3 ms·
Stupid question: Being that a large fraction of the problematic plants seem to exist close to or within desert countries, couldn't you simply pump it into the d
by xg15 8y ago
Stupid question: Being that a large fraction of the problematic plants seem to exist close to or within desert countries, couldn't you simply pump it into the desert? I figure, if you find an appropriate area, you'll have not much of an ecosystem to destroy anyway and the area could eventually function as an enormous evaporation pond.
- simonh 8y agoIf you're wanting to make fresh water there, it's probably because people do actually live there and want to do other stuff there, so any method of polluting the environment is going to have negative consequences. For example if they are extracting fresh water from seawater, they are probably also already using groundwater as well which your proposal would pollute.
- growlist 8y agoSaudi is enormous - no doubt there are vast expanses completely away from civilisation, and I'm guessing there are plenty of remote oil field areas that are already degraded to some extent. However: firstly as you hint at the desert does have an ecosystem, and secondly salt is not the only contaminant in the sea. I could imagine an Aral Sea type scenario where heavy metals, for example, were evaporated out in significant concentrations over time. Then with a little wind blowing the dust towards populated areas, you are in trouble.
- loudmax 8y agoI think the issue is the scale of the operation. It's not that the desert doesn't have the capacity to absorb brine, it's that pumping all that brine into one spot creates a local ecological catastrophe. To avoid a concentration of toxins you need to spread it around, which is expensive. My expectation is that the brine will have to go back into the ocean. The deserts a big, but the ocean is bigger. What the paper mentioned in the article points out is that you can't dump this all in one place.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- swish_bob 8y agoI think you're underestimating how much of an ecosystem there is in a desert. It's often a fairly fragile one as well.