3 ms·
That's not quite true: we do know how to make large, complex, highly reliable programs. It's just that in most cases, no-one cares enough to pay what it costs.
by gaius 16y ago
That's not quite true: we do know how to make large, complex, highly reliable programs.
It's just that in most cases, no-one cares enough to pay what it costs. You either have to be extremely high profile (e.g. the Space Shuttle) or doing huge volume (think of a CPU as simply a Verilog program) to make it worthwhile. Would you pay 10x as much for a word processor or web browser that never, ever crashed? Would you pay 100x?
- steveklabnik 16y agoThe problem with the space shuttle example is that it has incredibly limited scope. Yes, we could build a large program to exacting specifications, but once they change, all bets are off. The space shuttle software doesn't need to adapt over time. And you're right, it is incredibly expensive... but even in my example, that just moves us forward to the Roman Empire, or something. People know how to build an aquaduct, but only the most excessive society on the face of the planet can afford it.
- gaius 16y agoBut if we're sticking with the civil engineering analogy, a road is not built in 1-week sprints with the route potentially changing as requests come in that it link more or different towns. So you have to compare like with like.
- steveklabnik 16y agoThere's a reason that I said my thoughts are half-baked. ;) Good point.