby project.