9 ms·
EU Copyright Directive is a catastrophe for free expression and competition
- TadaScientist 8y agoOk, so what can those of us not in Sweden, Germany, Poland or Belgium do?
- sethherr 8y agoGo to the article. Click on the button for your country to take action.
- TadaScientist 8y agoyou might want to read my question again - I am not a citizen of these countries.
- lixtra 8y agoRTFA: > If you live in the rest of Europe: please contact the ministers working on the Copyright in the Digital Single Market directive. We'll update this page with more information as we get it.
- diminoten 8y agoWhat about those of us who don't live in Europe?
- cft 8y agoBlock EU IPs if you are running a niche service with UGC. EU internet is cable TV basically now + illegal stuff outside of law enforcement reach
- ucaetano 8y agoAre you asking how can you influence law making in a country that you're not a citizen of?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- diminoten 8y agoYes, because it effects me, and I am morally opposed to this position.
- goto11 8y agoYou contact your country's foreign intelligence agency.
- Kalium 8y agoOr foreign trade representative agency. There are above-board ways to handle this too.
- yzb 8y agoEFF, keep your paws off Europe.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kodablah 8y agoAction was already taken when large-scale government interference of the internet was cheered on in the past. Since taking the bad with the good of a less-regulated internet wasn't acceptable, we now have to take the bad with the good of a more-regulated internet. Ideally we could have nuance where things work the way they're intended and overreach of power to add legislation wasn't continually leveraged. But reality has shown us it doesn't work that way.
- umvi 8y agoRight to be Forgotten, GDPR, and now this... pretty soon the barrier to entry will be so high that no new players would be able to get off the ground with an internet company in Europe.
- kowdermeister 8y agoI want to open a i-shirt store and I'm in the EU. None of these will prevent me. Edit: typo... t-shirt
- fuscy 8y agoI have no idea what i-shirt is but it's likely that if an user uses copyrighted material for his i-shirt, you'll have to pay because it's your platform. Bonus points for not using a censorship filter in trying to do this.
- diminoten 8y agoAsk him again about censorship in the EU when his most popular shirt is "Hitler did nothing wrong" or some other such nonsense.
- kowdermeister 8y agoNo UGC will be allowed and the text you add will not be displayed anywhere :)
- nothis 8y agoTry an i-Twitter or an i-Facebook.
- LoSboccacc 8y agovery innovative. meanwhile this will likely cost a lot to qwertee
- oldboyFX 8y agoIt almost seems like we're hell bent on suffocating what little amount of innovation we have left.
- mc32 8y agoIt's alarming that there appears to be no provision for fair use of copyrighted materials. I'm not in the EU, but that would seem to be a grave oversight. One can imagine an image or any copyrightable material which might become offensive or embarrassing might get copyrighted so as to in effect censor the material.
- Ygg2 8y agoI'd be surprised, if this whole situation didn't already happen with Youtube and DMCA (I know the real law does leave such provisions but current system of DMCA takedowns is still used in this manner).
- pas 8y agoHm, well, education is an exception already, but political speech and comedy are not enumerated as exceptions. (Though I guess these things will be decided by the Courts eventually, as the Directive is about proportional remuneration). Also, the proposal leaves intact other Directives, and it'll take a bit of work to figure out if all of these are in harmony, or if there's a conflict between the rules. (And if there which one prevails.) "Except in the cases referred to in Article 6, this Directive shall leave intact and shall in no way affect existing rules laid down in the Directives currently in force in this area, in particular Directives 96/9/EC, 2001/29/EC, 2006/115/EC, 2009/24/EC, 2012/28/EU and 2014/26/EU." for example 2001/29/EC is the WIPO copyright treaty [ratification] directive, which already protects political speech and parody/caricature. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Directive#Exceptions_and_limitations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Directive#Exceptions... )
- Silhouette 8y agoThere is no direct equivalent in EU law to the general "fair use" provisions in the US. Indeed, the US provisions are somewhat controversial, because arguably they don't meet the requirements of the main umbrella international agreements for intellectual property. The closest equivalent in Europe would be something like the fair dealing provisions here in England and their counterparts in other member states, but those tend to enumerate specific scenarios where copying may be lawful without the permission of the copyright holder, rather than the US approach of specifying a small number of general principles and leaving it to the courts to resolve any specific case.
