3 ms·
In general, GM is just another tool for the organism designer. It gives the designer more flexibility and speed than traditional techniques, but whether its use
by tzs 8y ago
In general, GM is just another tool for the organism designer. It gives the designer more flexibility and speed than traditional techniques, but whether its use is safe or dangerous, good or evil is not a science question. It's a business question.
This is why I have no inherent objection to GM, but I do want such foods labeled so that I can avoid such foods from companies whose balancing between their business needs and my health and nutrition needs I do not trust with the increased power that GM gives them.
- drugme 8y agoWhy is "whether its use is safe or dangerous" not a science question?
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI think GP's view is this: science is about expanding the space of possible choices. Business is about making the choices. "Safe" and "dangerous" are adjectives referring to concrete choices in context of their application, therefore a business question. I believe this view is correct, and I share it, but with a caveat that labels are flexible and context-dependent. People believing GM is itself dangerous and bad are just victims of ideology. But other people saying GM is dangerous actually mean concrete instances of applying GM methods - i.e. they're really criticizing a bunch of business decisions, but doing it in an ambiguous way. Therefore, for the cases where you actually care about other person's opinions, it's worth to dig deeper into what they actually mean and why.
- akvadrako 8y agoThat only makes sense if we label foods with every step of their production and the labels would become large documents. There is nothing special about GM which warrants a special label. GM is probably much safer than mutation via massive radiation - but nobody is asking to label that.