10 ms·
It seems[0] the new MongoDB license is basically non-free and it would make no sense to include it in RHEL8. I hope Debian and other distros follow suit as a re
by giancarlostoro 8y ago
It seems[0] the new MongoDB license is basically non-free and it would make no sense to include it in RHEL8. I hope Debian and other distros follow suit as a result if they come in agreement. It's sad that the license change all resorts to greed basically, as if Oracle took over MongoDB.
If I were to ever use a NoSQL database for a new project I'd aim for MIT / 2-clause BSD based projects instead. PostgreSQL has no issue being BSD-like licensed (all this time I thought it was BSD or MIT, turns out it's a similar license instead). It saddens me RethinkDB couldn't compete more with MongoDB.
[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18919728 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18919728
- hannob 8y ago> It's sad that the license change all resorts to greed basically, as if Oracle took over MongoDB. It's essentially "we convinced the stock market that our company tripled in value over the course of a year, and now we have to tell them what business model is behind this value growth" [1]. [1] https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/MDB/?guccounter=1 https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/MDB/?guccounter=1
- iqy 8y agoIf the new MongoDB licence is non-free, the chances that Debian will include that software in their repos are nil.
- vbezhenar 8y agoAFAIK there's non-free repo in Debian. Not sure how they compared to main repo in terms of maintaining.
- Twirrim 8y agoI think Debian would keep it around, probably, but it'll be punted out of the main repos and in to the ones designated for non-free software. Impact on the end user will likely be minimal. They'll still be able to apt-get install it as before.
- ploxiln 8y agoThey will probably keep the last version before the license change for a while, and probably add minor community-sourced patches. The next version of ubuntu will include mongdb version "3.6.9+really3.6.8+90~g8e540c0b6d" which you can see means "last commit before the license change"
- sokoloff 8y agoI can foresee the day when that version of MongoDB is advertised/discussed as having "AWS Document DB compatibility" (rather than today's converse).
- lwf 8y agoWe're at 3.4 right now, but there's concern that shipping any non-SSPL-licensed version is unsustainable for the lifetime of a Debian release. See https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=916107 https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=916107
- xellisx 8y agoI had hopes for MongoDB back 10 years ago, but it just let me down. I'm thinking of trying out ArangoDB next. OrientDB is just riddled with bug and their docs are lack luster.
- Twirrim 8y agoWhy not pick a mature database software, learn to use it properly, and just get on with life? Why would you risk _anything_ to immature databases?d
- xellisx 8y agoFor S&Gs.
- threeseed 8y agoIt's a 9 year old database. Can you be more specific about what makes it immature ?
- dsnuh 8y agoPretty sure that they were referring to ArangoDB and OrientDB as being immature, not MongoDB...
- outworlder 8y agoCompared to some other databases out there, MongoDB is a baby. These others... are not even born.
- zymhan 8y ago9 years _is_ immature when you're talking about systems that will store data and operate for decades, with various components being upgraded over that time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- brianwawok 8y ago
- gigatexal 8y agoBut RHEL is not free. So... can’t this be included then only used after the user sets up a license?
- cyphar 8y agoRHEL is free software. It's not free of charge though.
- aurailious 8y agoThe difference is generally not understood on a lot people. Its freedom, not price.
- anticensor 8y agoIt is an issue of English language that cannot cover it. Turkish, my mother tongue, has six counterparts for them: ücretsiz "unpaid", bedava "gratis", hür "unrestricted (person)", özgür "free (freedom)", serbest "unrestricted, accessible (thing)", beleş "price-free (as in, you ought not to expect much out of it)"
- afroboy 8y agoIt's 100% free, you can use CentOS which is identical to RHEL and provided by Redhat.
- TrueDuality 8y agoWhile it's true CentOS is free and exactly the same (minus a few packages that needed to change RHEL to CentOS), RHEL is exclusively a licensed distribution and is a commercial product.
- giancarlostoro 8y ago> RHEL is exclusively a licensed distribution It's still GPL and you still get the full code, hence CentOS. The benefit to licensed RHEL is the support.
- lmm 8y agoI don't see the rationale for their claims that the license is non-free? There's nothing discriminatory on the face of it. Plenty of acknowledgedly free licenses make commercial users uncomfortable (e.g. the AGPL).
