5 ms·
Before anyone breathlessly gushes about their life-changing fasting regime, remember that this study was done on mice.
by paulcole 8y ago
Before anyone breathlessly gushes about their life-changing fasting regime, remember that this study was done on mice.
- krat0sprakhar 8y agoAnd for only 24 hours of fasting. I wish we could get more scientific literature on the 16:8 fasting cycle.
- chillacy 8y agoMice have fast metabolism, so 24 hours of fasting for them is more than 24 hours for us.
- tdburn 8y agoNow that the 16:8 fasting method is becoming more popular, more research is being done specifically for that regimine.
- Jach 8y agoOn more than mice? I'm pretty sure such research has already been done a lot on mice, I've been hearing about positive intermittent fasting / caloric restriction studies for years (but it's always in mouse models).
- aaroninsf 8y agoI wandered into 16:8 as part of general cargo ship steering towards better health/fitness. Used as just one aspect, along with: going cold turkey on snacking at work, switching to black coffee, and doing some daily simple fitness basics (pushups and the like), and ongoing bike commuting [prior to calorie consumption] the consequences over the last 18 months have been dramatic. The main reason 16:8 IM helped with significant weight loss for me is certainly the "side effect" of significantly reduced caloric intake (thank you CICO). Normalizing to two meals and much reduced snacking has made a ton of difference. So much so that when I hit my semi-formal "target" (midpoint of the "normal" BMI weight range for my height) I think I am going to have to get conscious about getting enough healthy calories to maintain muscle etc. I try to make slightly more sensible choices, and exercise some mediocre "portion" control... but haven't switched diet to speak of. I am a convert. I can see that it's not magic, but, for me at least IM as part of a broader modest trajectory change is turning out to be honestly life-changing.
- 8fingerlouie 8y agoI've been doing 16:8 for decades without knowing it was a thing :) For me it basically burns down to skipping breakfast, eating lunch at 12:00 and dinner at 18:00, and that's it. I did 5:2 for 3-4 years as well, and lost 20kg (~44 freedom units). I did 36 hour fasts, and after a while it just felt naturally, but i'd be lying if i said the fasting days were easy. It gets "easier" but never easy. I usually took a break from fasting during holidays, and a few years back i never really got back into it, and reverted to my old 16:8 ways. I'd love to see more research on it, but from my own experience, it's nowhere as effective as a regular 5:2 diet.
- porpoisely 8y agoNot only that, more often than not, it turns out that the original claims turn out to be false or negligible at best. The latest weight fad was intermittent fasting. Turns out it isn't any better than any other weight loss regime. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18537250 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18537250
- chlvsl 8y agoAs the title says, it improves overall health. Nobody mentioned weight loss. From the article, "...optimal fasting in a timed manner would be strategic to positively affect cellular functions and ultimately benefiting health and protecting against aging-associated diseases." If you really want to lose weight - stop eating.
- nonbel 8y agoI don't know about intermittent fasting, and don't feel like checking your source at the moment. But I know in the case of "low-carb" diets the people publishing research articles on it made up their own definition that has nothing to do with what people actually call "low carb".[1] So the track record of people who study diets is abysmal in my experience. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18453665#18457257 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18453665#18457257
- jplayer01 8y agoThe amount of decent studies on actual low-carb diets is near non-existent.
- nsxwolf 8y agoPerhaps the headline should have been "Fasting can improve overall health in mice".
- amatern 8y agoThere have been studies on people as well, with encouraging results: http://stm.sciencemag.org/content/9/377/eaai8700 http://stm.sciencemag.org/content/9/377/eaai8700 as well as https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1550413118302535 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S155041311... Still, more work needs to be done.