3 ms·
>> He called them “gettiers” for short. So we used to talk about gettiers all the time, no doubt in part just because it felt clever to talk about them, but als
by phkahler 8y ago
>> He called them “gettiers” for short. So we used to talk about gettiers all the time, no doubt in part just because it felt clever to talk about them, but also because when you’re a programmer, you run into things that feel like Gettier cases with unusual frequency.
Sometimes I think that is what philosophers are doing - feeling clever - perhaps as a defense against some negative inner problem (psychology is an outgrowth of philosophy after all). The whole cow story stinks of telling someone "you're right, but you're also WRONG! Your perception of reality is BROKEN!". To me knowledge is simply having a model of the world that can be used to make useful predictions and communicate (and some other things). Aside from that, it doesn't matter if your model is "grounded in reality" until it fails to work for you, at which time it can be helpful to realize your knowledge (model) needs adjustment.
One way to resolving the authors first software issue would be to check a diff between what he committed and the previous production revision - this would quickly uncover the changes he "didn't make". This is an old lesson for me - what I changed may not be limited to what I think I changed. It's a lesson in "trust but verify". There are any number of ways to view it, but in the end we only care about ways that lead to desired outcomes weather they're "right" or not.
On a related note, I've found that software is one of the only places where there is a "ground truth" that can be examined and understood in every detail. It's completely deterministic (given a set of common assumptions). I've found the real world - and people in particular - to not be like that at all.
- ozy 8y agoExactly, one ontology of knowledge is: pointers (names), categories (matchers/recognizers), models (descriptions of systems). The first two have all the problems philosophers talk about. But the last one does not. Not even underdeterminism, unless the system of the model is fundamental or fades into history or is a "wicked" problem.
- thejohnconway 8y ago> Sometimes I think that is what philosophers are doing - feeling clever - perhaps as a defense against some negative inner problem (psychology is an outgrowth of philosophy after all). All science is an outgrowth of philosophy. It's very frustrating when people look the obviously trivial and sometimes silly examples that philosophers use to elucidate a problem, and take it to mean that they are interested in trivial and silly things. Being right for the wrong reasons is a common and difficult problem, and some if the solutions to it a really insightful and powerful ideas. > Aside from that, it doesn't matter if your model is "grounded in reality" until it fails to work for you, at which time it can be helpful to realize your knowledge (model) needs adjustment. It might matter a great deal if your model is not grounded in reality - there are situations where that can kill you. It also seems like one of the fundamental aims of science, to have theories fail less often.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]