5 ms·
As Dan Savage said, I'm glad to be a man because we seem less complicated (though he was commenting on genitalia). If Wired had a picture of some guy's schlong
by petercooper 16y ago
As Dan Savage said, I'm glad to be a man because we seem less complicated (though he was commenting on genitalia). If Wired had a picture of some guy's schlong on the cover, I wouldn't, as a man, find it "unfriendly." I can't even imagine how it feels to be so intimidated by pictures of other people. Stick goatse on a magazine and it probably wouldn't stop me buying it.
But any decision to stop reading Wired seems wise to me - it has its moments but the odd issues I buy when traveling are packed with gimmicks and populist dross. Pick up magazines like Communications of the ACM instead (sadly not at airport stores) - no gimmicky covers or chesticles in sight there!
- jamesaguilar 16y agoI'm sure you would feel differently if the average appreciation of your gender was for its usefulness as a sex object, baby producer, and/or domestic slave. You would not feel intimidated by your representation in this way because there is such a constellation of social roles for men that are portrayed regularly in the media and other venues. Things are certainly not as bad as they once were for women, but a quick glance at sites like http://bechdeltest.com/ http://bechdeltest.com/ will make it clear that all is not well in the world either. Pardon me if my tone is a bit harsh, but honestly your comment comes off like you think it's pejoratively "complicated" for this woman to recognize and decry the objectification of her gender and its under-representation in a widely circulated magazine. By contrast you seem to feel that men are approbatively "simple" for not worrying about such things. The reality of course is that there is simply less on this front for men to worry about and this has nothing to do with one gender being complicated and the other simple. Perhaps that was not your intent, although I have to tell you that if it was I find it pretty offensive.
- stevenbedrick 16y agoThis. This, this this. That is all.
- ja30278 16y agoI've never understood how it's possible to be offended on someone else's behalf, particularly on a perpetual basis, as your tone leads me to believe you must be. Your pejorative reading of "complicated" is far out of proportion to the original comment. Like it or not, gender differences extend beyond just having different sex organs. Men and women differ in lots of ways, including in typical emotional response. It's entirely reasonable to point out that women may respond differently to visual depictions of nudity in the same way that it's reasonable to point out that they tend to be less hairy.
- jamesaguilar 16y ago> I've never understood how it's possible to be offended on someone else's behalf . . . This may be true (that you don't understand), but I doubt it. If you have ever taken a stance on the wellbeing of people other than yourself, particularly a political stance, or if you have ever defended a friend or family member against an accuser, or any number of other normal human social interactions, then you do understand what it feels like, although perhaps to a different degree than me in this case. And, I also have to point out that whether you understand why I argue about this has precisely nothing to do with the validity of my arguments. > It's entirely reasonable to point out that women may respond differently to visual depictions of nudity Only if it's backed up by evidence and relevant. It is neither in this case. Observing that women are less hairy is a fact, provable, and does not play a role in the argument at hand. Observing that women react differently to nudity than men is wrong on two fronts. First, it may not even be true. Second, in the context of a woman making a political statement about the depiction of her gender, it is a rhetorical device based on a premise of unknown veracity whose primary purpose is to discredit her beliefs to a male audience. It's a variant of "women are irrational, so we don't need to listen to them," albeit less transparently foolish.
- jamaicahest 16y agoThe legal system here in Denmark requires you to be directly involved if you want to bring charges against someone, ie. you can't accuse someone of making racist comments unless they were about you. The law often has flaws and it does not translate directly to being emotionally offended, but it does politically. Disclaimer: IANAL.
- jdp23 16y agoWell said! Guys, if you don't want to give the wrong impression when you're talking about stuff like this, it's a good idea to reread your posts to see if you're projecting your own experiences (and privilege) in situations where it doesn't apply -- or implying that the way men approach things is better than how women do.
- mfukar 16y agoThat's exactly what's being done by women too, in articles like the one posted, and it hasn't stopped anyone from sympathizing or the collective hypocritic outcry of the masses that are offended by public displays of parts of the human body.
- jdp23 16y agoTry reading the article again. She was explicitly writing from her own experiences, not projecting them on others. And her primary point was that Wired doesn't feature women on its cover.
- mfukar 16y agoNo, don't fall into that trap. She was projecting her experiences onto a cover which could be received in many different ways. The way she rejected it as sexist is the result of this underlying process.
- nimms 16y agoOn a level, referring to the role of a mother as a "sex object, baby producer, domestic slave" is pretty flawed where along the way did we lose respect for women who stay at home to raise a family?? also using hollywood movies as a litmus test is pretty flawed...the modern male hardly comes out unscathed either as they're either bumbling, asshole fathers or will do anything for sex.
- jamesaguilar 16y agoThere's nothing wrong with women who want to stay at home. The problem comes in when a woman is not appreciated for anything else.
- nimms 16y agoNo I think it's a problem when women aren't allowed to do anything else.
- jamesaguilar 16y agoYou and I have different standards for egalitarian society. Depiction has an effect on permission.
- Tichy 16y agoIronically, by stating that "usefulness as a sex object, baby producer, and/or domestic slave" is somehow inferior (ok, let's skip the slave), you actually cement the classic world view. Men are usually only appreciated as "providers", and it seems in your world view that is also the only worthy way to be a human being. Good job.