I'm sad that I had to read so far down the thread to find this comment, which beautifully cuts right through the argument. The problem is the idea of absolute

I'm sad that I had to read so far down the thread to find this comment, which beautifully cuts right through the argument. The problem is the idea of absolute knowledge -- knowledge is probabilistic and contextual. If I'm driving by the field in a car, I may be duped by the cow, but my perception that I'm surrounded by pasture land is more than adequate to support the activity of driving. If on the other hand, I'm Farmer Jones and I'm searching my pasture for Susie the cow, well, I'm not going to be taken in by a statue of a cow for more than a split second anyway.