8 ms·
They've been retreating for 15,000 years or more. At what point do we say "this is where they should stop"? The high water mark for inter-glacial sea level is q
by phkahler 8y ago
They've been retreating for 15,000 years or more. At what point do we say "this is where they should stop"? The high water mark for inter-glacial sea level is quite a bit higher that it is now:
https://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/climate-change/changing-ice/high-water-mark https://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/climate-change/changing-ice...
- thinkcontext 8y agoSpeed matters. It makes a big difference if a glacier field providing a large chunk of water for your city disappears over the course of 50 years or 500 years.
- RobLach 8y ago“I’ve been dying since I was 20 so what makes it special now that I have cancer”
- ThomPete 8y ago50 years is still plenty of time to deal with that especially in todays society.
- saagarjha 8y agoThat doesn't preclude us from starting to deal with it now.
- ThomPete 8y agoDealing with what and how and at what price? Should we stop poor countries from using fossil fuels which is what they primarily are using right now?
- saagarjha 8y ago> Should we stop poor countries from using fossil fuels which is what they primarily are using right now? I mean, that would one thing we could work on.
- ThomPete 8y agoSo basically let them starve and freeze so you can feel better about yourself? Or what's your solution exactly?
- saagarjha 8y ago> So basically let them starve and freeze so you can feel better about yourself? This is a strawman argument, and you know it. The rest of the world is hard at work trying to come up with better ways to meet energy needs that have a smaller impact on our climate.
- ThomPete 8y agoNo it was a question and you havent answered it. How do we do that?
- saagarjha 8y agoWe come up with alternative energy sources and implement them, as we are slowly doing already.
- ThomPete 8y agoIf you are talking about wind and sun then they are only providing a fraction of what the world needs right now less than 1%. Even with unheard improvements they wouldn't be getting much above 5%. Don't believe the hype.
- thinkcontext 8y agoThere will be costs either for action or inaction on climate change, economists attempt to put numbers on both of those. Here's an editorial from Nature that introduces a recent study, as well as a skeptical rebuttal. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-05219-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-05219-5 In this thread I've had a hard time figuring out what you mean by "dealing with" the effects of climate change, by mentioning "price" you give some hint that economic analysis. Do you consider this a worthy way of deciding whether to take action or not? It sounds like you've made up your mind on costs, but again, I can't tell.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoYou're far more optimistic than I. What changes have humans made in the last 5 years that indicate we're doing to make a massive turn around? When IS it time to panic?
- ThomPete 8y agoI wish someone would tell me exactly what it is I should be worried about. I get that there will be consequences to climate change that's how it's always been, but nature throws that at us all the time and have always been doing that. If anything we've just become better and better at dealing with it. So I wish someone could provide anything other than speculation here.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoWhat level of evidence are you willing to accept? And how can we do anything BUT speculate on future events?
- ThomPete 8y agoYou don't have to speculate if you can prove it scientifically. Yet this discussion is being had AS IF we are debating what is scientifically true when in fact we are debating which interpretation of the science we should prioritize. If someone can demonstrate scientifically to me that it's a cataclysmic event and that humans have no way of dealing with it you have my attention. Other than that I prefer to worry about the current generations issues not panicking and rushing to conclusions making absurd political decisions like we are doing today, btw decisions that won't actually solve the very problems they are claiming to deal with.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoSo the fact that, while the evidence and scientific consensus is overwhelmingly in favour of climate change causing issues for our planet, and let me be clear it's the mainstream scientific consensus, as we don't have a "this is how it's going to kill us" smoking gun, and we might somehow magically figure out how to save ourselves, it's a non issue? Do places like Flint Michigan not make you think that maybe your hope in the collective power of mankind is a little misplaced? It's well within our means to solve that particular problem, but no one can be bothered.
- thinkcontext 8y agoBut you don't know whether its 10 years or 50. You don't know that if you implement water recycling to replace the glacier water the amount of rain won't also change. You don't know if your city won't be inundated by farmers who are fleeing drought.
- ThomPete 8y agoI don't know if an astroid will hit earth in 10 minutes either. Thats not really a useful way of living life. Guessing what the problem is have never been a good way to spend our resources.
- saagarjha 8y agoThere is little we can do today to prevent an asteroid impact, which is significantly more unpredictable than climate change is.
- ThomPete 8y agoPlease stop yourself. We aren't debating climate change v.s astroid we are debating cataclysmic climate change vs. astroid thats quite a different discussion which is the whole point here.
- ip26 8y agoGlaciers supply summer water. Regardless how you feel about how things "should" be, in practical terms, we have a strong vested interest in their ability to supply water year round, both for our own use and to support local ecosystems that provide us with services. They have high albedo as well; their retreat is decreasing the albedo of the terrain. This isn't their most important feature, but they are a piece in the puzzle of keeping temperatures stable, and stability is good for us.
- ThomPete 8y agoNature has never been stable especially not for humans so that's hardly a useful premise. If anything we have made it more stable because we are better at handling all the things it throws at us. I would still ask those most worried to point to a scientifically demonstrated consequence of climate change we don't know how to deal with or that they believe we won't be able to find solutions for over the next 50-100 years or so. Edit: It's funny how downvotes are being used instead of argument by people I assume consider themselves on the side of science.
- titzer 8y agoYou're being downvoted for trotting out well-worn and eye-roll inducing ignorance. It'd be one thing to approach this conversation with an open mind, but just stating blanket nonsense raises hackles. > Nature has never been stable especially not for humans Yeah, it changes on geologic timescales, i.e. thousands and millions of years. We've subjected nature to catastrophic shocks 1000x faster. It does not respond well. It collapses. We're in the middle of shit storm because of our own actions. It is absolutely not business as usual for Earth. > I would still ask those most worried to point to a scientifically demonstrated consequence of climate change We're not really sure how Earth is gonna function if the oceans are dead and there are no insects, and parts of it are literally uninhabitable for humans because it will be too hot to go outside (~130F). > If anything we have made it more stable Nonsense. We chopped down most of the forests in the US [1] to make farmland. Literally. My home state of Indiana was _literally_ solid hardwood forest 250 years ago. Take a look at it on Google maps sometime. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deforestation_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deforestation_in_the_United_St... Edit: added handy reference
- snowwrestler 8y agoIt's not correct to says that glaciers have "been retreating for 15,000 years or more." It's more accurate to say that there was a major global retreat of glaciers at the beginning of the current interglacial period about 10,000 years ago. But since then, while regions and individual glaciers have experience growth and reduction, the global balance has been relatively stable. In the absence of human activity, we would not be seeing the glacial retreat that we are seeing now. In fact we would expect relative stability until the onset of the next glacial period--then growth. And of course, we care about all this because the civilization we've built is deeply integrated with the current climate, and it will be extremely expensive and traumatic to alter or adapt, especially on timelines as short as 50 to 100 years. Cities that rely on glaciers for year-round water are thousands of years old in some cases. Most of India, for example.