5 ms·
I don't see the rationale for their claims that the license is non-free? There's nothing discriminatory on the face of it. Plenty of acknowledgedly free license
by lmm 8y ago
I don't see the rationale for their claims that the license is non-free? There's nothing discriminatory on the face of it. Plenty of acknowledgedly free licenses make commercial users uncomfortable (e.g. the AGPL).
- lozenge 8y ago"The freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose" (freedom 0) You can't run it using closed source management software to offer MongoDB as a service.
- lmm 8y agoBy that logic the GPL is also non-free, since you can't run a GPL program embedded in a closed-source management program.
- jerf 8y agoYou own sentence shows the relevant difference: "embedded". The GPL license has always stopped at the OS process boundary. You can essentially do whatever you want with a GPL program as long as you interact with it over standard OS mechanisms, rather than direct modification; you're still obligated to distribute source but it's source that is already publicly available, so there's no proprietary interest in it. Mongo's does not. Neither does the AGPL, to show this isn't new.
- lmm 8y ago> The GPL license has always stopped at the OS process boundary. You can essentially do whatever you want with a GPL program as long as you interact with it over standard OS mechanisms, rather than direct modification Not strictly the case according to the FSF's FAQ; the GPL applies to anything that integrates deeply enough with the covered program to constitute a "derivative work" under copyright law, which is not necessarily the process boundary. > Neither does the AGPL, to show this isn't new. Indeed - so what is RedHat's rationale for permitting AGPL but disallowing this MongoDB license?
- nix0n 8y agoRed Hat Legal feels that AGPL stops at the tarball boundary, and the preamble isn't binding[0](2009). [0]https://www.redhat.com/archives/fedora-infrastructure-list/2009-July/msg00171.html https://www.redhat.com/archives/fedora-infrastructure-list/2...
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The GPL license has always stopped at the OS process boundary No, it stops at the copyright law boundary of derivative work. Whether or not a court would find that to be equivalent to an OS process boundary probably varies by jurisdiction and detailed facts of particular cases.
- klez 8y ago> you can't run a GPL program embedded in a closed-source management program Uh? Of course you can. What kind of scenario are you envisioning that makes running a GPLed software not legal?
- giancarlostoro 8y agoAGPL doesn't target specific users of the software, it affects all users regardless of how they use it.
- klez 8y agoWe're specifically talking about GPL.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoAnd in the parent post in the thread I mentioned the AGPL vs the SSPL. I was adding a contrast of the AGPL vs SSPL.
- toast0 8y agoYou absolutely can run GPL software embedeeded however you feel. You can't distribute it without meeting the conditions, however (and some database software providers think distribution within a company counts as distribution, so there's that) AGPL is a totally different beast.
- DannyBee 8y agoYes, you can. You have obligations if you distribute it. Even the AGPL simply gives you obligations. There have been arguments about whether the AGPL is discriminatory, and those have been mostly waved away (wrongly, i think, but c'est la vie). In that vein, SSPL is arguably a free license. It simply changes when obligations to distribute source occur. Compare to the the commons clause, which is not a free license - it says you have no right to sell the software as a service at all.
- kemitchell 8y agoI completely agree. I would only add that there have also been arguments about whether GPLv2 is discriminatory, though they also feel long behind us now. In case it's interesting, here's my standard reference link on nondiscrimination under OSD 5 and 6: https://writing.kemitchell.com/2018/11/05/OSD-Copyleft-Regulation.html#discrimination https://writing.kemitchell.com/2018/11/05/OSD-Copyleft-Regul...
- belorn 8y agoThere is always a case in which all license will be discriminatory when it comes to "specific fields of endeavor". If the endeavor is to break copyright then a copyright license can't permit that. To take a example, permissive licenses do not allow someone to take full ownership of the copyright of someone else work. As such the Open Source Definition with the phrase "specific field of endeavor" is limited to cover areas which don't involve copyright law. For many reasons, including copyright law itself, it can not grant that which would be the most broad definition of nondiscrimination.
- rcdwealth 8y agoYou can run it. The four freedoms refer to the freedoms when you receive the software. You can use GPL software within non-free management software within your company without problems. What you cannot do with the GPL software is distribute it as non-free. That is all. But how you run it for yourself, from yourself, that is up to you.
- amyjess 8y agoFrom the Open Source Definition: > 9. License Must Not Restrict Other Software > The license must not place restrictions on other software that is distributed along with the licensed software. For example, the license must not insist that all other programs distributed on the same medium must be open-source software.
- tzs 8y agoDoes the MondoDB license run afoul of that? My limited understanding is that the problematic part of the new MondoDB license is a clause that says that if you offer MongoDB as a service, you have to make source for it and all software involved in that offering (such as control panels, management interfaces, and so on) available for download. That doesn't sound like it would be incompatible with section 9 of the OSD, as section 9 covers software whose distribution imposes restrictions on other software. MondoDB's license is imposing a condition based on usage, not distribution, of MongoDB. If MongoDB's license does not satisfy the OSD, I think it is probably section 6 that it conflicts with: > 6. No Discrimination Against Fields of Endeavor > The license must not restrict anyone from making use of the program in a specific field of endeavor. For example, it may not restrict the program from being used in a business, or from being used for genetic research.
- amyjess 8y ago"Other software" also includes "control panels, management interfaces, and so on".
- kemitchell 8y agoIt's very hard to read OSD 9 in context to prohibit SSPL. https://writing.kemitchell.com/2018/11/05/OSD-Copyleft-Regulation.html#contamination https://writing.kemitchell.com/2018/11/05/OSD-Copyleft-Regul... Bruce Perens sees it as N/A for a narrower reason: http://lists.opensource.org/pipermail/license-review_lists.opensource.org/2018-October/003750.html http://lists.opensource.org/pipermail/license-review_lists.o...
- Proven 8y agoAny license that I must understand and consider, makes me uncomfortable. The MIT, Apache 2.0, BSD and such: I go ahead as soon as I see it's one of these. Nothing to be concerned about. If it's one of the fake-free licenses, then I must carefully consider how I might use it both now and later and whether some important details may later change causing me inconvenience. I wouldn't call such licenses "discriminatory", that'd be nonsense. No one is forced to to use software that comes with them.