- lbj 8y agoI wonder whyI always get downvoted into oblivion for stating that which to me is an obvious fact: The EU is too far removed from reality to legislate. It now has a long and sordid history of over-doing things to the extreme. In Denmark, we've had 'cinnamon patrols' go from bakery to bakery to verify that only the allowed amount of cinnamon was sprinkled on buns. We had what felt like a complete shutdown of IT departments in the months leading up to the GDPR because, again, it was overreaching and too vague. (the idea was good though) I could write a list much longer, but in general I think the Unix approach works: Many small things that each do one thing well. The EU is the opposite: One giant thing which does nothing well - If for no other reason, than the distance from the Parliament to a wooden cabin on the mountains of norway is just too great for them to regulate that cabin in great detail, but still this is what they attempt to do. And now, down to each word on each and every webpage accesible from the EU.
- chosenbreed37 8y ago> In Denmark, we've had 'cinnamon patrols' go from bakery to bakery to verify that only the allowed amount of cinnamon was sprinkled on buns. Is this for real? I know it's anecdotal but I find it hilarious > I could write a list much longer, but in general I think the Unix approach works: Many small things that each do one thing well. The EU is the opposite: One giant thing which does nothing well Well...I'm sure many could point out somethings that the EU has done well...I guess at the heart of regulating cinnamon buns is the issue of standards...that specific instance is probably an overkill but having a common standard of electrical equipment produced/imported to the EU makes sense...at the very least you could argue that some member states have benefited considerably although that may not necessarily be attributable to EU policy
- lbj 8y agoYeah I'm afraid the example is quite real. But sure, example could be dug up of good things the EU have done. But even in those cases the cost is much too great. For instance, they built a really nice hallway at the Parliament, but when it came time to name it, they assigned 76 diplomats and the president of the EU to work through the name. That alone ended up costing something like 11 million euros. I can't think of anything they've done, which hasn't resulted in millions of taxpayers money being poured down the drain. Not surprisingly, the EU has the lowest growth rate in the world.
- BlackFly 8y agoI wish that the EFF would include links to the updated directive. The latest I can find is the language as of 2018-05-25 (http://www.consilium.europa.eu/media/35373/st09134-en18.pdf http://www.consilium.europa.eu/media/35373/st09134-en18.pdf) which doesn't contain the terms "commercial platforms", "news site" or link. It does leave the definition of "unsubstantial parts" up to member states, which is indeed worrying from a single market perspective. Furthermore, that wording contradicts EFF's assertion for article 13 that unlicensed content is not allowed to appear, "even for an instant." Since all that is needed to avoid liability is to perform effective and proportionate efforts to prevent availability and to react expeditiously upon notification. Proportionality and effectiveness explicitly depend on the size of the content provider: a new streaming video service would explicitly need to do less than YouTube. Has the updated documentation explicitly removed the provision about expeditious action upon notification? Because the exception proves the rule (the rule being that unlicensed content is indeed allowed to appear for more than an instant). So... links to spam commissioners but no links to verify that EFF is presenting a fair reading of the updated documents.
- dmitriid 8y agoThis is a much better update: https://juliareda.eu/2019/01/article-13-almost-finished/ https://juliareda.eu/2019/01/article-13-almost-finished/ It describes the changes and why they will/will not work
- BlackFly 8y agoThat is indeed. Thank you for that. Instead of requiring filtering on behalf of rightsholders that refuse to license to platforms (an asymmetric relationship that just increases costs for one party), I wish that the EU would legislate FRAND style royalties. As in, if you want copyright protection then you have to issue Fair, Reasonable And Non-Discriminatory licenses to any platform that may want to host the content. Don't want to issue such a license? Then the EU won't help you protect your work. In that way a platform could just host the content using a central database and performing deduplication instead of using the same central database to forbid viewing. Rightsholders would get royalties by virtue of the license agreement, EU would spend less money policing copyright since there would be many more legal avenues to access content.
- tway111 8y agoAnd they call us V4 countries anti-european and backwards-thinking. I guess the western Europe is in for its own taste of full blown totalitarian socialism.
- agigao 8y agoThis one I do like. People could diverge from consumption of “data deluge”, and return back in time when we used to have meaningful conversations on a private forums created around a very concrete ideas other than feeding society with ads.
- cronix 8y agoTo get around the linking to news sites problem, couldn't search engines just not provide ANY links to news sites? Who defines what a "news" site is? Is there a strict definition? Anybody with a website? If it's something I have not read or known before, it's "news" to me no matter how old or from where.
- sobani 8y agoThat's what Google did in Germany when a "have a contract with news sites" law went into effect. It didn't take long before Google got free access to all German news sites. Spain learned from this and make a minimum compensation mandatory. Since then Google News hasn't been available in Spain. So now they're making a third attempt to make Google pay for sending business to news site. The result will probably be the same though.