3 ms·
> The risk for regulation has passed as citizens see AirBnB as an accepted reality. Hotels aren't happy, but rightfully see AirBnB as a competitor. I agree wit
by jedberg 8y ago
> The risk for regulation has passed as citizens see AirBnB as an accepted reality. Hotels aren't happy, but rightfully see AirBnB as a competitor.
I agree with your overall, but I'm not so sure I agree with this part.
South Lake Tahoe just passed a voter initiative in November that bans AirBnB (and VRBO) except for a few places right next to the major hotels. It was, not surprisingly, heavily supported by the major hotels.
- zaroth 8y agoI was just reading about this. Looks like the measure barely squeaked by (less than 1 percent margin) and parts of it are on hold pending a lawsuit. I’m very conflicted about these types of bans. I have an apartment which I share with extended family, and we share the costs. Technically the way these bans are written would prevent us from doing that without somehow getting everyone’s name of the lease which would not be practical. I wish that people would fine heavily for actual bad behavior, and let fair economic arrangements between respectful parties happen. But I also understand that enforcement is very difficult, and most people are assholes.
- the_watcher 8y agoSouth Lake Tahoe is exactly the kind of market that OP isn't talking about (if I'm reading it correctly). There are tons of places where hotels simply aren't dominant. A good framing for me: If Airbnb were just looking to compete with hotels, this wouldn't be that exciting of a business, even if I knew they could survive. What's exciting about Airbnb is that they're looking to win in places that hotels aren't.
- jedberg 8y agoYes and no. There are three big hotels, but VRBO and AirBnB have been the dominant way to get housing in Tahoe forever, unless you're a gambler.
- the_watcher 8y agoThat can be true at the same time that "winning markets like South Lake Tahoe aren't the markets most critical to their growth" is true.
- _delirium 8y agoWashington DC also passed a partial ban a few months ago: https://dc.curbed.com/2018/11/15/18095658/dc-airbnb-regulations-short-term-rentals-council https://dc.curbed.com/2018/11/15/18095658/dc-airbnb-regulati... Under the new rules, you can only rent out your primary residence that you actually live in (not second homes/condos), and you can only do that for up to 90 days a year. That'll remove a pretty large percentage of the AirBnB inventory if it's enforced, since a lot of units on AirBnB are investment properties used purely to rent out, not anyone's primary residence.
- rconti 8y agoPacific Grove, too. I was just staying in an AirBnB in PG in October. Signs in yards opposing "measure M" which turned out to be an initiative to "keep Pacific Grove a community"... which means no short-term rentals.