4 ms·
Lomborg's basic position is "Global warming is real - it is man-made and it is an important problem. But it is not the end of the world."
by guelo 16y ago
Lomborg's basic position is "Global warming is real - it is man-made and it is an important problem. But it is not the end of the world."
- uriel 16y agoThis sounds disturbingly... reasonable.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoIt's disturbing to me how much logic, reason, and science have been bypassed in the race to global warming panic. The idea that it's necessary for human civilization to take drastic steps in order to forestall global warming is based on an entire chain of reasoning: that global warming exists, that it is unnatural and anthropogenic, that massively devastating consequences to mankind and the environment will result if AGW is allowed to continue along current trends, and that curtailing CO2 emissions will prevent those consequences and is the best way of dealing with their possibility. Of these at best only the first and perhaps the 2nd could be considered "proven" (though there is still significant debate), but the rest are just assumed, nothing even approaching a robust analysis has been done (sadly Lomborg's work is perhaps the best analysis so far).
- philwelch 16y agoRemember risk management. It doesn't have to be proven "that massively devastating consequences to mankind and the environment will result if AGW is allowed to continue along current trends", it only has to be probable. Likewise for "curtailing CO2 emissions will prevent those consequences and is the best way of dealing with their possibility". It's perfectly rational to curtail CO2 emissions for fear of the consequences of AGW if curtailing CO2 emissions has a high enough EV, calculating this with, of course, the EV of catastrophic consequences to AGW. It doesn't have to be proven if catastrophic enough consequences are probable enough to dominate the EV, even if that probability is less than "certainty".
- TomOfTTB 16y agoBut the question is whether the risk of catastrophic consequences due to AGW out weighs the certainty of the economic impact. Lomborg isn't asking for certainty on AGW (which would be impossible) he's simply arguing the equation has become weighted too much to one side because of fear.
- philwelch 16y agoI agree with you completely. At the root level, though, even that isn't the real question. The real question is: given any particular measure which may impact AGW, what's the EV of that particular measure? For instance, building tons of nuclear power plants has an EV which is affected, but not necessarily dominated, by factors related to global warming. Likewise for measures targeted at reducing car usage. It may be that the typical cap-and-trade or carbon tax schemes proposed to deal with global warming are -EV. That doesn't mean global warming shouldn't inform our decisions.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoYes, the precautionary principle, Pascal's wager. I take it from this that you are a devout Catholic, or perhaps a fundamentalist Muslim?
- philwelch 16y agoWhether or not EV holds valid with risks of infinitesimal probability and infinite cost is an interesting philosophical question, but it doesn't undermine the use of EV to deal with risks of finite cost and probability.
- shard 16y agoI don't think Pascal's wager applied universally across all religions results in a Catholic or Muslim. Maybe an atheist...
- jacoblyles 16y agoSure. It's a numeric problem. The proper question isn't "should we build an asteroid shield around the earth?". If it's free, then yeah we should go for it. But if not, then we should first ask ourselves questions like "how much will it cost?", "how likely is it that an asteroid impact will occur?", "how much damage will an impact cause relative to the cost of prevention?", and "how does an asteroid shield relate to alternative preventative measures?". Lomborg did the math and he decided that policy which focuses primarily on emissions reductions is unlikely to do more good than harm. Though with different assumptions of course you wind up with different conclusions.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoThat’s what I love about Lomborg’s argument. The Global Warming alarmists get by with weak science by saying their preliminary findings appear to be right and there’s no time to debate any further because the world will end if we don’t act now. Lomborg essentially bypasses the science part of that argument and attacks the real issue which is the urgency claim. In doing so he takes away the reasons for politicization of the issue and puts the focus back on scientific study of the problem.
- anthonyb 16y agoThe Global Warming alarmists get by with weak science Meanwhile, the Climate Deniers get by with a jedi hand wave and a "everything's fine, no need to do anything at all" </sarcasm> Strawman much?
- shadowsun7 16y agoThe eminent physicist Freeman Dyson shares this same sentiment: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/29/magazine/29Dyson-t.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/29/magazine/29Dyson-t.html (with a few extra, weirder, ideas, of course).