2 ms·
>First, thin air alone doesn’t fully explain the cognitive deficits observed in mountain climbers, since the Kilimanjaro group fared worse than the altitude cha
by trhway 8y ago
>First, thin air alone doesn’t fully explain the cognitive deficits observed in mountain climbers, since the Kilimanjaro group fared worse than the altitude chamber group.
they should have made the chamber group doing heavy weight-lifting and treadmill running in the chamber (with thermostat set to -40 degrees) and i bet the results would be very close.
>And second, fatigue from prolonged exercise doesn’t explain the difference, since the ski touring group didn’t show any negative effects.
if anything, cross-country skiing pumps you up with energy and overall great feeling. Your brain works even better after that, and even of you get very tired, it isn't really a fatigue like you get during even modest mountain hiking (did Shasta once and it was pretty tough for me even just a bit beyond 4km - you feel really slow and remembering some stuff later with friends - happen to be more stupid than usual too). They should have tested super-marathon of 100mi instead of cross-country skiing.
The article somehow dances around obvious - oxygen insufficiency (like at high altitude) which naturally gets aggravated by heavy physical activity/exercise as well as cold which at the altitude slows down body energy production while taking its significant share of produced energy (at high altitudes there is also some effect that digesting food isn't energy efficient anymore or something like this).
Any one factor alone that they tested - like the chamber - may just not be enough to hit the threshold where oxygen insufficiency (more precisely - resulting balance of energy production and consumption in the body) starts to affect the brain. Especially given that our body prioritizes oxygen delivery to the brain (just look at the blood vessels diagram).
- tim333 8y agoI climbed Kili with an upmarket, catering to old rich folk, tour operator and they made a big deal about going very slowly and not getting out or breath. They said that way about 99% of people including unfit tourists can make the top whereas if you go fast a lot get sick. It was a bit frustrating going at a pace where you could have used a zimmer frame but it seemed to work.