5 ms·
Is Google using some subtle permutation on every version of the email sent out? All it would take would be swapping "--" for "...", "ie"/"i.e."/"eg"/"e.g." You
by mmastrac 16y ago
Is Google using some subtle permutation on every version of the email sent out?
All it would take would be swapping "--" for "...", "ie"/"i.e."/"eg"/"e.g." You should probably compare your local copy of an email with someone else before leaking it!
- olalonde 16y agoI doubt there are 23,300 possible permutations. Moreover, I doubt a Googler wouldn't think of this classic before leaking his e-mail. Any other theory? Perhaps no one was fired and it's just link bait?
- rflrob 16y agoI heard from a Googler before the article came out that the leaker was fired. While one could imagine a second, as-yet unleaked email about the fake firing, isn't it much simpler just to assume that the leaker was fired?
- d2viant 16y agoMost likely somebody just forwarded it to their favorite blog, especially if they didn't think the email was confidential. Pretty easy to track outgoing email.
- jedc 16y agoWith "CONFIDENTIAL: INTERNAL ONLY GOOGLERS ONLY (FULL TIME AND PART TIME EMPLOYEES)" at the top it's hard to believe they might have thought it wasn't confidential.
- alextgordon 16y agoAssuming a worst case of two possibilities for each difference, that comes out as ceil(log_2(23300)) = 15 differences necessary. You could easily get that by swapping out words for synonyms (especially if you use more than two synonyms per difference).
- gojomo 16y agoDon't forget unicode homoglyphs, as well. And even if a journalist trimmed whitespace when formatting for publication, they might not have if forwarding back to a Google rep 'for comment'.
- barrkel 16y agoYou'd need over 14 binary manipulation choices, but only about 9 if you had a choice of three. If you include word synonyms in the choices, with over 250 words in the memo, I don't think it's unreasonable.
- lhnn 16y agoHow about summarizing a memo instead of copypasta? Then they'd have to diff the facts to mess you up.
- tedunangst 16y agoA good news source, if there are any left, probably won't run a story based solely on an anonymous tip.
- rflrob 16y ago"Hey Bob, I'm thinking about leaking my email... can I diff it with yours?" The other problem I can see is that there's only 5 or 6 of those points, which would be enough to narrow down the leaker, but not ID them outright. Probably easier (if more evil) to check all the outgoing mail in gmail.
- joshu 16y agoYou can also use trailing spaces. I have done this on the past successfully
- michaelhart 16y agoBut when it's actually leaked and posted, it'll most definitely be trimmed.
- roel_v 16y agoYou could use a pattern of one or two spaces after each sentence. Encode an id in that. If text is copy and pasted and not processed with a s/ / /g, that most likely won't be detected by the copy-and-paster (especially when it's all done in a variable width font).
- roel_v 16y agoLooks like HN does remove double spaces, what I meant was obviously s/[space][space]/[space]/g :)
- modeless 16y agoIt's not HN, it's a feature of HTML. All whitespace characters (including tabs and newlines) are condensed to a single space, and leading/trailing spaces are removed. So if you have a habit of double-spacing after sentences, HTML simply ignores you, unless you use <pre> or .
- 16y ago
- vaksel 16y agoi doubt it's that complicated, they have full control of the mailservers, I bet the person just didn't think leaking the information was that big of a deal.
- chollida1 16y agoWith 23,000 employee's that's alot of permutations for a 3 paragraph email.
- tlrobinson 16y agoOr, you know, run a giant grep on every mail sent to or from Gmail and internal mail over the last 12 hours...