- lozenge 8y ago"The freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose" (freedom 0) You can't run it using closed source management software to offer MongoDB as a service.
- lmm 8y agoBy that logic the GPL is also non-free, since you can't run a GPL program embedded in a closed-source management program.
- jerf 8y agoYou own sentence shows the relevant difference: "embedded". The GPL license has always stopped at the OS process boundary. You can essentially do whatever you want with a GPL program as long as you interact with it over standard OS mechanisms, rather than direct modification; you're still obligated to distribute source but it's source that is already publicly available, so there's no proprietary interest in it. Mongo's does not. Neither does the AGPL, to show this isn't new.
- lmm 8y ago> The GPL license has always stopped at the OS process boundary. You can essentially do whatever you want with a GPL program as long as you interact with it over standard OS mechanisms, rather than direct modification Not strictly the case according to the FSF's FAQ; the GPL applies to anything that integrates deeply enough with the covered program to constitute a "derivative work" under copyright law, which is not necessarily the process boundary. > Neither does the AGPL, to show this isn't new. Indeed - so what is RedHat's rationale for permitting AGPL but disallowing this MongoDB license?
- chris_wot 8y agoIMO, MongoDB was suss from the very start. They made claims and overpromised (though I might be a little unfair in that others jumped on this bandwagon more heavily), so removing MongoDB from RHEL is not necessarily a bad thing. Of course, I'm not a MongoDB fan for many, many reasons so I'm quite biased.
- StreamBright 8y agoThe webscale video was our absolute favorite in one of Amazon's systems engineering team for a long time.
- sokoloff 8y agoThat's the case for many engineering teams. For those who haven't seen it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2F-DItXtZs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2F-DItXtZs
- NeoBasilisk 8y agostill one of my favorites
- tpaschalis 8y agoWell, distros will follow through. One such example could be the rise of `systemd`; once it was adopted by Fedora/RHEL it was game over for `init`.
- acdha 8y agoThat's a somewhat different situation: they take different levels of purity test on licensing (not to mention falling under different legal considerations depending on where the developers reside) but adding or removing Mongo has little ripple effect for anyone who doesn't use it. If they don't ship it, the people who were using it will switch to Mongo's main YUM repo and nobody else will notice. In contrast, changing the init system affects every package which runs a daemon and systemd does more than most of the alternatives so supporting multiple init systems is a substantial amount of extra work which is unlikely to attract corresponding volunteer assistance or result in any user-visible benefits.
- tpaschalis 8y agoWell, yes, you're very much right on that regard, and as others mentioned, the 'official installation instructions' were always using Mongo's official repo, so it's a different case. But I still feel that Red Hat has pull with the Linux industry, and others might make their decisions based on "what's RHEL up to".
- kbenson 8y ago> others might make their decisions based on "what's RHEL up to". Looking at systemd from one angle might lead one to think that, but I viewed it from a different angle. It's obvious from the different distros that have replaced the SysVinit system that they were looking for something it wasn't providing. Systemd apparently provided enough of those capabilities to be viewed favorably by some distros, or they looked at the extra capabilities and decided that even if they didn't like aspects of it, it was important to support them to compete. I'm sure Redhat did evangelize it, but I doubt it went along the lines of "hey, we're Redhat, you want to be doing what we're doing." Instead I think it was more like "Hey, we built this cool new thing. Let me tell you about all the new things it has to offer, and how it solves these problems you've had."
- merlynn 8y agoMichael from MongoDB here... Greed? You realize that anyone can still view, download, use, develop, modify and do everything they could do prior to the change - right? The only difference is that if they decide to offer the licensed software as a public service they must release the other components of the service under the same license.
- antt 8y ago>It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it. I'd say I'm surprised that some people are attacking your license, which overall forces providers to increase user freedom, but I remember the 90s and 00s when the GPL/AGPL was being attacked as a non-free (as in freedom) license - "How can it respect freedom when it FORCES me to release my source code?" The same people today go on about how great the CC licenses are when they have the NC-SA, which I've been using for my artistic projects since it came out. Do you have a Stallman like wall of text about defending users freedoms? Because there are enough people who would read it and understand what you're doing once they get past the FUD of "It's proprietary!!!".
