4 ms·
This is really curious. Are there any systems that govern well that don’t recognize democratic principles? I’m trying to figure out how the U.K. can make decis
by prepend 8y ago
This is really curious. Are there any systems that govern well that don’t recognize democratic principles?
I’m trying to figure out how the U.K. can make decisions given that very few will have a literal majority given that there are so many non-voters (eg, babies and comatose).
What is a better form of determining the will of the people than an election?
In the US there is a constitution so huge changes can’t be made by referendum. Would the U.K. adapt a system like that? And how could they if it required 50.1% of every soul in the U.K. to vote for it?
- toomuchtodo 8y agoDefine "govern well". Is that where the will of the people is aligned as closely as possible to public policy and government action? Is it where their quality of life is most improved regardless of their desires? It's a hard question to answer. China governs very well as an autocracy, if I had to measure by the quality of life of its citizens. Yes, their will is not expressed through representation, but China has done more than any other nation or company to pull an enormous amount of humans out of poverty in a short amount of time. They have traded a reduction in representation and exerted will for a reduction in suffering. It's a similar thought exercise to "What is success?" I cannot answer your question unfortunately.
- prepend 8y agoI think I agree with your definition, but it’s pretty hard to know the true will of the people. My ideal state is where the government executed the will of the people in spirit but not in letter. (Ie, people want heroin literally but happiness and freedom in spirit)
- mullingitover 8y ago> This is really curious. Are there any systems that govern well that don’t recognize democratic principles? The United States has two branches of Congress to insulate the country from the whims of the mob. Pure democracy has long been derided as an anti-pattern in government.