3 ms·
I work in adtech. This has nothing to do with how effective targeting is, and a single site does not reflect the entire industry when they're all competing for
by manigandham 8y ago
I work in adtech. This has nothing to do with how effective targeting is, and a single site does not reflect the entire industry when they're all competing for the same pool of ad dollars.
There is a massive drop in EU programmatic advertising because of GDPR. Most EU advertisers now buy a few large campaigns with coarse targeting instead, and sites with the biggest reach like NYT will get more money but there's less money in the overall market.
This is another case of regulation benefiting the bigger players (advertisers and publishers). EDIT: curious what downvotes are disagreeing with here.
- thatguyagain 8y agoI don't understand. What stands in the way of a small niche website for, say, dog owners to sell ad space for dog related products without having some kind of data hoarding ad tech behind it?
- manigandham 8y agoBecause advertisers don't want to deal with a bunch of smaller sites. That's why ad networks and exchanges exist, so you can buy a single impression for the right user wherever they are across the web. Take away the fine-grained targeting and you end up with big blind campaigns running on a few large sites with the biggest reach. This is the way TV and radio work, wasteful and expensive but great for the channels that get them.
- mook 8y agoWhy can't middlemen still exist, just without the individual targeting? Can't sites still self-report their categories (so that, say, a dog grooming site would say they should get dog ads)?
- manigandham 8y agoThey can and they do, that's what ad networks are. There are plenty of ways to group sites by category and readership without individual targeting but middlemen add percentage costs to the ad spend which the industry has been slowly pushing out. The bigger issue is that fine-grained targeting is still wanted so if you remove 3rd-party tracking then advertisers will go towards the biggest sites that can supply it via their own 1st-party tracking. Even then it's still hard to work with many vendors so even more of the money is now going to Google and Facebook who can just do it all with better data than anyone else.
- JAlexoid 8y agoFine grained targeting is a myth.
- manigandham 8y agoIt's definitely real and used for hundreds of billions in annual ad spend. Perhaps you're referring to effectiveness, in which case that's dependent on thousands of factors.
- olegious 8y agoThe small niche site doesn't have the resources to direct sell to these advertisers. Also, for most advertisers it is far more convenient to go to a player that can sell them many of these niche sites bundled together on a single order form.
- sbuttgereit 8y agoIf I were buying ads (I've made some micro purchases in the past), I'd also understand that the users of the small, niche website are also likely using the larger websites, too. So the time in researching what small websites exist for my market (say dog owners), the ad cost per buy of making many small buys, the administrative overhead related to maintaining many small accounts (accounting, dealing with many sales people, many platforms to administer, etc) vs. buying ads in greater bulk with a few content providers like the NYT or others alongside pet related stories (or other compatible content) where I'm likely to get most of the niche site users and others that are also in my market that don't use those sites.... seems kinda no-brainer. I also expect data aggregation to continue, even without a focus on "personalized" or "one-to-one" behavioral data. For example the NYT times would likely want to be able to show advertisers that those that read dog articles also disproportionately read articles about outdoors activities... they can produce those metrics within the course of normal operations, I would think, possible even without employing things like cookies for the purpose... naturally the metrics being captured today do have a market value beyond just allowing the collector what ads to show and my suggestion doesn't replace that path, but I expect for just the purpose of targeting ads that's probably more useful anyway.
- Mirioron 8y agoTime. Would you rather deal with one website that gets a billion hits or 1000 websites that get 1 million hits each? Negotiating deals, verifying them and all that stuff costs time and money.
- tboyd47 8y agoI didn't downvote you, but I worked in adtech a couple of years back, and observed the opposite. We saw direct-sold contracts overtake DFP income almost immediately after the team started looking for them. It was a mid-size company (about 1,000 employees). My reasoning on why this is is that networks like DoubleClick don't care or know any of the qualities that raise the value of a particular publication in the advertiser's mind. All you are to them is a blank square above or below the fold on a domain with X monthly uniques. Do you have a source for your claim that there's "less money in the overall market"?
- manigandham 8y agoDirect-sold contracts will always have more income because they are larger deals, the same way TV buys easily reach into millions, but you have to pay for that sales team which cuts into margins so net net can be very different. Advertisers are getting more into programmatic to consolidate their media teams into a few DSPs and strategies because of the targeting and attribution capabilities of digital. My sources are the CEOs of major ad exchanges and the internal discussions with their BD and revenue teams, although there are some posts about it [1]. Europe has seen a big drop in liquidity on open-exchanges and while a lot of spend has shifted to private deals, it's still more labor to setup and and manage those deals so spend is now further focused on Goog/FB and large sites. 1. https://digiday.com/media/google-data-protection-regulation-gdpr-strafing-ad-sellers/ https://digiday.com/media/google-data-protection-regulation-...
- alkonaut 8y ago> This is another case of regulation benefiting the bigger players > curious what downvotes are disagreeing with here not downvoting but I suppose it might be that your post comes across as saying that's necessarily a bad thing. if you need to be a big publisher to mamage doing well-behaved (not ad-net served ads) and you aren't a big player - then my opinion is you should shut down rather than use ad-nets. I don't care whether 80% of content and jobs just disappear in the process. Integrity and privacy are more importanmt than both.
- manigandham 8y agoThe biggest players are Facebook and Google who are further entrenched by this regulation, even though it seems like they were supposed to be the targets. All the other sites suffer as a result, while only large ones like NYT stay viable. Many smaller players are now looking at paywalls or patronage to stay in business. You can easily avoid sites you do not like but I don't see what that has to do with integrity (of what exactly?), or why you think that everyone else would also be ok with losing 80% of content and jobs? Billions of people over decades have shown they prefer free and plentiful content and it's unlikely that is changing anytime soon unless you can somehow change human behavior first.
- alkonaut 8y agoI don’t mind paywalls. I do mind paying with my information rather than with money without being given an option.
- manigandham 8y agoYou have an option: dont visit the site. Nobody is forcing you to read that content.
- alkonaut 8y agoThat assumes I can be aware of which sites do what, to make an informed decision. That would be a great first step but that’s not how it works.