3 ms·
You ask if the patent is valid; Concisely, if it has been granted, then yes, it is valid. The question of whether it should have been granted in the first plac
by ineedasername 8y ago
You ask if the patent is valid; Concisely, if it has been granted, then yes, it is valid.
The question of whether it should have been granted in the first place is much more complex and, now granted, irrelevant unless/until it is challenged in some way.
It should be noted that even seemingly obvious prior art may not actually invalidate a patent, even with judicial review, because the aspects of a patent that make it "novel" can be subtle. For example, pharmaceutical companies frequently gain extra patent extra for a drug by patenting an "extended release" version. It would seem therefore that an "extended release" drug is now an obvious innovation, and not patent-able. However, the specific mechanisms by which a given chemical compound can be made to extent its release often vary significantly.
That said, patents that follow the pattern of "doing mundane task X, but with a computer" have often been held as obvious and therefore not eligible to receive a patent. This particular patent may follow that pattern. Though again, there may be subtle aspects of novelty here that aren't apparent from a cursory review.
- dv_dt 8y agoPatent extension generics through the years: with a computer with the internet with a mobile app (drugs) with optimized release and, predicted: with an AI decision.
- neodypsis 8y agoIf I understand correctly, they're claiming using a Bluetooth beacon workflow as their novelty, but they also mention the QR code scanning workflow as an alternative implementation. This last workflow is exactly the one shown in the linked video (dated 2013).