4 ms·
What's also interesting is how a casus belli can evolve after a war, when the facts finally become clear. Consider America's entry into World War II. Ask a mod
by sho 8y ago
What's also interesting is how a casus belli can evolve after a war, when the facts finally become clear.
Consider America's entry into World War II. Ask a modern American, or anyone really, what the justification for entering the war was and they'd probably say to stop Hitler. Asked why they'd care about stopping Hitler, and the answer might be that Hitler killed several million Jews. A pretty good reason.
But Americans in 1941 had no idea about the Holocaust. Yes, there had been reporting on persecution of Jews under the Nazis, and there's still controversy over who knew what, when, and how, but in general they didn't know. So why did the USA still go in? Well, no doubt there were still good reasons. But they become a lot less cut and dried when we take into account what was known at the time. The real reasons at the time were geopolitical. Only later did the moral case become obvious, and retroactively applied.
I sometimes wonder what might have gone differently if the Nazis were not quite so cartoonishly and stupidly evil, confining themselves to "just" taking over Western Europe and not trying their hand at genocide quite so enthusiastically, or if Japan had not been so foolish and arrogant as to attack Pearl Harbour. Would the USA have stirred in this alternate universe, if Hitler had one less screw loose and Tojo had one fewer bottles of sake? If not, history could have easily turned out very differently.
- agabara 8y ago> Ask a modern American, or anyone really, what the justification for entering the war was and they'd probably say to stop Hitler. I'm pretty sure this is false and that most people know the US entered WWII because of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoGP's point may be rescued by changing this to: Americans may have entered the war because of Pearl Harbor, but the reason why the Allies were the "good guys" is that they "fought the nazis". The reason why nazis needed to be fought is genocide and concentration camps. But, in 1941, most people didn't know (or believe; reports were coming out since 1930s, but fell on deaf ears) in all the atrocities the nazis committed. Back in 1941, for most countries involved this was just a regular war; the extra moral significance was added post-war.