4 ms·
Honestly, a google home or something similar seems to be the right way to go - while it's not "secure", it's incredibly intuitive, can't be misplaced, and has m
by SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
Honestly, a google home or something similar seems to be the right way to go - while it's not "secure", it's incredibly intuitive, can't be misplaced, and has most of the functionality you'll need, and I imagine as time passes it'll develop a lot of the rest.
- notahacker 8y agoThe elderly are certainly the natural use case for voice interfaces and IoT services, since they're a group of people that often find basic household tasks and using a GUI and handheld interface genuinely difficult. I think there's an enormous market there for the right products. But I suspect the mobility-impaired and the lonely-and-bored are more easily served than those with declining cognitive functions. Once people have reached the stage where they're starting to not recognise people or remember what year it is, [re]discovering a disembodied voice in their living room that sometimes answers questions intelligibly and/or does what they ask of it could be a bit disturbing. The UX problem is much harder than simply ensuring the service doesn't make buggy recommendations, and not an easy one to test.
- crooked-v 8y ago> Once people have reached the stage where they're starting to not recognise people or remember what year it is, [re]discovering a disembodied voice in their living room that sometimes answers questions intelligibly and/or does what they ask of it could be a bit disturbing. On the other hand, there are people who exist now who will, in old age, have had helpful (but occasionally stupid) disembodied computer voices around since childhood.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoYeah, I was framing it in my mind as helping my own senility. There's not a lot of helping the tech illiterate current elderly - even google home requires a little bit of mental framing as far as commands are concerned.
- notahacker 8y agoTrue, but they're not the main market. And I don't think the main problem is that elderly people have never been familiar with the idea of a disembodied voice; radio's been around since before everyone was born. I think it's that (i) it's not necessarily smart or human enough to persuade someone with declining mental functions that it has their best interests at heart and (ii) one of the more distressing aspects of talking to someone with declining cognitive function is that their perception of the day and their problems are often filled with conversations they didn't have (or didn't have in the last decade). Putting a machine into the equation which conceivably could have been responsible for "John told me NOT to take my pills" or "someone keeps asking me for money" makes untangling this more difficult for family, as well as something the machine itself can't handle (though I suppose smart devices with logging and "rewind/replay" functions are a lot better than telephones with scam callers in that respect)
- sk5t 8y agoI think this comment hits the mark; making a voice assistant to help a nonagenarian who thinks it's time to get ready for school, or to send out invitations for a long-ago child's birthday party, is a distinct challenge.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoI had a similar thought and got my grandmother an Amazon Echo. It's been ok but not great. Part of why we got it for her is because her eyesight is failing I thought it'd be easier for her to make calls by just saying someone's name. However Amazon makes it very hard for people that don't have cell phones— before you can make calls you have to type in a code that they'll send you in an SMS message. Since my grandma doesn't have a cell phone, only a landline, that wasn't doable. I had amazon text the code to my phone. She can call people via Alexa now, but the caller ID on their end shows up as my phone number instead of hers. It confuses the hell out of people she calls (including me, when I see that I'm getting a call from myself!) I think older people who aren't fluent in the use of search engines also have a harder time making voice queries that the assistants can understand. She'll sometimes throw in extra information that isn't necessary for her question/command which throws off the results. Although it is adorable when she says "Good morning Alexa, would you please tell me what time it is?" instead of just "Alexa, what time is it?"
- devereaux 8y agoCaller ID is configurable with many VOIP services, so it's just an oversight by Amazon. Simple workaround idea: is it possible to have amazon text a google voice number (or equivalent) set in her name, and redirecting to her landline?
- karmakaze 8y agoThis sounds terrifying. I can't imagine what it would be like to depend on something in my daily routine, then have some minor automatic update change the way it works so I don't know how to do anything anymore with no way of going back or relearning how to do things. Unless there's a device specifically targeting the elderly and their priorities AND you're confident that that business model will survive for your lifetime, I couldn't recommend it. It's fine to have it be one of the ways you do things but don't put most of your eggs in that basket.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> I can't imagine what it would be like to depend on something in my daily routine, then have some minor automatic update change the way it works so I don't know how to do anything anymore with no way of going back or relearning how to do things. Yeah, really, at the end of the day no device has that guarantee.
- gegtik 8y agoFor xmas i got my grandfather a google home hub purely to serve as a digital picture frame so I can send him pics of my family easily. Talked to my dad today, it's been unplugged because my granddad is worried that satellites are taking his picture and showing it to him, and he doesn't dare use any voice commands. Turns out it was a poor gift. I wonder what kind of creepy shit my kids' kids will try to pawn off on me.