- FireBeyond 8y agoBecause such things are "necessary" when it provides benefit: access to software/CC stock photography/imagery/fonts. And less so when it impinges on the ability to make profit from it (leaving aside the argument about "no-one says you can't make money from open source software" - of course you can, but the business model is a little less... convenient... so they fault the license, not anything else).
- sieabahlpark 8y agoThanks for finally giving Amazon the kick it needed to implement your API. We finally don't have to manage a mongodb cluster anymore.
- merlynn 8y agoI suppose but it might be interesting to note that you didn't have to wait for Amazon for that. A lot of people don't know that there exists a fully managed offering from MongoDB. It's called Atlas... not trying to sell here - just informing people that may read your comment and think it was a valid motivation for Amazon to create their DocumentDB offering. Atlas has existed for 2 years.
- brazzledazzle 8y agoI’ll never understand why we collectively wag our fingers at individuals or companies that try to keep the likes of Amazon from building a profitable service off of their hard work then contribute back little-to-nothing. Would redis, mongodb and dgraph have even considered alternate licensing if companies like Amazon had thrown them a minuscule amount of funding and patches? We can’t know because they didn’t. And then we sneer at them for having the audacity to try to stay open but stop these giants from using them and throwing them away. This kind of aggressive behavior toward these people trying to stop their own destruction at the hands of the biggest and most profitable companies in the world makes me wonder what the hell is wrong with our industry. This could easily be any of us. It might be any of us in the future. What do we gain by consolidating control in 3-4 different giants? What are we achieving with such a black and white view of what constitutes open source or not?
- kodablah 8y agoPeople are tired of restrictions, regardless of whether they are the ones targeted. The behavior is not aggressive in any sense and these types of restrictions are worked around predictably. You are making the mistake of confusing the intent of the changes with the reality as though the opposers favor the giants. In reality, something free for everyone might be misused and that's ok because of the size of the benefits. Free software needs to stop trying to pick and choose winners, because what they want to happen rarely does.
- 013a 8y agoThe bigger concern should be that databases like MongoDB and Redis are part of an older breed. The newest databases, built to handle the most demanding load, like DynamoDB, Aurora, or CloudSpanner, are intimately tied to the cloud providers they're deployed on, for legitimately necessary reasons. As the world gets more complex and demanding, this old model of "I've got a server, lets put a database on it" just doesn't scale, even including these "web scale" NoSQL databases like MongoDB. No one beside AWS (or Google or Microsoft) is even capable of building databases to meet these new challenges. For now. Cost plays into this as well. DocumentDB is so cheap because it is built on the Aurora storage engine, which in turn is intimately tied to the infrastructure. MongoDB Atlas can't compete with that. They have to charge you more because they can still point to the servers that your database is running on. An Aurora database might be spread across a dozen different servers and services within AWS, taking up just bits and pieces of processing on each; the parts of Aurora that need lots of storage are on machines optimized for that, the parts that need compute are on machines optimized for that, they're all connected with terabits of networking, and those pennies of savings turn into hundreds of dollars at scale which they can pass on to their customers. Google did the SAME THING years ago with Cloud Memorystore, which exposes a Redis API. Microsoft did the same thing with CosmosDB, which exposes a MongoDB API (among others). Why? Its because the fundamental tech that MongoDB built isn't good. MongoDB is so unbelievably uninteresting to Amazon. Why would they even want to contribute back to it? If they adopted MongoDB wholesale, they and their customers would be worse-off for it. The only people that would win is MongoDB. But they are interested in the API, because that's what their customers are using. The license is a red herring. The real reason Amazon did this is the tech. They now have the Aurora storage engine and DynamoDB, which they can put any API they want on top of and it'll be cheaper, more performant, more resilient to failure, and easier to scale than taking "Database of the month X", throwing it on an EC2 instance, and calling it Managed. And the reason why we're seeing this centralization is because Amazon made the investment in Infrastructure while MongoDB just wanted to build a cool database. Didn't Alan Kay warn us that if you care about the software, you have to care about the hardware? Did we really believe that this only applies to consumer experiences? Amazon didn't. And that's why they're winning.
- kemitchell 8y agoThank you for linking to the e-mail from Tom Callaway.