5 ms·
It’s not a Supra. It’s not even a Toyota. It’s an ok BMW. Nothing that makes the Supra appealing or especially elevated it to legendary car culture status is
by mulmen 8y ago
It’s not a Supra. It’s not even a Toyota. It’s an ok BMW. Nothing that makes the Supra appealing or especially elevated it to legendary car culture status is true of this new “Supra”. It’s extremely disappointing and a slap in the face to any fan of true Toyota sports cars.
Akio Toyoda claims to be a “car guy” but after the massive disappointment of the FR-S and Scion in general it is clear he’s entirely clueless.
Toyota is a disappointing shell of itself, this car is another example in a long line of soulless non-Toyota letdowns.
- voltagex_ 8y agoThe BRZ has been a big hit over in Australia (at least from the sheer number of them I see around) - is it just the FR-S and Scion re-badges that are the issue?
- mulmen 8y agoThe BR-Z is a fantastic car, don’t get me wrong. I totally love them. It’s just not a Toyota. It’s a Subaru.
- ako 8y agoThe subaru BRZ and toyota scion/ft86/gt86 are apparently the same car: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_86 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_86 How can the subaru BRZ be a fantastic car, when the toyota scion is not?
- RickS 8y agoI believe this is a statement about who gets credit, not quality difference between models. They're the same car. But, in the eyes of the comment you're replying to, subaru is responsible for the engineering decisions that make it great.
- mulmen 8y agoThe Toyota Scion is not a car. The Scion FR-S/Subaru BR-Z is a fine car, it just isn’t a Toyota. As I said, it’s a Subaru. Scion was a failed marketing ploy that betrays Toyota’s deep misunderstanding of the youth market.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoSubaru fans will say it's not a Subaru as it's RWD. It's really a bastard child of Toyota and Subaru. I've actually never heard anyone in New Zealand (where they're also very popular, as the Toyota 86) complain about it being a "Subaru". I think that badge engineering (i.e. putting a Toyota badge on a Subaru or a BMW) isn't looked down upon so much over here, as it's been commonplace for decades.
- tjr225 8y agoBut for the non-car enthusiast, Toyota still dominates. Its almost a multigenerational "meme" in my family to buy Toyota. So, while they might be pissing off the niche enthusiast community, they're still winning for people who want an affordable, dependable car, which is most people. That said it is a bit disappointing.
- mulmen 8y agoSure but what does that have to do with the Supra? Why even bother releasing this? It’s an objectively bad car. It’s not a halo car because none of it is Toyota. At least when you buy a Chevy Bolt you can tell yourself it’s from the same people who make the Corvette. This is just a rebranded BMW. It’s like Toyota is rubbing in the fact they only make bland toasters.
- Cookingboy 8y ago>It’s an objectively bad car. How is it an objectively bad car? Have you driven it? All the early impressions are quite positive and you can argue however you want it not being a Supra (it's also much cheaper than the old A80), but you literally cannot call it objectively bad without actually mentioning why. It looks good inside out, is priced reasonably, seems to have a good chassis tuning and is fairly quick with a great engine, so what's wrong with it?
- tjr225 8y agoI'm not speaking of the Supra - only of the claim that Toyota is a shell of its former self. I don't think the Toyota is bad, and I think they're doing quite well at what they're good at, even if it pisses car enthusiasts, such as myself or yourself, off.
- mulmen 8y agoToyota is a shell of its former self because it stopped building interesting cars. They’re fine appliances but it’s nothing like the madness they were managing to pull off in the 90s.
- Sendotsh 8y agoI've been a huge Toyota fan since the late 80s. I've owned multiple 1970s Corollas, 80s and 90s Celicas, Hiluxes, the list goes on. All the way up to mid 2000s. This Supra is an abomination. They go on about how it's "for the fans", which just rubs it in even worse. If they'd just made a bigger 86 with a turbo V6 I would've put money down the minute they took preorders. Instead I'm just upset that they absolutely destroyed the name of one of the most iconic cars of my generation by outsourcing it to BMW and whitelabeling a boring overpriced midlife crisis car. Every single Toyota car nut I know is insulted, and you just have to look at ANY car forum to see how badly this entire thing is being received. For most people, a car is the second biggest possession in their life after a house. For many it's THE biggest possession. It's not unfair for people to be attached to brands they've grown up with, and cars they've worked their asses off and poured literally blood sweat and tears into. Look how upset people are over a missing headphone jack. Now imagine if the iPhone 11 was a rebadged Android phone made entirely by Samsung with an Apple sticker on the back, not even running iOS. Toyota really screwed this one.
- Cookingboy 8y ago>Every single Toyota car nut I know is insulted, and you just have to look at ANY car forum to see how badly this entire thing is being received. I don't know, it's fairly well received on Reddit, and I personally like it even though I'm a big fan of the A80 Supra. Let's be honest, enthusiasts are never happy about anything, they all want something that's 500hp that also weights 2000lbs and comes straight from the factory with the price of a 3 years old used Miata. Is this the same type of car as the A80 Supra? Of course not, but all signs pointing toward it being a quite promising sports car, and all the early reviews are quite positives as well. The kind of people who make the loudest noise on the forums aren't the type who would be putting money down buying a new $80k GT-R caliber Supra anyway. For $50k starting price, you get a good looking 2 seater that's relatively light, agile, 4.1s 0-60 and very nicely equipped with the latest BMW cabin tech and Toyota styling, I think this thing will sell like hotcakes.
- rasz 8y agoAnd BMW Z4 is a car for those people. Looking at the sale numbers says it all, people you cite as enthusiastic about it dont buy cars.
- outericky 8y agoMiata M4?
- toomanybeersies 8y agoFundamentally Toyota (and most other car manufacturers) is a company that sells cars to people to use for commuting and other day to day business. Sports cars are just a marketing tool. Toyota makes their money selling the Hilux and the Corolla, not the 86 or the Supra. And the Hilux and Corolla are as good as ever (well, nothing will ever beat the 90's Hiluxes)